-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Xenoblade Chronicles X soundtrack got a bad rap.
- Thread starter DeSo
- Start date
ryanofcall
Member
There are some good bits, but there's too much vocals overall, repeating and repeating and repeating and repeating. It's so annoying in a JRPG you're supposed to put 50h+ in.
Gotdatmoney
Member
Its pretty good. It starts awful though and has questionable mixing and music triggers.
TatteredHat
Member
Either you love Sawano Hiroyuki, or you hate him.
victreeb3l
Member
Youre saying this to discredit the XCX soundtrack, but all I see is proof that its incredible
victreeb3l
Member
Bring Sawano back for the next XC. Sylvalum (night) and Oblivia themes were well worth the negatives.
GinoFelino
Member
It's memorable and distinct; two words that you'll rarely use to describe modern game soundtracks. For that alone it should be praised.
That said, I didn't love everything. Anything with vocals is bound to get annoying eventually.
All they have to improve for the next Xenoblade is to just go instrumental-only.
That said, I didn't love everything. Anything with vocals is bound to get annoying eventually.
All they have to improve for the next Xenoblade is to just go instrumental-only.
Adam Prime
hates soccer, is Mexican
I beat the game and I still play it so Ican do something while listening to the OST.
Seriously, I keep coming back to this so I can just listen to the OST haha, so dumb.
Seriously, I keep coming back to this so I can just listen to the OST haha, so dumb.
victreeb3l
Member
Yup, I used to just leave the game on during the title screen.
EVA UNIT 01
Member
Unfortunately i despised it.
Made me stop playing, playing on mute isnt fun.
Made me stop playing, playing on mute isnt fun.
JimboJones
Member
The next Smash Bros has to have a New LA level and those two tracks as it's music options.
Oh man, no wonder I kept thinking of Kill la Kill when I play XCX. Especially the tyrant battle theme sounds like it's straight out of KLK, but I had no idea Sawano did that too. Love it!
So that's the name of that track. Sweet! Thanks, man.
Mockingbird
Member
My 3 favorites:
Theme X: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GE_Fsg7kdJw
????? Theme (vocals only): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifEWNBvX69c&index=22&list=PLLJGSB687CSFiiZy-rS9vWq0GOAiNBC6K
Uncontrollable: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwT-S0Fb4LM&list=PLLJGSB687CSFiiZy-rS9vWq0GOAiNBC6K&index=19
Theme X: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GE_Fsg7kdJw
????? Theme (vocals only): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ifEWNBvX69c&index=22&list=PLLJGSB687CSFiiZy-rS9vWq0GOAiNBC6K
Uncontrollable: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xwT-S0Fb4LM&list=PLLJGSB687CSFiiZy-rS9vWq0GOAiNBC6K&index=19
Newtype-001
Member
I cant remember what its called but the track that plays when you fly in your skell is goat.
Over the rainbow
There's a glorious sight
It's lighting our dreams and I hope we're alright
There's a glorious sight
It's lighting our dreams and I hope we're alright
I hate him. He's a big part of why I stopped playing Xenoblade Chronicles X (along with the weak story and characters).
And tiny font.
and we're done here.
It's just a fact that some people have really awful taste in music. That's fine, it's their problem and doesn't Impact me at all.
This is the only time when people's awful taste was imposed relentlessly onto me and completely ruined an otherwise fantastic piece of media. I just couldn't bear the audio torture of hearing that completely vapid vocal chorus loop for the 1,000th time and had to stop playing.
The crazy thing is it all could be rectified with the simple addition of either a volume control or a on/off option.
This is the only time when people's awful taste was imposed relentlessly onto me and completely ruined an otherwise fantastic piece of media. I just couldn't bear the audio torture of hearing that completely vapid vocal chorus loop for the 1,000th time and had to stop playing.
The crazy thing is it all could be rectified with the simple addition of either a volume control or a on/off option.
Uncontrollable is so scary when you're low level and it randomly comes on.
"SHIT! There's a Tyrant here?"
I don't dislike any of the music, I just dislike the levels that it's played during some cutscenes.
My favorite song is possibly the menu theme when you're choosing what squad to play on. Idk the name of it though
Damn this is so wrong, seeing how taste is really subjective, but I share your frustration lol.
victreeb3l
Member
DONT WORRY ABOUT THE FUTURE ITS ALRIGHT
It's so hard not to sing to this! Actually all of the music in the game gets stuck in my head when playing from Oblivia's "DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUN DUNDUNDUN DUN" at the beginning to both town themes. I sing along.
Also, I found it. This is my favorite song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EmUeqMnWmDY
Aw yeah another melancholia fan :3
victreeb3l
Member
Yup, after a while the music infects your brain and you cant help but sing along.
Black Tar is at the same time one of the best and worst songs in the game. The lyrics are so fucking stupid you cant help but laugh everytime it comes on, and then have the biggest grin on your face while singing along.
Oblivia is top 3. I love the night version.
RadixNegative2
Member
I stopped playing because I couldn't stand the battle music and there was no way to turn it down. The rest of what I heard was fine though.
The only really good tracks were the exploration music, specially Cauldros' the rest of the music was either just decent or very bad, hardly matters anyway because the music was implemented very badly.
You wouldn't hear the lyrics of some songs during battle, would not be able to hear dialogue during cutscenes thanks to the music, what a mess. It all gets worse when you unlock the flying module, and you never get to hear the exploration music properly again.
They really need to get their shit together with the sound mixing for the next game, and get a different composer to.
I can dream.
You wouldn't hear the lyrics of some songs during battle, would not be able to hear dialogue during cutscenes thanks to the music, what a mess. It all gets worse when you unlock the flying module, and you never get to hear the exploration music properly again.
They really need to get their shit together with the sound mixing for the next game, and get a different composer to.
I can dream.
Adam Prime
hates soccer, is Mexican
Its my ringtone when my wife calls me. The intro to that song is perfect for a ring tone.
I agree, Sawano is just an experimental composer. It's unfortunate that the New LA song plays in the HUB world of the game, but the rest of the tracks are amazing for the most part IMO.
This is my favorite track. It gets me all the time.
This is my favorite track. It gets me all the time.
Hey! I like that song.
Honestly for how bad the songs sounded to me listening to them on YouTube I gotta say Xenoblade X's OST ranges somewhere "weird and noticeably experimental, but tolerable" to "I actually like this". Oblivia's daytime theme is actually pretty great and one of the few tracks I actually think are up there with the original Xenoblade Chronicles' level of OST quality.
The only track that bothers me is the flying track. That one gets old REALLY fast and I would have preferred to just listen to the local area's music over a dedicated track whenever I take off.
The only track that bothers me is the flying track. That one gets old REALLY fast and I would have preferred to just listen to the local area's music over a dedicated track whenever I take off.
Sheriff_Battlesnake
Banned
One of my favorite jams in the game. Gets me SO PUMPED AHHH!
Lunafreya Nox Fleuret
Member
Not sure what game you played. There are some excellent themes here and there. I wouldn't call it "fucking garbage". Any xeno game has amazing OST. I dislike that Xeno X has rap and lyrical music everywhere but hey some themes are great.
Arondight
Member
I actually don't like any of Hiroyuki Sawano soundtracks. It's kind of like he puts out 2-3 very fitting tracks according to particular setting or scene and then the rest are a huge mixed bag. His style is consistent throughout all his works at least ranging from Unicorn>AOT>KLK to XCX but I don't enjoy them at all.
These people who think the controversy over the soundtrack is manufactured, or from people who didn't play it - why?
How often is there ever a controversy over a soundtrack? Almost never, right? Why would Nintendo fans suddenly choose this one to be angry about? Isn't it far more likely that massive amounts of people came to the same conclusion and said 'Wow, I really don't like this.' Argue that it's a good soundtrack all you want, but to claim that the detractors are all lying or biased is just bizarre - there's no reason they would be.
This is pretty much my take on it.
The entire thing is too bombastic, too tryhard, and therefore become irritating very quickly in a game that lasts 80+ hours. That's a big problem. And that applies to the field themes (which are okay as songs in a vacuum) just as much as to the vocal songs (which are indefensible). It's like a sauce in a restaurant that's interesting but so strong that it completely drowns out the flavour of the meat and veg etc. And because of the amount of vocal tracks, multiple cutscenes are completely ruined if you had subs off like I did. Yes they could have mixed the sound much better, but if Sawano hadn't plastered vocals in places where he really shouldn't like 'touching song that will obviously play during a cutscene' then it wouldn't have happened.
Worst of all, though, was that the NLA songs began to give me a headache every time I played. It's the only game where I didn't want to turn it on because of the soundtrack, and the only game where I'd stop a play session early having got a headache because of the soundtrack. Literally has never happened before. Only other game to give me actual headaches was the first 5 hours of Metroid Prime 3 while I was getting used to the FPS pointer controls.
Needless to say, in the future when I think of my least favourite soundtracks ever, this one will come to mind alongside New Super Mario Bros for the DS before any others. I strongly disliked it.
How often is there ever a controversy over a soundtrack? Almost never, right? Why would Nintendo fans suddenly choose this one to be angry about? Isn't it far more likely that massive amounts of people came to the same conclusion and said 'Wow, I really don't like this.' Argue that it's a good soundtrack all you want, but to claim that the detractors are all lying or biased is just bizarre - there's no reason they would be.
This is pretty much my take on it.
The entire thing is too bombastic, too tryhard, and therefore become irritating very quickly in a game that lasts 80+ hours. That's a big problem. And that applies to the field themes (which are okay as songs in a vacuum) just as much as to the vocal songs (which are indefensible). It's like a sauce in a restaurant that's interesting but so strong that it completely drowns out the flavour of the meat and veg etc. And because of the amount of vocal tracks, multiple cutscenes are completely ruined if you had subs off like I did. Yes they could have mixed the sound much better, but if Sawano hadn't plastered vocals in places where he really shouldn't like 'touching song that will obviously play during a cutscene' then it wouldn't have happened.
Worst of all, though, was that the NLA songs began to give me a headache every time I played. It's the only game where I didn't want to turn it on because of the soundtrack, and the only game where I'd stop a play session early having got a headache because of the soundtrack. Literally has never happened before. Only other game to give me actual headaches was the first 5 hours of Metroid Prime 3 while I was getting used to the FPS pointer controls.
Needless to say, in the future when I think of my least favourite soundtracks ever, this one will come to mind alongside New Super Mario Bros for the DS before any others. I strongly disliked it.