• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Transformers: Age of Extinction reviews

Status
Not open for further replies.
Will watch it when it's out of the theater. Dark of the Moon was marginally better (the last forty minutes were pretty damn watchable) because of the special effects, but man, even the Dinobots can't help me feeling a bit enthousiastic about this movie. Thanks Bay.
 
I imagine in 5-10 years Bay will be just be doing giant robot mayhem with porn in-between. Maximize what the audience wants.
 
I do not understand why these movies are so damn long. You would think they would want this series to clock in at a nice even 2 hours to fit in more screenings opening weekend.
 
The Tofunator said:
No,
those are just terraforming ships.
Click to expand...

I think it's rumored that
space will be a factor/setting in the last 2 of the trilogy

choo choo
astrotrain01.jpg
 
TitusGroan said:
You have to hand it to Bay. At this point, his films are fucking nuclear bomb proof when it comes to critical reception. Every critic in the world could form an alliance and launch the most scathing critical campaign against Transformers ever, films would still print money.

Ah well... for people who want to see robot dinosaurs, I'm sure it'll be a blast. I'll look forward to Mark Kermode's inevitable mental breakdown trying to review the film.
Click to expand...

Yup, can't wait for the inevitable Kermode head banging review.

iNgM5hoeieJJ7.gif
 
tghm1801 said:
I don't think it's commendable, at all. If a game dev kept releasing mediocre games with the exact same issues, would that be commendable?

I don't think anyone finds game franchises that refuse to fix burning issues "commendable".
Click to expand...

technical issues and artistic disparity are two different things. If a ton of people artistically liked a dumb game then its the same thing and its fine.

And yes they are reviewing it wrong. It's a fucking dinosaur robot explosion movie and never said it would be anything else. It's like reviewing little kids movies and complaining about compelling stories. Its 123 ABC.
 
I don't really expect an Academy Award winning, thought provoking story from Transformers. Just give me something coherent with lots of robot violence and explosions, and I'll be satisfied with it.
 
Palabrah said:
technical issues and artistic disparity are two different things. If a ton of people artistically liked a dumb game then its the same thing and its fine.

And yes they are reviewing it wrong. It's a fucking dinosaur robot explosion movie and never said it would be anything else. It's like reviewing little kids movies and complaining about compelling stories. Its 123 ABC.
Click to expand...

It's attitudes like this that lead to movies like Batman and Robin.

"And yes they are reviewing it wrong. It's a fucking Batman bam-pow-kick explosion movie and never said it would be anything else. It's like reviewing little kids movies and complaining about compelling stories. It's 123 ABC."
 
B.K. said:
I don't really expect an Academy Award winning, thought provoking story from Transformers. Just give me something coherent with lots of robot violence and explosions, and I'll be satisfied with it.
Click to expand...

You have way too high expectations already. This series and even just competently shot action scenes are a rarity.
 
Delta Assault said:
It's attitudes like this that lead to movies like Batman and Robin.

"And yes they are reviewing it wrong. It's a fucking Batman bam-pow-kick explosion movie and never said it would be anything else. It's like reviewing little kids movies and complaining about compelling stories. It's 123 ABC."
Click to expand...

Batman and Robin was not technically sound, or beautiful. Michael Bay films are.
 
TemplaerDude said:
No, they're shit and he needs to stop making movies,
Click to expand...

umm thats a totally disrectful thing to say.

your not in control of his life nor should you be

he'll continue to make films that will entertain audiences. he doesn't cater to the random internet forum dweller.

i for one am happy people like him exist to make movies.
 
I wish Bay hadn't completely lost any trace of self-control in recent years. The Rock is a genuinely great action movie and even the first Transformers movie is pretty decent. Transformers 2 and 3 were hideously bloated, tedious and visually incomprehensible, and the trailers for Age Of Extinction looked like suffering exactly the same problems only, even more ridiculously, now 10 minutes LONGER than movies which were already drastically overlong. If these movies were 100 minutes long, without all the pointless supporting characters and a more palpable sense of humour and they'd already be infinitely more bearable. These movies don't need to be clever or respectable, but good action movies should be concise, clear and well-paced, which is pretty much the opposite of everything Bay's been making after the first Transformers.
 
Slayven said:
I never understood what people had against the movies? They seen the source material right?
Click to expand...

Right, the source material where Optimus Prime is a noble, principled leader and not an unhinged, psychotic murderer who wants to tear off faces? The source material where the robots are all in blocky, identifiable, iconic silhouettes and not confusing, jumbled, spikey junkyard scraps stuck together? The source material where all the robots are not offensive racial stereotypes that make jokes about being unable to read and call people "pussies?" The source material where the humor is toned down and kid appropriate and you don't have shots of John Turturro's asscheeks, Bumblebee pissing on John Turturro, Ken Jeong jumping on top of Shia LaBeouf in a toilet stall and calling himself "Deep Wang," or a shot of Devastator's testicles? The source material where women aren't just treated as sex objects and shot with blatantly pornographic sensibilities? That source material?
 
Slayven said:
I never understood what people had against the movies? They seen the source material right?
Click to expand...

What does the source material have to do with it ? Bad writing/directing is what it is .

Who would of thought a mythology of a man who dresses up as a Bat versus a man called The Joker would be so endeared by critics and audiences alike.

Or a mythology that consists of Wookies and The Force could be so loved especially it's first two entries with one of them often regarded as one of the best films ever made.

You can give anything character, heart and purpose when it's well written and directed. Even a bunch of robots that change into vehicles
 
Leave it to Transformers and TASM 2 to be the sole marks on a otherwise great summer of blockbusters. I think they are legit the only things to end up with rotten ratings so far lol. I'll still trade that over a summer of mostly shit with a few gems tho.
 
Slayven said:
I never understood what people had against the movies? They seen the source material right?
Click to expand...
Even as someone who didn't really watch much Transformers cartoons, LOL. Still waiting for a Transformers movie with not groan-worthy dialogue or toilet humour, competently shot and exciting robot-on-robot action choreography, likeable human characters, more focus on the bloody robots, and not to be completely forgettable an hour after you've seen them.
 
Delta Assault said:
Right, the source material where Optimus Prime is a noble, principled leader and not an unhinged, psychotic murderer who wants to tear off faces? The source material where the robots are all in blocky, identifiable, iconic silhouettes and not confusing, jumbled, spikey junkyard scraps stuck together? The source material where all the robots are not offensive racial stereotypes that make jokes about being unable to read and call people "pussies?" The source material where the humor is toned down and kid appropriate and you don't have shots of John Turturro's asscheeks, Bumblebee pissing on John Turturro, Ken Jeong jumping on top of Shia LaBeouf in a toilet stall and calling himself "Deep Wang," or a shot of Devastator's testicles? The source material where women aren't just treated as sex objects and shot with blatantly pornographic sensibilities? That source material?
Click to expand...
Modern Prime is the best, he actually acts like a general in a war. War makes you do bad things, sometimes jsut to survive sometimes for the greater good. G1 Prime was an idiot. When Cosmo told him teh construcons were on an astestroid doing dirty shit. He told the little guy that isn't proof they were up to no good. No wonder dumbasses liek Megatron and Starscream had him on the ropes.
digoutyoursoul said:
What does the source material have to do with it ? Bad writing/directing is what it is .

Who would of thought a mythology of a man who dresses up as a Bat versus a man called The Joker would be so endeared by critics and audiences alike.

Or a mythology that consists of Wookies and The Force could be so loved especially it's first two entries with one of them often regarded as one of the best films ever made.

You can give anything character, heart and purpose when it's well written and directed. Even a bunch of robots that change into vehicles
Click to expand...
I know right? Transformers prime and Beast Wars was awesome for that.
 
Slayven said:
Modern Prime is the best, he actually acts like a general in a war. War makes you do bad things, sometimes jsut to survive sometimes for the greater good. G1 Prime was an idiot. When Cosmo told him teh construcons were on an astestroid doing dirty shit. He told the little guy that isn't proof they were up to no good.

I know right? Transformers prime and Beast Wars was awesome for that.
Click to expand...

It doesn't excuse for the shit we get now, you can make anything decent if the talent is there
 
Slayven said:
Modern Prime is the best, he actually acts like a general in a war. War makes you do bad things, sometimes jsut to survive sometimes for the greater good. G1 Prime was an idiot. When Cosmo told him teh construcons were on an astestroid doing dirty shit. He told the little guy that isn't proof they were up to no good. No wonder dumbasses liek Megatron and Starscream had him on the ropes.

I know right? Transformers prime and Beast Wars was awesome for that.
Click to expand...

Yeah... no. I disagree. Optimus Prime is kind of like Superman... he's got his principles and ethics and he stands tall because of them. The moral courage he displays is every bit as important to the character as his courage in battle.

I have no emotional connection to an Optimus Prime that goes around yelling "Give Me Your Face!" That's just a mad dog that needs to be put down.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

I felt a transformation
24
298
calico replied
Catherine O’Hara has passed away at 71 years of age
2
96
1K
TerribleAtThisGame replied
cologne-age 2.0: Recommend and share fragrances here.
2
74
1K
IDKFA replied
Perturbator's new album Age of Aquarius is out now
12
556
CGNoire replied
The erosion of privacy: Federal Level Operating Age Verification System coming to US and Digital ID App coming to Europe
Social News 
45
552
Maiden Voyage replied
Top Bottom