Wait, why do people like J Allard? I've never even heard of this guy until now. When I look at his Wiki page, it says he worked on the first Xbox, the Zune, the Kin, and the Courier. That's a horrible track record. Say what you will about Don Mattrick, but he oversaw the Xbox 360 as it witnessed huge growth, increasing profitability, and a highly successful Kinect.
Unless of course you hate Microsoft and want them to lose money and exit the games industry, then yeah, J Allard sounds like a good choice.