Edit: and no, I don't want you to go through the whole book. Tha'd take just as long and wouldn't really get us anywhere. I really cannot see us agreeing on this one way or the other.
What'd take you 3 hours, would take me 23 to go through each event and explain how Kvothe managed it. I'm just saying you're case is easier to prove than mine. And I totally see us agreeing, we just have to go through the actual testing field to verify the answer and then one of us will have to admit they were wrong(which wouldn't mean our personal like/dislike of the book would have to change, just that we were off about the assessment we made). Told you analysis isn't fun. But if you choose not to do it, I get it. Still, I think the 3rd novel is due soon. Maybe a year or two. That said, I'd greatly contest your point of the second novel not being good. In my opinion, it's far superior to the first.
But I understand, and I'd like to conclude this debate on amicable terms.
Edit: The third novel has been started a while ago. I don't know where you heard otherwise, but it's been in the works.