borghe said:
They are precious about their classic films because they want them to be treasures, not commodities. Today's classic (iron man for example) is tomorrow's $7.99 end cap filler. And what do we think of those $7.99 end cap fillers? Garbage, exactly. Not necessarily in quality, but definitely in that "must-have" sense.
By spacing out the releases, putting them on moratorium, etc, they keep the demand high for these movies. I mean they double dipped on Little Mermaid for example. Do you really think they would have sold as many copies of Little Mermaid had they kept it out for 9 years as they had/have selling it once for a limited time and then rereleasing it 6-7 years later? And let's talk about Sleeping Beauty.. we all know that the mainstream doesn't feel "pushed" to BRD. How pushed do you think Mommy Dearest would be to buy Sleeping Beauty on Blu-ray if it's readily available on DVD?
I don't necessarily agree with how Disney releases and then pulls their movies from distribution, HOWEVER I also completely understand why they do it and no matter what have to admit.... their plan works and is frankly part of the reason that their movies are not only loved, but revered as well.
I understand that, but I still hate it. I think their values are screwed. Given the sheer amount of discs they have, I can't go and a get certain film that I grew up with in any decent quality for a younger relative, and by the time it comes out, they will have outgrown that age.
OK fine Disney needs to look after its treasures sure - but why do you think the Disney brand only holds any relevence for young adults who are all nostalgic now? Kids nowadays don't get much chance to relive the classic fairytales, Disney was a great source for the older generation, but nowdays if you don't read you ain't gonna know what aladdin or snow white is unless an adult force feeds you this old looking film. Some treasures eh. Its not like fairytales go out of fashion - why then do kids nowadays look forward to High School Musical and not give a damn about the "Classics"? Cos Disney is too damn precious about them.
They should be out there entertaining kids and making them dream the way we used to dream - thats how you make these things into treasures, through the hopes and dreams of kids. Ironically it was probably Disney who filled me with that crap in the first place.
I remember enquiring about the Little Mermaid once, back when Beauty and the Beast (I think) got the awesome DVD treatment, but years and years later when TLM came out - I just didnt give a damn anymore. I barely knew it came out.
Pixar have released multiple versions of their films, there are multiple editions of LOTR, books included, does this decrease the value of the DVDs? Yes, does it decrease the sentimental value of the films? Nope.
My sister adores Toy Story because she is surrounded by it, we have multiple editions of the film, some she scratched up beyond repair, some just about work and we'll probably buy another copy soon. Similar for other Pixar films. Thats how you make something into a treasure, what disney are doing is making their archive into antiques which are barely relevent anymore.
Thats years of frustration ladies and gentlemen, I need me some Disney
