Twilight Princess.
The build-up to this game's release was intense. I think I was around 12-13 when it was first announced .That first trailer, showcasing a darker tone as Link stands alone against hordes of monsters, without a hint of story, blew my mind back then. The second trailer continued with that theme of isolation and "show, don't tell" storytelling as Link traversed quiet forests and dark dungeons seemingly dripping with hidden history. I was convinced that we would be getting a modern interpretation of Zelda 1 in a darker setting.
And then the third trailer came out, emphasizing the story over everything else. But I was still excited, although it looked like we weren't getting the "Metroid Prime of Zelda" like I thought we were. And then the game came out and... well, I liked it, but I couldn't help but feel let down by the overbearing story, drab overworld, and linearity.
Fast-forward to last year, when I finally played Dark Souls and realized that was the game I'd always wished TP had been. Ironically enough, after trading in my dusty Wii U it looks like a Zelda game came out that actually is a modern interpretation of Zelda 1.