Just finished Persona 3 Portable. It was brillant in every aspect (design, art, story).
Thrid time a charm I guess, since I never managed to get into P3 and P4 on PS2...I think it came from my anticipation (playing a great jRPG and something close to SMTNocturne) and what I got (social-sim+dRPG+dating)
I think since I was more "aware" of what I was getting, I had a blast with Portable, I was able to enjoy it for what it is. Also the game seemed to move at a faster pace thanks to the change in presentation. Also I can't believe I was actually EAGER to know what the characters had to say and how the story would progress. I can't remember the last time it had happen for me in a jRPG. Also, it made me THINK. It was a bit the "Evangelion" of videogame in that regard...full of anime cliché but done in such a manner, with so much wit that it becomes something else.
I have just begun P4 Golden...and the intro is sooooo long (well, P3 had the same problem), I think they could really improve that with P5...it's the only problem I seem to have now with this serie. Oh and the dating stuff, It was so lame...even if I didn't want to, I had to date all those girls in the end when all I wanted to do is to know them better...