Interesting thread. Some interesting posts, and strange readings of some situations.
I went to school in the same town from elementary through high school and it was a typically miserable experience all around. I was one of the shortest, youngest, nerdiest, least athletic kids growing up. Got picked on here and there in elementary, but it was merciless in middle. Well, first two years of middle. 5th grade was a nightmare. None of my friends in my class. Group of four guys decided to torment me for the whole year. Put me down a very dark path. To this day, I probably resent them for it a little bit, even though I've mellowed considerably. What bothered me most of all--and I'd venture what bothers any victim--wasn't the act of bullying; it was the lack of viable solutions and responses. Each guy there was easily a few inches taller and 10lbs heavier. Doesn't sound like a lot, but it makes a difference, and it meant that I couldn't physically take them on because I'd get destroyed.
We got zero traction with the school administration, as well. They simply didn't give a shit. Any action they *did* take was procedural, at best, and a token gesture. Just enough to document so they wouldn't get sued if something truly bad did happen. My mom wrote letters. Nothing. Both parents called meetings. Nothing.
Then a new vice principal rolled in. Dude was a no-nonsense hardass. Old school motherfucker who loathed stupid. I recall a SINGLE meeting with him and these dipshits in the 2nd half of the year and after that, I didn't have any problems with them. There was definitely more that happened after that meeting. Even back then, I greatly respected him. His style and approach really resonated with me.
6th grade was marginally better and marginally worse, though. Different group started with me, way more direct and targeted, and some REALLY vile things that I don't discuss with anyone. It was that cruel. The year started to turn around once I started lashing out. I guess you could say the inner pain and fury become outer pain and fury. Dangerous combination, since I also finally started sprouting up, started to fill out, and I'd been taking martial arts classes since 4th grade. Between 5th and 6th it all started clicking. Suddenly, in the span of a summer, I became very dangerous in a fight. I never went after my direct antagonists, but there were quite a few secondary little shits that got a bit too aggressive with me.
There was one distinct memory I have of a lunch room fight. We got into line at the same time, he pushed me, HARD, I pushed him back harder, and punches started flying. Well, only two. His, that I sidestepped, and mine, that connected right square in his face. He stumbled after missing me, I grabbed his bowlcut (hahahah oh man that WAS the style back then, wasn't it?) hair with my left hand, pulled his head up, pivoted my hips, and brought my right fist straight in. I didn't just punch. I punched THROUGH.
Ironically enough, while my masters would have applauded my technique, they would have chastised me for the fight. It was always more about avoidance. Fighting if you really, truly had to, and even then, to only use as much force as warranted. Be discreet in killing. I guess in a sense, I did follow that tenet. I ended the fight with a single punch and didn't continue once the guy was stumbling and bleeding.
The hardass VP raced in at that point, looked at me, him, looked back at me, "Go to my office."
Weirdest thing was, we walked down together. No teacher from what I could tell. That part still confuses me. Along the way I told the kid I was sorry, but this is what happens when you screw with someone. Kind of unfeeling and cruel but the truth, nonetheless.
The worst part about the whole incident was that I didn't receive any punishment, which clued me in on one major, major, major revelation: I could do anything I goddamn well pleased and get away with it as long as I didn't throw the first punch. As far as the VP and administration were concerned, I was still the same scared and angry 5th grader who was just trying to survive in hell.
The next couple of years, I was a terror. If I didn't like someone, you can be damn sure I was going to go after them in some sneaky, diabolically underhanded way that got them to start the physical fight. In my defense, I had a very detached approach to my classmates. I didn't give a crap about them. The only time when I would give any a second thought was if they jabbed at me.
Technically, I was a bully, and I admit that, but it was very nuanced. Lots of shades of gray. I was coming from a completely different headspace than the hardcore, franchise bullies. I found the whole system to be suspect. The educational institution to be woefully corrupt. As middle and high school went on, and I had to deal with antagonism every single year, with next to no help or guidance or anything from the admins, I became even more comfortable with that belief, that the whole place and the people in it were lost. Beyond saving. The system was completely broken beyond repair. One big joke.
That was sophomore year of high school, I think. Maybe junior year.
After that, I stopped running in that ridiculous rat race. Tons of extra courses, for what? To be the big fish in a microscopic pond of 160 students? No thanks. Try to fit in with people for which I hold nothing but contempt? Not a chance. Pretend that any of them are worth a damn, or any shred of respect? I refused to play that stupid game.
So I guess my view is a bit more sociopathic than most, with personal issues compounded by a very high intellect and aptitude, social integration problems created and exacerbated by years of very cruel targeted bullying, and a very dim view of humanity.
When all is said and done, there are more than just two sides in bullying. I've been on most of them. What I mentioned here (and truthfully, I'm AMAZED that I was even able to talk about it because I literally have not talked about a lot of that stuff with ANYONE in years) is a fraction of what I've seen and done. Bullying is a shitty situation because there are so many moving parts and an equal number of potential and contradictory solutions.
And it sucks.