• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Xbox 360 vs. PS3 Face-Off: Round 16

As much as I hate to say it... there's something in what you're saying there.
Click to expand...
Yeah I don't want to get into the frontline here as I don't constantly watch who is biased about what but it is noticeable that the amount of Uncharted and KZ2 pics and mentioning (even when its totally unrelated) is far bigger than I have ever seen for the 360 "counterparts"...just wait for February though. Then the real fun should start ;)

I am also anticipating kz2 and will get it day 1 btw

Banjo doesn't even get mentioned that much in terms of graphics, ever. And I find that one to be as impressive as gears 2.

(this is going way ot though, so I'm out)
 
Ariexv said:
my god looking over the past couple years....

2006-Gears 1 comes out destroys everything graphically: Didn't really see any constant pic posting
2007-Uncharted is king of graphics:50%+ of all threads on Neogaf contain pics of Uncharted
2008-Gears 2 and Banjo dominate the graphics this time around:Again You don't see people going around posting Gears 2/Banjo screenshots in every thread do you?
2009-KZ2 comes out:We've been getting constant screenshots of this for several months now.....


Do Ps3 fans really need to try and prove that their $600 was well spent this badly? Or do you all actually still believe Sonys utter bullshit about 4D/1080p/60FPS from before the Ps3 released?
Click to expand...
Talk about butt hurt!
 
Firewire said:
Talk about butt hurt!
Click to expand...
wtf butt-hurt? I was just pointing out something thats been going on for a pretty long time.... Heck you don't even see Crysis pictures as often as you see KZ2/Uncharted ones......


Hellraizer said:
Banjo doesn't even get mentioned that much in terms of graphics, ever. And I find that one to be as impressive as gears 2.
Click to expand...
I 100% agree, I can't wait till Rare comes out with a non-cartoony game so people will actually recognize what they've been accomplishing.
 
If texture pop in isn't a problem with the PS3 version of ME, they probably should've waited for both versions to load properly.

These ones have a bit more detail in distant building textures to the left on PS3, but a little more aliasing and a few missing shadows in the foreground.

http://images.eurogamer.net/assets/articles//a/3/1/8/3/8/2/Mirror_s_Edge_360_017.jpg.jpg
http://images.eurogamer.net/assets/articles//a/3/1/8/3/8/2/Mirror_s_Edge_PS3_017.jpg.jpg

As you can see from the video, there's barely anything to tell these games apart. They're both equally excellent to look at, and the overall gameplay experience is virtually identical.
Click to expand...
 
Ariexv said:
wtf butt-hurt? I was just pointing out something thats been going on for a pretty long time.... Heck you don't even see Crysis pictures as often as you see KZ2/Uncharted ones......



I 100% agree, I can't wait till Rare comes out with a non-cartoony game so people will actually recognize what they've been accomplishing.
Click to expand...
Nah, you could ease up and respect fans of these games though. If you don't like it then stay out. Crysis is not a fair barometer for consoles so that's why it's unfair to bring it up in a mainly console oriented discussion. Uncharted and KZ2 are brought up (often times unnecessarily) to show that PS3 can render some unbelievable scenery when threads like this show some inferiority within 3rd party efforts.

DCharlie said:
hard to refute though, isn't it?
Click to expand...
No, but sometimes you have to bite your tongue in order to keep the thread from swaying into a fanboy war. You know what I mean. Often times it goes too far and we can't even have relevant discussion :(
 
LiquidMetal14 said:
Nah, you could ease up and respect fans of these games though. If you don't like it then stay out. Crysis is not a fair barometer for consoles so that's why it's unfair to bring it up in a mainly console oriented discussion. Uncharted and KZ2 are brought up (often times unnecessarily) to show that PS3 can render some unbelievable scenery when threads like this show some inferiority within 3rd party efforts.
Click to expand...
Ok comon, can you honestly sit their and say that the pic posting from those 2 games hasnt gotten a bit out of hand?
 
drohne said:
textures clearly haven't loaded yet in the ps3 shot. i almost hate to point this out, as it's just going to give butthurt ps3 fans another pretext to rail on eurogamer's highly informative comparisons
Click to expand...
You are right. I don't care about Sony, but the comparison pics are worthless.
 
LiquidMetal14 said:
Nah, you could ease up and respect fans of these games though. If you don't like it then stay out. Crysis is not a fair barometer for consoles so that's why it's unfair to bring it up in a mainly console oriented discussion. Uncharted and KZ2 are brought up (often times unnecessarily) to show that PS3 can render some unbelievable scenery when threads like this show some inferiority within 3rd party efforts.
Click to expand...

But neither of those games are 3rd party efforts and the entire point of the thread is to compare third party games. Posting anything about first party titles are completely off topic.
 
DCharlie said:
hard to refute though, isn't it?
Click to expand...
People like good graphics, so people post good graphics, kinda understandable is it not? Oh but I forgot! If it isn't on the 360 it must be shit, and therfore the two of you don't like it.
 
Firewire said:
People like good graphics, so people post good graphics, kinda understandable is it not? Oh but I forgot! If it isn't on the 360 it must be shit, and therfore the two of you don't like it.
Click to expand...
Wtf where did anyone ever say anything like that? Any time anyone anywhere even mentions graphics on these forums within 10 posts there's a SS from Uncharted or KZ2. Meanwhile despite Gears 2/Banjo/Gears 1 all being the best games graphically for their time you don't see the same thing happening..... I'm sorry but no1 wants to see 5 pages of Uncharted Screenshots in every thread. It feels like anytime anyone mentions good graphics on anything but the Ps3 some sony fan needs to come running in going "OH LOOK ME2 ME2 I CAN HAVE GOOD GRAPHICS TOO"
 
danwarb said:
If texture pop in isn't a problem with the PS3 version of ME, they probably should've waited for both versions to load properly.

These ones have a bit more detail in distant building textures to the left on PS3, but a little more aliasing and a few missing shadows in the foreground.

http://images.eurogamer.net/assets/articles//a/3/1/8/3/8/2/Mirror_s_Edge_360_017.jpg.jpg
http://images.eurogamer.net/assets/articles//a/3/1/8/3/8/2/Mirror_s_Edge_PS3_017.jpg.jpg
Click to expand...

:lol More FUD from the Microsoft shills. Trust me Mirror's Edge looks nothing like that on PS3.
 
I'm sorry but no1 wants to see 5 pages of Uncharted Screenshots in every thread.
Click to expand...

oh i'm sure i can think of one person who might...

Heh, yeah, the textures probably haven't been loaded yet on that PS3 pic
Click to expand...

serious question : is there a difference in load times between the two games for the textures?
 
Ariexv said:
Wtf where did anyone ever say anything like that? Any time anyone anywhere even mentions graphics on these forums within 10 posts there's a SS from Uncharted or KZ2. Meanwhile despite Gears 2/Banjo/Gears 1 all being the best games graphically for their time you don't see the same thing happening..... I'm sorry but no1 wants to see 5 pages of Uncharted Screenshots in every thread. It feels like anytime anyone mentions good graphics on anything but the Ps3 some sony fan needs to come running in going "OH LOOK ME2 ME2 I CAN HAVE GOOD GRAPHICS TOO"
Click to expand...

How bout the screen shots come from the fact that when someone says that uncharted or killzone2 look good you get 20 asshats that put them down or say better could be done on 360...

The fact that ps3 and 360 can do great gfx is a given, but when someone actually gets proud of the choice they made because of the quality of the games released some fuckwad hater has to put them down. Stop the hate and the screen shots will disappear.....
 
DCharlie said:
serious question : is there a difference in load times between the two games for the textures?
Click to expand...

No idea, but I didn't notice that much pop ups when playing the PS3-version. And it looked pretty good too, nothing like in that picture imho.
 
The fact that ps3 and 360 can do great gfx is a given, but when someone actuallly gets proud of the choice they made becuse of the quality of the games released some fuckwad hater has to put them down. Stop the hate and the screen shots will dissapear.....
Click to expand...

PROUD of the CHOICE they have made is 99% of the problem.

Until everyone is able to have both consoles, it'll never EVER stop.
Until then it's going to be people who had to chose between one of the two available consoles finding more and more justification on their choice then pushing that on other people.

Me? i'm just here for the free pie. ;)

No idea, but I didn't notice that much pop ups when playing the PS3-version. And it looked pretty good too, nothing like in that picture imho.
Click to expand...

yeah, between the demos i saw no differences beyond aliasing and slight differences in colour schemes. lol - it would be funny if it turned out the Eurogamer PS3 is borked!
 
Ariexv said:
Wtf where did anyone ever say anything like that? Any time anyone anywhere even mentions graphics on these forums within 10 posts there's a SS from Uncharted or KZ2. Meanwhile despite Gears 2/Banjo/Gears 1 all being the best games graphically for their time you don't see the same thing happening..... I'm sorry but no1 wants to see 5 pages of Uncharted Screenshots in every thread. It feels like anytime anyone mentions good graphics on anything but the Ps3 some sony fan needs to come running in going "OH LOOK ME2 ME2 I CAN HAVE GOOD GRAPHICS TOO"
Click to expand...
..

:lol :lol :lol Seriously? Sorry but 360 definitely has an arguably superior line-up for the fall. It might vary from person to person but in the end its going to end up Gears > resistance(again)
Click to expand...

Crysis came out a year ago, it destroys and will continue to destroy any and all games on the Ps3 graphically without there even being a contest.
Click to expand...

Notice the arguably and the differs from person to person, and I'm sorry but you have to be insane if you think sales-wise and even critical acclaim that Resistance is going to match up to Gears
Click to expand...

Gears 2 is going to do Halo 2 like numbers...... Resistance can't possibly hope to get even close to matching it, Fable 1 did 3 million + despite the hype for the game on these forums LBP isn't going...
Click to expand...

Depends on what you think is a curb stomp, to me Gears 2 selling 7 million+ while Resistance 2 probably only does 3 million is a curb stomp, Fable II doing 3 million + while LBP maybe does 1 million.
Click to expand...

360 can and will easily catch up to the Ps3 for the year in the U.S, there's 3 months left, and 360s been embarrassing Ps3 in Japan lately. Microsoft always leans heavily on the Fall to support their
Click to expand...

Ps3 has the least AAA games as well....
Click to expand...

The Xenos IS superior to the RSX.
Click to expand...

I'm just correcting a fact, there's no reason to spread false information.


360-15
Wii-6
Ps3-5
Click to expand...

Actually going by reviews Wii has 6, Ps3 has 5.
Click to expand...

:lol bu buh i have a ratchet avatar!11
 
KeioSquad2 said:
How bout the screen shots come from the fact that when someone says that uncharted or killzone2 look good you get 20 asshats that put them down or say better could be done on 360...

The fact that ps3 and 360 can do great gfx is a given, but when someone actually gets proud of the choice they made because of the quality of the games released some fuckwad hater has to put them down. Stop the hate and the screen shots will disappear.....
Click to expand...

Problem is they post KZ2 and Uncharted pics in unrelated topics. You think I should post Banjo, Alan Wake and Gears 2 pics in PS3 threads?
 
KeioSquad2 said:
How bout the screen shots come from the fact that when someone says that uncharted or killzone2 look good you get 20 asshats that put them down or say better could be done on 360...

The fact that ps3 and 360 can do great gfx is a given, but when someone actually gets proud of the choice they made because of the quality of the games released some fuckwad hater has to put them down. Stop the hate and the screen shots will disappear.....
Click to expand...


I remember back in the day when it was gamers against everyone else. Now its all about whos team you are on, and you are not cool with a certain crowd unless you play gory fps all the time. Or you are not cool with another crowd unless you play Jrpgs all the time.

A lot of stupid BS came with the mass market.
 
DCharlie said:
PROUD of the CHOICE they have made is 99% of the problem.

Until everyone is able to have both consoles, it'll never EVER stop.
Click to expand...

Why should people buy 2 consoles though, especially in an age where there are hardly any exclusive games left......

The problem is that someone or other doesn't like the fact that they might miss out on having the best thing, and they have to make others feel like shit because of it, and that works both ways.
 
Why should people buy 2 consoles though, especially in an age where there are hardly any exclusive games left......
Click to expand...

I'm not saying they should - i'm saying the only way the fanboy wars would ever stop is if everyone had both machines (well, it wouldn't stop but either side wouldn't be annoyed by the other sides pride ! :) )

The problem is that someone or other doesn't like the fact that they might miss out on having the best thing, and they have to make others feel like shit because of it, and that works both ways.
Click to expand...

but it's all still opinion, i'm sure most Sony fans have convinced themselves that Gears 2 is crap and they wouldn't be interested in it in the same way MS fans are trying to convince themselves that they don't want Killzone.

the difference being pointed out is that MS fans are't going into a ton of thread posting picture upon picture of Gears 2, where as the other way round we do get KZ2 pics.

this is the point where some should step into say "why would anyone post pics of Gears 2 ? it looks like crap!"
 
Ariexv said:
Wtf where did anyone ever say anything like that? Any time anyone anywhere even mentions graphics on these forums within 10 posts there's a SS from Uncharted or KZ2. Meanwhile despite Gears 2/Banjo/Gears 1 all being the best games graphically for their time you don't see the same thing happening..... I'm sorry but no1 wants to see 5 pages of Uncharted Screenshots in every thread. It feels like anytime anyone mentions good graphics on anything but the Ps3 some sony fan needs to come running in going "OH LOOK ME2 ME2 I CAN HAVE GOOD GRAPHICS TOO"
Click to expand...

I think people post images of both Uncharted and KZ2 because the how technically advanced the render engines are in comparison to UE3.

I would like to see EA move from UE3 in favor of the engine used in Dead Space. This way the UE3 pissing contests would end, and we would have a better render engine than UE3 for future games.
 
KeioSquad2 said:
Why should people buy 2 consoles though, especially in an age where there are hardly any exclusive games left......

The problem is that someone or other doesn't like the fact that they might miss out on having the best thing, and they have to make others feel like shit because of it, and that works both ways.
Click to expand...

the best thing is relative. the differences between ps3 and 360 games are a fraction of what they were between the psx saturn and n64, ps2 , gc and xbox.

its pretty much fanboy fodder. you are not missing out on anything buying a game on either console. unless one has more content.
 
Same shit, every month. Richard Leadbetter is a cunt who uses selective examples to make it appear that these games look wayyyy better on the 360 when in fact the differences are marginal at best, at worst the game looks marginally better on the PS3. Whateverthefuckever.
 
sprocket said:
I remember back in the day when it was gamers against everyone else. Now its all about whos team you are on, and you are not cool with a certain crowd unless you play gory fps all the time. Or you are not cool with another crowd unless you play Jrpgs all the time.

A lot of stupid BS came with the mass market.
Click to expand...

True, and that shit is just stupid. Why can't people have a choice and just be happy and live with it.......
 
I remember back in the day when it was gamers against everyone else.
Click to expand...

huh?
when was this ever the case?

the only thing different is that it's went from small playground/neighbourhood banter to arguing across the world on the internet.

At least in Europe, there's been fanboy wars going on for years.

Spectrum vs C64 (vs Amstrad CPC vs BBC - not that they were a factor , they sucked! (i'm kidding))
ST vs Amiga
Amiga vs Megadrive
Megadrive vs SNES etc....

Why can't people have a choice and just be happy and live with it.......
Click to expand...

you already answered this question yourself : Because people feel some strange pride in having backed the "right horse" and they wan't everyone to know how RIGHT they were. DEFINITELY RIGHT. DEFINITELY want to play THESE games, not THOSE games over there. You guys are wrong, i am superior at purchasing choices because i was RIGHT. Man, ... how right am i? SO RIGHT.
 
DCharlie said:
MYYHearse was just predicting the future of the thread, it inevitably ends with how great KZ2 is and how much better looking than Crysis it is.

I don't think he was invoking the KZ2 - but i see at least 3 posters actually high fiving and "/thread"Ă­ng :lol

i guess now the defense protocol involves :

+ secret game
+ god of war
+ how bad Gears 2 looks

Sony fans, be sure to tell as many as your friends as you can before black friday please.

but yeah, these threads are becoming pointless, i'm also not sure why Eurogamer bother. This is round 16, i think everyone gets the message that there are minor differences in the X360's favour. The only real message is the differences are getting more and more tiny.

So just lock it up - only one post required in the thread - the score, and then we can all stop dancing the same dance each week.
Click to expand...

lol
qft
 
DCharlie said:
I'm not saying they should - i'm saying the only way the fanboy wars would ever stop is if everyone had both machines (well, it wouldn't stop but either side wouldn't be annoyed by the other sides pride ! :) )



but it's all still opinion, i'm sure most Sony fans have convinced themselves that Gears 2 is crap and they wouldn't be interested in it in the same way MS fans are trying to convince themselves that they don't want Killzone.

the difference being pointed out is that MS fans aren't going into a ton of thread posting picture upon picture of Gears 2, where as the other way round we do get KZ2 pics.

this is the point where some should step into say "why would anyone post pics of Gears 2 ? it looks like crap!"
Click to expand...

The difference is that MS fans all go into the threads where the screen shots are likely to be, and then start bagging on the games...... being to busy to actually post screen shots themselves.

Dude, it is all just a big circle of "mines better then yours" and it hasn't changed since Atari vs Intellivision, some hate and some defend. I guess that's the way it will always be.
 
Dude, it is all just a big circle of "mines better then yours" and it hasn't changed since Atari vs Intellivision, some hate and some defend. I guess that's the way it will always be.
Click to expand...

oh i agree, but i think the point is that it's all down to justification of a choice. If people were totally honest with themselves, they'd want what the other side has that they don't.

It's human nature, the grass is ALWAYS greener and the only way to convince yourself other wise is to hate. And that's manifest here on GAF by the bucket load.
 
DCharlie is my fave poster on GAF right now, sense!

First time I've chimed in on one of these threads but I'm really starting to get fed up with the regular vocal minority of fanboys trying to sway threads and jump in stating there platform/games are the ones to have.

Really why can't everyone just get along.



360 & PS3 owners get to enjoy the most of the same stuff excluding the odd exclusive its almost a similar experience.

It makes me sad that great multiplatform games get overlooked for average overhyped exclusives.

I am hating this tread of shouting which platform people are getting a game for or comparing games or posting comparisons, I HATE comparison threads with a passion.

I mean most of the time any differences are very minor.

I'm gonna be brutal honest here as I see it it really is the Sony only fans that seem to be the insecure ones, going out of their way to sway threads, troll other systems and leap to posting screenshots or finding any old argument to bitch about why there purchase is the right choice for them while it seems much harder to find the same 360 only guys.

Guys you have a decent system just play the games, why is anyone worried x game looks a little bit worse on either system, play on what you prefer for your own reasons and don't force them down everyones throat.

Even the worst versions of the games still look great, if there wasn't a version that looked a tiny bit different no body would care, I really don't get why these comparisons still happen the argument has been beaten to death.

And if its just visuals then why do people ignore the PC (tho the recent Left4Dead if its not on PC then its dogshit statements I've heard have pissed me off also)


and with that my rant is over & I'm off to sleep.

God I hate game comparison articles when there isn't any big differences.
 
 
CoG said:
Same shit, every month. Richard Leadbetter is a cunt who uses selective examples to make it appear that these games look wayyyy better on the 360 when in fact the differences are marginal at best, at worst the game looks marginally better on the PS3. Whateverthefuckever.
Click to expand...
I don't think so. Richard Leadbetter in the ME comparison: "there's barely anything to tell these games apart.”
 
xbhaskarx said:
What the hell? Apparently I will be purchasing the 360 version.
Click to expand...
Apparently the textures take longer to load in on PS3. There are plenty of other comparison screens; it doesn't always look like that.
 
Really why can't everyone just get along.

360 & PS3 owners get to enjoy the most of the same stuff excluding the odd exclusive its almost a similar experience.
Click to expand...

"yes, UNITE AGAINST THE COMMON ENEMY!"
"THE NINTENDO FRONT OF JUDEA!"

(kidding)

I'd be interested in seeing who would, hand on heart say : "i have an X360/PS3 , but damn i'd love to play <game>"

I'd start that thread but, you know, it would appear i've been "perma juniored"
 
DCharlie said:
I'd be interested in seeing who would, hand on heart say : "i have an X360/PS3 , but damn i'd love to play <game>"
Click to expand...
I've seen that quite a lot... not everyone is a fanboy idiot. Sadly the idiots do tend to be the most vocal and argumentative though.
 
Gowans007 said:
DCharlie is my fave poster on GAF right now, sense!

First time I've chimed in on one of these threads but I'm really starting to get fed up with the regular vocal minority of fanboys trying to sway threads and jump in stating there platform/games are the ones to have.

Really why can't everyone just get along.



360 & PS3 owners get to enjoy the most of the same stuff excluding the odd exclusive its almost a similar experience.

It makes me sad that great multi platform games get overlooked for average overhyped exclusives.

I am hating this tread of shouting which platform people are getting a game for or comparing games or posting comparisons, I HATE comparison threads with a passion.

I mean most of the time any differences are very minor.

I'm gonna be brutal honest here as I see it it really is the Sony only fans that seem to be the insecure ones, going out of their way to sway threads, troll other systems and leap to posting screenshots or finding any old argument to bitch about why there purchase is the right choice for them while it seems much harder to find the same 360 only guys.

Guys you have a decent system just play the games, why is anyone worried x game looks a little bit worse on either system, play on what you prefer for your own reasons and don't force them down everyones throat.

Even the worst versions of the games still look great, if there wasn't a version that looked a tiny bit different no body would care, I really don't get why these comparisons still happen the argument has been beaten to death.

And if its just visuals then why do people ignore the PC (tho the recent Left4Dead if its not on PC then its dogshit statements I've heard have pissed me off also)


and with that my rant is over & I'm off to sleep.

God I hate game comparison articles when there isn't any big differences.
Click to expand...

It's not only Sony fans, and this post doesn't help just because it's one sided...

I've read many a thread on these forums way before I ever joined, and most consisted of:

"I can't wait for such and such to come out on PS3, it's going to be killer."
"Yea yea, You say that about every PS3 game, and they all turn out just like such and such, which was garbage."
"No, Random programmer never makes a bad game."
"Dude, if you think that will in any way be better then Gears your crazy."
"Never said it would be better, just that it probably will be great."
"Gears sold how many million, that will be lucky to sell 5 copies because of the small PS3base."

It's always the same shit, both sides are guilty. Fact is, I see it more with 360 fans, it might be vengeance for how ps2 fans were, I have no idea......but it has to stop somewhere.
 
DCharlie said:
"yes, UNITE AGAINST THE COMMON ENEMY!"
"THE NINTENDO FRONT OF JUDEA!"

(kidding)

I'd be interested in seeing who would, hand on heart say : "i have an X360/PS3 , but damn i'd love to play <game>"

I'd start that thread but, you know, it would appear i've been "perma juniored"
Click to expand...

this is the reason I have all the consoles and a PC,

So I can say "i have an X360, PS3, wii, and a PC, and I cant wait to play<game>!!!!"

:D :D :D
 
my ps3 version of Mirror's Edge must be weird because they get this
Mirror_s_Edge_PS3_013.jpg.jpg

and i get this
30dkk7s.jpg


Forgetting that theirs is a digital capture and mine is analog... I notice a couple of differences to say the least
 
Yeah, those Eurogamer shots reek.

I mean, we know by now that the 360 is better for multiplatform games, but the difference isn't that huge. Last time I've seen differences like that were Ubi's 2007 games, Splinter Cell et. al.

Unprofessional at best, biased at worst when they chose these shots.


Also, I'm trying hard not to post the Physx .gifs from Mirror's Edge PC. Don't want to make this discussion more heated as it is already. :lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

  • Poll
PS1 racing graphics face-off
48
1K
roosnam1980 replied
Tekken: Dark Resurrection - PS5 vs. PS3 vs. PSP Emulator (PPSSPP) | Side by Side
Analysis Retro Trailer 
1
278
Danny Dudekisser replied
RexGlue Xbox 360 recomps; a new way to recomp 360 games...kind of
5
631
IbizaPocholo replied
Crystal Dynamics Faces Fourth Round Of Layoffs In Just 12 Months
Business Game Dev 
2
164
Dr. Samuel Hayden replied
[WC] Microsoft and Xbox are "actively investigating" a rampant 'can't connect' issue for backwards compatible Xbox 360 games
2
58
760
Tobimacoss replied
Top Bottom