alright, these should be all the UNFULFILLED requests up to truly101
Chû Totoro - Last Guardian griffon
DaveKap - Kefka
Eternal_0 - Rock Volnutt or anything from Mega Man Legends
Kodiak - A bear
SailorDaravon - FFVI Tina/Terra
Pseudo_Sam - Michael, with his paint roller from the DVD covers (arrested development)
laserbeam - Super Mario
Jtwo - Dr Ian Malcom (Jurassic Park) OR general Jeff Goldblum
Volcynika - Millia Rage from Guilty Gear OR Jack Frost (MegaTen)
A Link to the Snitch - Rhythm Heaven girl
Jon - Phillie Phanatic
Fredescu - Neil (the young ones)
Victrix - Ninja Gaiden Ryu (8 Bit)
PBalfredo - Flint (mother 3)
krypt0nian - Superman
Maxrpg - His own avatar
Perdew - Shinra
Mashing - Illyria
Forgotten_Taco - A sad clown
GeneralIroh - Zuko OR Uncle Iroh (Avatar the Last Airbender)
Dark Ninja - Link OR Red (pokemon)
HK-47 - HK-47 with a red cape
Keyser Soze - GOB (arrested development)
MetatronM - One Piece crew members
unreon - Umbreon with glowing rings
Firehead - Gordon Freeman or G-Man
Raide - his own avatar
edgefusion - his own avatar
El Pescado - Ghostbusters (Peter OR Ray)
TwinIonEngines - TIE Fighter OR TIE Fighter Pilot
Scalemail Ted - his own avatar
BlueMagic - Guybrush Threepwood.
Wyndstryker - Pyramid Head
D4Danger - Agent 47 (Hitman)
SnakeXs - Link (LTTP)
..pakbeka.. - Mario 2 Phanto Mask + Key
Gamer @ Heart - Shinobi's Hotsuma Preferably holding a glowing sword
TheGreatDave - A flashing Agent Dale Cooper!
Label - Dynamite Heady, preferably with the vacuum head!
Danielsan - Gene from God Hand
evlcookie - Cookie Monster (evil?)
Wheeliedude - Gitaroo Man
Archie - Eddie (Iron Maiden)
Raging Spaniard - Raging Spaniard
ethelred - Lans Tartare (Tactics Ogre) or Demifiend (Nocturne)
LiquidMetal14 - Shiva from FFX
Cat in the Hat - Micheal Jackson
Teetris - Mike Tyson
plank - nih-pah
Ravidrath - Red Mage from FFXI
robochimp - Cyborg Ninja (metal gear solid)
M.J. Doja - Omar, the thug (The Wire)
rzr4 - R2D2/Darth Vader
Nakazato - Hume thf af 1 or Ray Lewis
Lucario - Lucario
Renshi - Ike (Fire Emblem)
dygiT - Altair (assassins creed)
ICallItFutile - Jade (beyond good and evil)
JPBrowncoat - River Tam
Won - something from Starcraft
daCuk - Guy (final fight / street fighter alpha)
Black-Wind - pikachu wearing a mario hat
Kagari - Stella (FF Versus XIII)
Ramirez - Cortana
ZeroGravity - Miyuki (Lucky Star)
louie - Samas Aran
ChazAshley - Chaz Ashley
rataven - Cloud (FF7)
drkOne - Noel from BlazBlue
Y2Kev - Cloud
akachan ningen - Tony Tony Chopper (One Piece)
Jive Turkey - Sexy Asian Toad Girl
Himuro - Laguna Loire.
Linkzg - Gene from God Hand
Jswanko - Bender w/cigar (futurama)
Yazuka - KOS-MOS
Gryphter - Wizard Yuki Nagato from The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
Replicant - Dingo Egret from ZOE2
vectorman06 - Pokemon Red Trainer
Forkball - Link
EmCeeGramr - Metal Man
MidnightScott - Houndoom
oneHeero - white Sackboy
Meier - Joel McHale OR Noel Gallagher
Sidzed2 - Kratos
brlito - his own avatar
Narag - Tyrael (Diablo II)
BudokaiMR2 - Ibuki
Beardz - Alex from River City Ransom
timetokill - Earthworm Jim, in gun pose
AlucarD.eq - baby bart/jesus
Duke Togo - Duke Togo
TurtleSnatcher - El Fuerte
Parallax - toad avatar OR a mark harmon OR david caruso
Bluth54 - 10th Doctor
NameGenerated - Matthew Lesko
FunkyMunkey - Majora's Mask fierce deity link
Firestorm - charmander
Ydahs - Guile from Chrono Cross.
mrklaw - lum
soulhouf - Luffy (One Piece)
TheFreshPrince - Mah Na Mah Na Muppet
Fortinbras - Buffy the Vampire Slayer (in a cool pose)
McBradders - Jill Valentine circa RE1
NintendoGal - Chef Ramsay
ReiGun - ShinkenGold
OokieSpookie - Ash (Evil Dead)
antispin - Duke Nukem
grandjedi6 - Jon Stewart
VAIL - http://i40.tinypic.com/r01t2d.jpg
Costanza - thumbs up Costanza
NeoForte - FFXI Mandragora
bistromathics - face-palming ps3 from castle vidcons Lord PS3
n3ss - Urien (3rd strike) OR Sanji (One Piece)
firehawk12 - female shepard
Red Scarlet - Rise (Persona 4) OR Jessica with the Mystery Bustier OR Penelo (FF12) OR Aigis (Persona 3)
ZROCOOL - Kanada from Akira
Otheradam - Big Daddy (Bioshock)
DrFunk - Snoopy (Joe Cool style, red shirt, sunglasses)
Llyranor - Ray Muzyka
Iron E Man - Alucard
John Harker - BALTHIER from FFXII
SuperSonic1305 - Super Saiyin teen Gohan
Nightz - Soundwave (G1 Transformers)
VaLiancY - TF2 Soldier
Hootie - Kyle Hyde (hotel dusk)
batbeg - Layle (Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles: The Crystal Bearers)
LovingSteam - Larry David (curb your enthusiasm)
Ferrio - Blue Mary
Monroeski - Captain Murphy (Sealab 2021)
Topher - Quinn (Sealab 2021)
Rewrite - his own avatar
Hero - Lenneth Valkyrie from Valkyrie Profile
markot - Star fox doing the 'come on' taunt from smash bros
strange_booj - Joanna Dark
RadioHeadAche - Thom Yorke
Affeinvasion - Deadpool
Vox-Pop - his avatar
Yoboman - MGS2 Snake (cigarette a must) sneaking up on a Gurlukovich soldier.
Cheesemeister - Howard Dean wearing a Cheesehead
Drensch - Adriana Lima
Darunia - Lenny (the simpsons)
mclem - Tier 2 Paladin from WoW
FSLink - Cyclops from the X-Men
Gallagher - Georg Prime
fanboi - his own avatar
Vashu - Vash the Stampede
hidepsyence - Kamina
gynoug - Rise (Persona 4)
Captain N - Captain N
Error - Jack Frost (MegaTen)
Fireflu - any character from Mighty Max (Max, Virgil, Norman, etc) OR either Bucky O'hare OR Jazz Jackrabbit.
TheChillyAcademic - Vexen
Mars - Judith (Tales of Vesperia)
Tytree - Linebeck (Zelda)
Shinobix - Daft Punk duo
Dizzle24 - Dante
ninj4junpei - Jehuty from Zone of the Enders
octopusman - Vyse from Skies of Arcadia
sh4mike - King Arthur (Monty Python)
Zeep - Dark Samus
Kuroyume - his own avatar
lackey - kuroro lucifer from hunter x hunter
Nightz - Soundwave (G1 Transformers)
Killthee - sad wwf panda
Gelry - Metroid
djdac - Shiren the Wanderer
chapel - guy with pikachu doll OR "i has a bucket" walrus
Rimshot - Goemon
Tonza - Yuri Lowell from Tales of Vesperia OR MC from Persona 4
Little Green Yoda - Yoda
Ysiadmihi - Daisy (Mario Strikers)
Fox the Sly - Spike Spiegel
8-Bit Soul - Megan Fox (Transformers)
Blyss - Crash Bandicoot
Alf-Life - Snake Plissken OR Joanna Dark
Princess Skittles - Disney Tinkerbell
Darkflight - Spiderman
BGBW - Captain Falcon
PTCoakley - This gundam
Kobun Heat - Kobun/Servbot
BlueMagic - the guy on the right
neojubei - Anubis (ZOE)
TheHeretic - Max Payne
PacoDG - Mag (katamari cousin)
AndyMoogle - Moogle
DrPirate - Peter Finch from network (1976 movie)
Krelian - Krelian from Xenogears.
Ca1amity - Fallout 3 Brotherhood of Steel Paladin OR Sean Connery as James Bond OR Magneto OR Hydralisk
Cipher - Wrex (Mass Effect)
autobzooty - Ness (OKay! pose)
U K Narayan - Green Dinosaur (Dinosaur Comics)
robut - Gunstar Green/Seven Force
OnPoint - Terminator T-800 (half Arnold/Half Machine)
permutated - Mog
Kletian - Autobot Hound (Transformers)
Hugbot - Grimlock
Dacvak - Mario
ZealousD - Protoss Zealot
aidan - Junpei (Persona 3)
SpiderJerusalem - Supergirl
lbcyalater - Schwarzenegger from Commando
Charron - Bridget
Azih - Raz from Psychonauts
Space Cadet - this guy
LaneDS - Alphonese Elric from Fullmetal Alchemist (as a suit of armor)
Clipper - Ryūta Ippongi from Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan?
whitehawk - cookie monster
RPS37 - Halo ODST Solider
Zel3 - Kizaru (One Piece)
Lkr - Cole Train (Gears of War)
kiryogi - CG style Beryl
Nobiru - Scarlet Spidey
clay_ghost - Gold from Pokemon
beermonkey@tehbias - Frank Zappa (w/ guitar)
bryehn - Brian (family guy)
Grand_Gamer - Worms 3D worm (with uzi)
replayy - Julian Casablancas
3roam - Faith (Mirrors Edge) OR Ezio (Assassins Creed 2)
Sage00 - Kazuma Kiryu from Yakuza
Guled - Cammy one with the ass
vehn - Crysis guy
justchris - TARDIS, or even just a Scribblenauts Phone Booth (but I prefer a TARDIS)
IntelliHeath - Reno from FF7
dagZ - Slimer from ghostbusters, OR possibly one of the ghostbusters please
ChennehCis - M. Bison (Street Fighter)
Caspel - Rinoa OR Michael Jackson doing the moon walk with hat OR Prince with his patented guitar and outfit
ivysaur12 - Guillo (Baten Kaitos Origins)
samratty - Frank Zappa
viewtiful_dru - Hideki Kamiya
kaizoku - Kamina from Gurren Lagann
koam - joker-mario-snake-mcbain
Evilink - Aliens
Hitlersaurus Christ - dinosaur hitler jesus.
Agent Dormer - Dr. House Scribblenautvatar. Cane, Pill Boll, Snark, and all
smokeymicpot - Brodie from Mallrats
jdub03 - hollow ichigo
ghstwrld - Sakura
truly101 - Bloodrayne avatar OR a Jen and Skree from Primal
Thanks to atomsk for the list!
The list will be cut off at 250
Chû Totoro - Last Guardian griffon
DaveKap - Kefka
Eternal_0 - Rock Volnutt or anything from Mega Man Legends
Kodiak - A bear
SailorDaravon - FFVI Tina/Terra
Pseudo_Sam - Michael, with his paint roller from the DVD covers (arrested development)
laserbeam - Super Mario
Jtwo - Dr Ian Malcom (Jurassic Park) OR general Jeff Goldblum
Volcynika - Millia Rage from Guilty Gear OR Jack Frost (MegaTen)
A Link to the Snitch - Rhythm Heaven girl
Jon - Phillie Phanatic
Fredescu - Neil (the young ones)
Victrix - Ninja Gaiden Ryu (8 Bit)
PBalfredo - Flint (mother 3)
krypt0nian - Superman
Maxrpg - His own avatar
Perdew - Shinra
Mashing - Illyria
Forgotten_Taco - A sad clown
GeneralIroh - Zuko OR Uncle Iroh (Avatar the Last Airbender)
Dark Ninja - Link OR Red (pokemon)
HK-47 - HK-47 with a red cape
Keyser Soze - GOB (arrested development)
MetatronM - One Piece crew members
unreon - Umbreon with glowing rings
Firehead - Gordon Freeman or G-Man
Raide - his own avatar
edgefusion - his own avatar
El Pescado - Ghostbusters (Peter OR Ray)
TwinIonEngines - TIE Fighter OR TIE Fighter Pilot
Scalemail Ted - his own avatar
BlueMagic - Guybrush Threepwood.
Wyndstryker - Pyramid Head
D4Danger - Agent 47 (Hitman)
SnakeXs - Link (LTTP)
..pakbeka.. - Mario 2 Phanto Mask + Key
Gamer @ Heart - Shinobi's Hotsuma Preferably holding a glowing sword
TheGreatDave - A flashing Agent Dale Cooper!
Label - Dynamite Heady, preferably with the vacuum head!
Danielsan - Gene from God Hand
evlcookie - Cookie Monster (evil?)
Wheeliedude - Gitaroo Man
Archie - Eddie (Iron Maiden)
Raging Spaniard - Raging Spaniard
ethelred - Lans Tartare (Tactics Ogre) or Demifiend (Nocturne)
LiquidMetal14 - Shiva from FFX
Cat in the Hat - Micheal Jackson
Teetris - Mike Tyson
plank - nih-pah
Ravidrath - Red Mage from FFXI
robochimp - Cyborg Ninja (metal gear solid)
M.J. Doja - Omar, the thug (The Wire)
rzr4 - R2D2/Darth Vader
Nakazato - Hume thf af 1 or Ray Lewis
Lucario - Lucario
Renshi - Ike (Fire Emblem)
dygiT - Altair (assassins creed)
ICallItFutile - Jade (beyond good and evil)
JPBrowncoat - River Tam
Won - something from Starcraft
daCuk - Guy (final fight / street fighter alpha)
Black-Wind - pikachu wearing a mario hat
Kagari - Stella (FF Versus XIII)
Ramirez - Cortana
ZeroGravity - Miyuki (Lucky Star)
louie - Samas Aran
ChazAshley - Chaz Ashley
rataven - Cloud (FF7)
drkOne - Noel from BlazBlue
Y2Kev - Cloud
akachan ningen - Tony Tony Chopper (One Piece)
Jive Turkey - Sexy Asian Toad Girl
Himuro - Laguna Loire.
Linkzg - Gene from God Hand
Jswanko - Bender w/cigar (futurama)
Yazuka - KOS-MOS
Gryphter - Wizard Yuki Nagato from The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya
Replicant - Dingo Egret from ZOE2
vectorman06 - Pokemon Red Trainer
Forkball - Link
EmCeeGramr - Metal Man
MidnightScott - Houndoom
oneHeero - white Sackboy
Meier - Joel McHale OR Noel Gallagher
Sidzed2 - Kratos
brlito - his own avatar
Narag - Tyrael (Diablo II)
BudokaiMR2 - Ibuki
Beardz - Alex from River City Ransom
timetokill - Earthworm Jim, in gun pose
AlucarD.eq - baby bart/jesus
Duke Togo - Duke Togo
TurtleSnatcher - El Fuerte
Parallax - toad avatar OR a mark harmon OR david caruso
Bluth54 - 10th Doctor
NameGenerated - Matthew Lesko
FunkyMunkey - Majora's Mask fierce deity link
Firestorm - charmander
Ydahs - Guile from Chrono Cross.
mrklaw - lum
soulhouf - Luffy (One Piece)
TheFreshPrince - Mah Na Mah Na Muppet
Fortinbras - Buffy the Vampire Slayer (in a cool pose)
McBradders - Jill Valentine circa RE1
NintendoGal - Chef Ramsay
ReiGun - ShinkenGold
OokieSpookie - Ash (Evil Dead)
antispin - Duke Nukem
grandjedi6 - Jon Stewart
VAIL - http://i40.tinypic.com/r01t2d.jpg
Costanza - thumbs up Costanza
NeoForte - FFXI Mandragora
bistromathics - face-palming ps3 from castle vidcons Lord PS3
n3ss - Urien (3rd strike) OR Sanji (One Piece)
firehawk12 - female shepard
Red Scarlet - Rise (Persona 4) OR Jessica with the Mystery Bustier OR Penelo (FF12) OR Aigis (Persona 3)
ZROCOOL - Kanada from Akira
Otheradam - Big Daddy (Bioshock)
DrFunk - Snoopy (Joe Cool style, red shirt, sunglasses)
Llyranor - Ray Muzyka
Iron E Man - Alucard
John Harker - BALTHIER from FFXII
SuperSonic1305 - Super Saiyin teen Gohan
Nightz - Soundwave (G1 Transformers)
VaLiancY - TF2 Soldier
Hootie - Kyle Hyde (hotel dusk)
batbeg - Layle (Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles: The Crystal Bearers)
LovingSteam - Larry David (curb your enthusiasm)
Ferrio - Blue Mary
Monroeski - Captain Murphy (Sealab 2021)
Topher - Quinn (Sealab 2021)
Rewrite - his own avatar
Hero - Lenneth Valkyrie from Valkyrie Profile
markot - Star fox doing the 'come on' taunt from smash bros
strange_booj - Joanna Dark
RadioHeadAche - Thom Yorke
Affeinvasion - Deadpool
Vox-Pop - his avatar
Yoboman - MGS2 Snake (cigarette a must) sneaking up on a Gurlukovich soldier.
Cheesemeister - Howard Dean wearing a Cheesehead
Drensch - Adriana Lima
Darunia - Lenny (the simpsons)
mclem - Tier 2 Paladin from WoW
FSLink - Cyclops from the X-Men
Gallagher - Georg Prime
fanboi - his own avatar
Vashu - Vash the Stampede
hidepsyence - Kamina
gynoug - Rise (Persona 4)
Captain N - Captain N
Error - Jack Frost (MegaTen)
Fireflu - any character from Mighty Max (Max, Virgil, Norman, etc) OR either Bucky O'hare OR Jazz Jackrabbit.
TheChillyAcademic - Vexen
Mars - Judith (Tales of Vesperia)
Tytree - Linebeck (Zelda)
Shinobix - Daft Punk duo
Dizzle24 - Dante
ninj4junpei - Jehuty from Zone of the Enders
octopusman - Vyse from Skies of Arcadia
sh4mike - King Arthur (Monty Python)
Zeep - Dark Samus
Kuroyume - his own avatar
lackey - kuroro lucifer from hunter x hunter
Nightz - Soundwave (G1 Transformers)
Killthee - sad wwf panda
Gelry - Metroid
djdac - Shiren the Wanderer
chapel - guy with pikachu doll OR "i has a bucket" walrus
Rimshot - Goemon
Tonza - Yuri Lowell from Tales of Vesperia OR MC from Persona 4
Little Green Yoda - Yoda
Ysiadmihi - Daisy (Mario Strikers)
Fox the Sly - Spike Spiegel
8-Bit Soul - Megan Fox (Transformers)
Blyss - Crash Bandicoot
Alf-Life - Snake Plissken OR Joanna Dark
Princess Skittles - Disney Tinkerbell
Darkflight - Spiderman
BGBW - Captain Falcon
PTCoakley - This gundam
Kobun Heat - Kobun/Servbot
BlueMagic - the guy on the right
neojubei - Anubis (ZOE)
TheHeretic - Max Payne
PacoDG - Mag (katamari cousin)
AndyMoogle - Moogle
DrPirate - Peter Finch from network (1976 movie)
Krelian - Krelian from Xenogears.
Ca1amity - Fallout 3 Brotherhood of Steel Paladin OR Sean Connery as James Bond OR Magneto OR Hydralisk
Cipher - Wrex (Mass Effect)
autobzooty - Ness (OKay! pose)
U K Narayan - Green Dinosaur (Dinosaur Comics)
robut - Gunstar Green/Seven Force
OnPoint - Terminator T-800 (half Arnold/Half Machine)
permutated - Mog
Kletian - Autobot Hound (Transformers)
Hugbot - Grimlock
Dacvak - Mario
ZealousD - Protoss Zealot
aidan - Junpei (Persona 3)
SpiderJerusalem - Supergirl
lbcyalater - Schwarzenegger from Commando
Charron - Bridget
Azih - Raz from Psychonauts
Space Cadet - this guy
LaneDS - Alphonese Elric from Fullmetal Alchemist (as a suit of armor)
Clipper - Ryūta Ippongi from Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan?
whitehawk - cookie monster
RPS37 - Halo ODST Solider
Zel3 - Kizaru (One Piece)
Lkr - Cole Train (Gears of War)
kiryogi - CG style Beryl
Nobiru - Scarlet Spidey
clay_ghost - Gold from Pokemon
beermonkey@tehbias - Frank Zappa (w/ guitar)
bryehn - Brian (family guy)
Grand_Gamer - Worms 3D worm (with uzi)
replayy - Julian Casablancas
3roam - Faith (Mirrors Edge) OR Ezio (Assassins Creed 2)
Sage00 - Kazuma Kiryu from Yakuza
Guled - Cammy one with the ass
vehn - Crysis guy
justchris - TARDIS, or even just a Scribblenauts Phone Booth (but I prefer a TARDIS)
IntelliHeath - Reno from FF7
dagZ - Slimer from ghostbusters, OR possibly one of the ghostbusters please
ChennehCis - M. Bison (Street Fighter)
Caspel - Rinoa OR Michael Jackson doing the moon walk with hat OR Prince with his patented guitar and outfit
ivysaur12 - Guillo (Baten Kaitos Origins)
samratty - Frank Zappa
viewtiful_dru - Hideki Kamiya
kaizoku - Kamina from Gurren Lagann
koam - joker-mario-snake-mcbain
Evilink - Aliens
Hitlersaurus Christ - dinosaur hitler jesus.
Agent Dormer - Dr. House Scribblenautvatar. Cane, Pill Boll, Snark, and all
smokeymicpot - Brodie from Mallrats
jdub03 - hollow ichigo
ghstwrld - Sakura
truly101 - Bloodrayne avatar OR a Jen and Skree from Primal
Thanks to atomsk for the list!
The list will be cut off at 250