You know... I definitely have fonder memories of SH1 than SH2... more replayable for me too. It's definitely MUCH scarier...
3rd favorite game of all time. It's now official.
Phantasy Star IV
Streets of Rage 1
Silent Hill 1
Thought I was alone in this. Everyone keeps gushing about SH2 but I found the story, themes, npcs of SH1 to be more memorable.