• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Total Recall: Was Quaid’s experience real or the Recall?

Nymphae

Banned
I am very curious about the ending of the novelization and cannot find a copy online, and book reviews I'm finding refuse to spoil it. Could be informative.
 
If it was a recall, why was his wife in it? Why make her a bad guy and then kill her off?

That one part makes no sense if it was supposed to all be a dream vacation. So he wakes up and mourns his wife? Or what?

#TeamReal

If it's a dream, I believe all the real people from his life he encounters in said dream are due to the schizoid embolism and wouldn't be there otherwise. To quote the movie:

"What you're experiencing is a free-form delusion based on our memory tapes...but you're inventing it yourself as you go along."

So while he's following the preset events of the rekall trip, he's mentally adding elements like Harry and his wife to the events he's dreaming. At least that's how it appears to me, as being able to murder friends and family in an experience as real as any memory would create some serious issues. =P
 

jason10mm

Gold Member
I seem to recall.....heh heh, a scene where the brunette mentions that she did modeling for rekall at one point, which would explain why her face shows up in the beginning. That may have been from the novelization though. But it always put me on team real.
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
Sharon Stone in this movie could be a whole thread on its own.
sharon-stone.jpg
 

Ivory Blood

Member
It's real, all of it. You can tell after that scene with the red pill doctor and his bead of sweat, and don't start with a "just a glitch in the simulation" nonsense.
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
It's real, all of it. You can tell after that scene with the red pill doctor and his bead of sweat, and don't start with a "just a glitch in the simulation" nonsense.

What if the sweat was supposed to happen, to make one think it were real? A part of the programming.
 

Ivory Blood

Member
What if the sweat was supposed to happen, to make one think it were real? A part of the programming.
But if the doctor was inserted into the simulation by the programmers, wasn't he "outside the Matrix" so to say? He shouldn't sweat then, he shouldn't even be able to die.
 
Last edited:

cryptoadam

Banned
Why would cophagen send the doctor with the pill? Lets say Quaid takes it then what? He goes back to earth to start over again?

Or Cophagen knew Quaid would say no and shoot the doctor?

If its all a memory it makes sense that everything worked out. If its real then Cophagen basically is screwing his plan over and over again.
 
Why would cophagen send the doctor with the pill? Lets say Quaid takes it then what? He goes back to earth to start over again?

Or Cophagen knew Quaid would say no and shoot the doctor?

If its all a memory it makes sense that everything worked out. If its real then Cophagen basically is screwing his plan over and over again.

and he cannot lie
 

MetalAlien

Banned
Why would cophagen send the doctor with the pill? Lets say Quaid takes it then what? He goes back to earth to start over again?

Or Cophagen knew Quaid would say no and shoot the doctor?

If its all a memory it makes sense that everything worked out. If its real then Cophagen basically is screwing his plan over and over again.
Well he said he wasn't supposed to be activated yet. Going to Recall moved all the plans ahead before they were ready.

If Recall was real I would fuck with my customers and insert memories of them banging purple haired SJW fatties.

Get on your knees thank God Recall is not a real thing. Black market memories where there are no victims. Imagine the darkest nastiness porn you've ever tried to forget seeing... and now you just lived it.
 
Last edited:
only part I always find I can't deal with is that Quaid would fantasize about someone who look like Rachel Ticotin when he has someone like Sharon Stone at home banging him.
 

Nymphae

Banned
only part I always find I can't deal with is that Quaid would fantasize about someone who look like Rachel Ticotin when he has someone like Sharon Stone at home banging him.

Remember when Arnie was fucking a haggard old nanny instead of Maria Schriver? Sometimes it's about getting some strange (but not this strange Arnold- wow)

article-1388212-0C1F522000000578-997_306x433.jpg
 
Last edited:
Well he said he wasn't supposed to be activated yet. Going to Recall moved all the plans ahead before they were ready.

Yeah but at that point Cohaagen had put the plan in motion anyway, having the guy give him the briefcase which then led him to Mars. Not to mention he already spoke to Mileena and gave her the whole "I'm Quaid now" spiel as well. Why try and capture him to restart the plan when he was already that deep into it. =P

It's real, all of it. You can tell after that scene with the red pill doctor and his bead of sweat, and don't start with a "just a glitch in the simulation" nonsense.

The explanation usually given for that aspect is Quaid basically "dreamed" it in there. From earlier in that same scene the Rekall guy says:

"What you're experiencing is a free-form delusion based on our memory tapes...but you're inventing it yourself as you go along."

So if that is true, then Quaid seeing the sweat drop would fall under that.
 
Top Bottom