PocoJoe
Banned
I own both Xbox One X and Ps4 Pro. Stopped using Pc for games a decade ago. That said, if I could only choose one next gen console, I would definitely go for Xbox. It might sound silly, but you should try and test controllers for both consoles - one of the reasons I haven't bought a single multiplatform game on ps4 is because Xbox controller is simply better in my humble opinion.
Xbox uses wrong layout for sticks so I dont think that it can be called better one objectively.
Zero reason to have unsymmetrical sticks, it just makes it weird to hold it, when other parts are symmetrical(case/triggere)