Makoto 1000%. My order of who I would have went with would have been: Makoto > Miss Kawakami > Ann > journalist > doctor > Haru >>>>>>>>> shoji girl [infinite >s] Futuba. I love Haru's design, but her personality just did not click at all with me. She ended up being more "I want to be her" and not "I want to be with her", because lord that girl has fashion sense right up my alley (and my hair at times is very similar to hers).
My Valentine's Day was super calm and sweet because I didn't dare cheat on Makoto. But, I've heard it can be crazy again in P5 if you don't follow that advice. if I even have the time to do a second run, I want to get it set up timing-wise where I could date them all to see the results, or see the solo results of some of the others. I guess that's what YouTube is for, though.