Support NeoGAF

[krzy123]

And lets not forget Infinite Undiscovery, Lost Odyssey, Blue Dragon, Cry On, Dead Rising, Lost Planet, Perfect Dark is a new IP for the 360, Banjo & Kazzooie, Eternal Sonata {its still only on the 360 mind you until the PS3 fabled release]

I thought we were listing quality new ips? most of those are average to below average.

 

[HK-47]

Games Already Out(Please correct me if I'm wrong in some way)

360

Dead Rising
Gears Of War
Bioshock
Mass Effect
Blue dragon
Lost Odyssey
Chromehounds
Crackdown
Kameo: Elements of Power
Viva Pinata

PS3
Folklore
*Haze*
*Lair*
Motorstorm
Resistance
Uncharted

Wii
Boom Blox
Elebits
No More Heroes
*Red Steel*
Wii Play
Zack & Wiki
Excite Truck

Wii Sports, Wii Fit, And I guess put Carnival Games and Mario & Sonic if crap like Lair counts.

Also PS3 and 360 should get all the multiplat new IPs they have

 

[Revelations]

I thought we were listing quality new ips? most of those are average to below average.

Read the thread topic again. New IP's.

 

[farnham]

wii

zack and wiki
nomoreheroez
bloom blox
family ski
wii sports
wii fit
mysims (uh... dunno if this qualifies)
excite truck (uh... dunno if this qualifies)

360

gears
lost planet
dead rising
bioshock (uh... dunno if this qualifies)

ps3

uh resistance?

 

[gofreak]

snip

Don't do lists unless you're going to do them properly. You're missing tonnes of games.

 

[TaKeRx]

Wii Sports, Wii Fit, And I guess put Carnival Games and Mario & Sonic if crap like Lair counts.

Also PS3 and 360 should get all the multiplat new IPs they have

well the games that have a * on the name, means that they were hyped and flopped. And I didn't want to put Wii Sports or Wii Fiit because they are essential games. lol I'm not making sense i'll put them in.

 

[farnham]

raving rabbids is a new IP... kinda.. it was rayman

but its obvious that rayman is.. like non existant in this franchise now

 

[Threi]

PS3
-PS3 has games? LOLOLOLOL

Wii
-Too casual

360
RROD

My list says they are pretty equal.

 

[JayDub]

PS3 IMO, it got us excited and hyped for Lair, Motorstorm, Resistance, Uncharter, Heavenly Sword...

Sony hasn't even released their big hitter sequels yet.

 

[r4z4]

'greatest share'? Wii.

 

[No6]

I think you're right. I've never played Systemshock either, but I have heard that mentioned before when it comes to Bioshock.

Only by fanchildren desperatly trying to discredit Bioshock's critical and financial success. Bioshock is a "spritual successor" in the same way that Quake is the spiritual successor to Doom.

Also, why are exclusives the only things that count? New IP is new IP, so if you get a new IP on the PC360 that's a new IP. If you get a new IP on PSWii that's a new IP.

 

[VideoMan]

Wii:

Boom Blox
Zack & Wiki: Quest for Barbaros' Treasure
No More Heroes
Wii Fit
Rayman Raving Rabbids*
Wii Sports
Excite Truck*
Elebits
Endless Ocean
Super Swing Golf
Kororinpa: Marble Mania
Dewy's Adventure
Red Steel
Smarty Pants
EA Playground
Battle of the Bands
Wii Play
Carnival Games
Boogie
Samurai Warriors: Katana
Ninja Reflex
Nitrobike
Wing Island

360:

BioShock
Gears of War
Mass Effect
Viva Pinata
Dead Rising
Crackdown
Rockstar Games presents Table Tennis**
Saints Row
Condemned**
Kameo: Elements of Power
Eternal Sonata**
Lost Odyssey
Lost Planet**
Blue Dragon
Scene It? Lights, Camera, Action

PS3:

Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
Resistance: Fall of Man
MotorStorm
Heavenly Sword
Folklore
The Eye of Judgment
Haze
Lair


* Controversial. RRR is an entirely new type of game with a past IP shoveled in. Excite Truck is technically an extension of the Excite Bike line of games

**I'm counting new IPs that were later ported more than six months later to other platforms as a new IP for the launch platform

I also didn't count any IPs that were launched simultaneously on multiple platforms, as well as ones that haven't been released yet.

New multiplatform IPs this gen:

Rock Band
Skate
Assassin's Creed
The Darkness
Stranglehold
Army of Two
The Club
Dark Sector
F.E.A.R.
Enchanted Arms
Kane & Lynch: Dead Men
Clive Barker's Jericho
Turning Point: Fall of Liberty

 

[MWS Natural]

PS3 IMO, it got us excited and hyped for Lair, Motorstorm, Resistance, Uncharter, Heavenly Sword...

Sony hasn't even released their big hitter sequels yet.

2008 2009 Year of the PS3 Confirmed.

 

[domokunrox]

I've used a previous list and added upon it as well as clarifications.

360

Dead Rising
Gears Of War (available for PC)
Mass Effect (available for PC)
Blue dragon
Lost Odyssey
Chromehounds
Crackdown
Kameo: Elements of Power
Viva Pinata

PS3
Folklore
Haze
Lair
Motorstorm
Resistance
Uncharted
Pixeljunk Monsters
Fl0w
Heavenly sword

Wii
Boom Blox
Elebits
No More Heroes
Red Steel
Wii Play
Zack & Wiki
Excite Truck

 

[DCharlie]

360
Dead Rising
Bioshock (available for PC, PS3 coming)
Gears Of War (available for PC)
Mass Effect (available for PC)
Blue dragon (also on DS)
Lost Odyssey
Chromehounds
Crackdown
Kameo: Elements of Power
Viva Pinata (available on PC)
everyparty
Zegapain
bullet witch
99 Nights
Idol Master
Eternal Sonata (PS3 eventually)
Love Football
Scene it
Over G
Operation Darkness
Battlestations Midway (available on PC?)
Two Worlds (available on PC?)
XBLA stuff

PS3
Folklore
Eye of Judgement
Haze (timed exclusive?)
Lair (going to Wii i thought - rumoured?)
Motorstorm
Resistance
Uncharted
Pixeljunk Monsters
Fl0w (available on PC/PSP)
Heavenly sword
Sega Golf


i'm sure theres more
PSN stuff

 

[KTallguy]

It's so obvious who owns a PS3 and who owns a 360 in this thread

Or at least who plays PS3 more over 360.
But definitely 360 has gotten more new IP than PS3 so far.

 

[jarrod]

Sorry Charlie, quickie paredown/corrections..

360
Zegapain (based on anime/manga)
Idol Master (based on AC game)
Scene it (based on board game)
Over G (had PS2 prequels)

PS3
Folklore (had PSP prequel)
Sega Golf (based on AC game, Sports license)

 

[jarrod]

Doing, just 1st party efforts (including Shared IPs and co-produced/funded 3rd party IPs)...

Microsoft
-Alan Wake (Remedy Entertainment)
-Blue Dragon (Mistwalker/Artoon)
-Crackdown (Realtime Worlds)
-everyparty (Game Republic)
-Gears of War (Epic Games)
-Infinite Undiscovery (Square Enix/tri-Ace)
-Kameo (RARE)
-Lost Odyssey (Mistwalker/feelplus)
-Mass Effect (Bioware)
-N3: Ninety-Nine Nights (Q? entertainment/Phantagram)
-Too Human (Silicon Knights)
-Viva Piñata (RARE)

Nintendo
-Disaster (MonolithSoft)
-Endless Ocean (Arika)
-Wii _____ (Nintendo)

SCE
-Afrika (Rhino Studios)
-Eight Days (Sony Studios London)
-Eyedentify (Japan Studio)
-Heavenly Sword (Ninja Theory)
-Heavy Rain (Quantic Dream)
-Infamous (Sucker Punch)
-Lair (Factor 5)
-LittleBigPlanet (Media Molecule)
-MotorStorm (Evolution Studios)
-Resistance (Insomniac Games)
-The Eye of Judgement (Japan Studio)
-Uncharted (Naughty Dog Software)
-White Night Story (Level 5)

 

[No6]

Scene it (based on board game)

I don't think being based on a board game should disqualify something as a new IP since the markets are so totally separate. I do agree that Scene It! could be removed, though, since the board game is almost like a videogame. Although I could also see arguing that arcade games count as new IPs since arcades are dead outside of Japan... eh, list warz.

Really though, you list warriors are still missing a lot of stuff simply because of obscurity. Where's Call of Juarez? Defend Your Castle? Random EyeToy game?

 

[Sol..]

lol if you have to add side notes, footnotes, and shit then it don't count.


Condense the nonsense people.

 

[jarrod]

I don't think being based on a board game should disqualify something as a new IP since the markets are so totally separate. I do agree that Scene It! could be removed, though, since the board game is almost like a videogame. Although I could also see arguing that arcade games count as new IPs since arcades are dead outside of Japan... eh, list warz.

It's about new IP... it doesn't matter if it's a different market, it's still an established IP. I mean, should every new film based license then count too? Every new sports license? Television? Book?

 

[2 Minutes Turkish]

Counting shovelware then the Wii by far. Not counting shovelware then I'd say 360.

I'd say this is spot on.

But surely we aren't counting shovelware like Ninjabreadman are we?

Decent to great new IPs then it's 360 by a stretch.

EDIT: Now that I think about it some more, the PS3 has quite a few also. Wow, we really are blessed this gen.

 

[Grayman]

I don't think being based on a board game should disqualify something as a new IP since the markets are so totally separate. I do agree that Scene It! could be removed, though, since the board game is almost like a videogame. Although I could also see arguing that arcade games count as new IPs since arcades are dead outside of Japan... eh, list warz.

Really though, you list warriors are still missing a lot of stuff simply because of obscurity. Where's Call of Juarez? Defend Your Castle? Random EyeToy game?

I don't own an eyetoy but random eyetoy game likely falls into the shovelware category.

 

[No6]

It's about new IP... it doesn't matter if it's a different market, it's still an established IP. I mean, should every new film based license then count too? Every new sports license? Television? Book?

Sure, why wouldn't they? They just normally don't get list warz'd because licensed stuff tends to suck and winds up on almost every platform. But I'd consider board games like Carcassone or whatever the Strongbad game is as new IPs.

I don't own an eyetoy but random eyetoy game likely falls into the shovelware category.

I like to pretend that there's a world of unexplored PSN gaming that I'm missing by not owning an EyeToy, and that's how things are going to stay.

 

[jarrod]

Sure, why wouldn't they? They just normally don't get list warz'd because licensed stuff tends to suck and winds up on almost every platform. But I'd consider board games like Carcassone or whatever the Strongbad game is as new IPs.

It's literally not a new IP. It might be a new game, new game series, but it's not a new IP.

 

[AndyD]

I don't own an eyetoy but random eyetoy game likely falls into the shovelware category.

Then you are missing out.. While theres some crap, theres a couple good things too.

 

[Liabe Brave]

360
Scene it (based on board game)

I'd agree this isn't a new IP. The transition is even less a jump than, say, Carcassone or Settlers, because Scene It? already had a video component.

Over G (had PS2 prequels)

Really? What were they called?

Folklore (had PSP prequel)

The PSP game Coded Soul is based on Folklore, not the other way around. It's not even out yet.

 

[jarrod]

Really? What were they called?

Energy Airforce. In fact Over G went by that title when it was still in development.

The PSP game Coded Soul is based on Folklore, not the other way around. It's not even out yet.

Folklore came after, and is based on the same universe as Monster Kingdom.

 

[Haunted]

ugh, nevermind.

 

[Liabe Brave]

Energy Airforce. In fact Over G went by that title when it was still in development.

Gotcha.

Folklore came after, and is based on the same universe as Monster Kingdom.

Alrighty then. Reading a FAQ the PSP Monster Kingdom doesn't look like it's set in the real world at all, but I do see that Folklore was initially itself called Monster Kingdom, so it must be the case.

Of course, the real question isn't whether PS3 has more new IPs than 360, because it clearly doesn't. The question is whether 360 has more than Wii. Given all the multiplats on PS360 or PC/360, and especially if you include XBLA titles, I bet it does.