• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Nintendo Direct coming November 12 [Over]

inb4 the 3D World defense force

Galaxy 2 > Galaxy > 64 > 3D Land > 3D World > Sunshine

Granted, I'd rather mess around with Sunshine's awesome controls than play 3D World again, but there's no denying it feels woefully unpolished and even incomplete in contrast to the rest.

It's also undoubtedly the weirdest fucking Mario game ever, which leads to hilarity unto itself (Mario goes to jail! You can kill birds by squirting water at them! I rescue NPCs from the slime and they throw me!) An HD uplift would have me insanely curious not just on what they'd improve on how much they'd retain all that craziness.

So is defense force just a word for 'group of people you disagree with' now
 
Yoshi's Island is the best Mario game.

Yup.

attackonwarawara9lj4j.png

2501888-3351201123-lJHcJ.gif
 

Ozium

Member
people saying snake has no ties to Nintendo is ridiculous.

the first metal gear on nes did much better than the msx version and exposed the series to the west. it was so popular it caused konami to make snake's revenge for nes.

hideo then decided to make his own sequel, mg2 solid snake which was later remade as metal gear solid

so basically MGS franchise wouldn't exist without Snake appearing on NES

y'all are bustas for hating on the legendary solid snake


tl:dr snake confirmed daddy sakurai please all over muh face
 
Seeing as how many 3D Mario fans are divided on which ones are the best, I suppose it's a good thing that Nintendo continues to try new things with Mario games.

My ranking:

3D Marios:

Galaxy 2 > Galaxy > Sunshine > 64

2D/quasi-3D Marios:

3D World > 3D Land > SMB 3 > NSLU > NSMBU > SMW > NSMB > SMB > SMB2
 
Alright we've debated Skyward Sword's controls, whether 3D World is a real 3D Mario or not, let's see...what do you guys think of Federation Force?
It'll be a fun game with a lot of TLC (because Next Level) that will get torn apart by the neckbeards on this forum because it isn't EXACTLY what they want. I expect tons of bitching without ever playing it.
 

Mik317

Member
3D World feels as "2D" as both Galaxies.

"True 3D Mario fans" are just Super Mario 64 fans. If they are fans of Super Mario Sunshine, then, well, they don't actually like Mario platformers but rather like action/adventures with platforming elements.

This is crazy elitist/hipstery lol
 
Seeing as how many 3D Mario fans are divided on which ones are the best, I suppose it's a good thing that Nintendo continues to try new things with Mario games.

My ranking:

3D Marios:

Galaxy 2 > Galaxy > Sunshine > 64

2D/quasi-3D Marios:

3D World > 3D Land > SMB 3 > NSLU > NSMBU > SMW > NSMB > SMB > SMB2

That doesn't work that way, especially considering that Galaxy 2 plays just like 3D World with a bit of Galaxy fluff.
 
Galaxy 2 > Galaxy > 3D World > 3D Land > 64 > Sunshine

All have been from "amazing" to "good" for me.

Also, I don't hate the openness, but I much prefer the linear style they've gone with in recent titles.
 

Malus

Member
It'll be a fun game with a lot of TLC (because Next Level) that will get torn apart by the neckbeards on this forum because it isn't EXACTLY what they want. I expect tons of bitching without ever playing it.

Well why would you buy and play a game if you don't like what you're seeing from it lol.
 

Nanashrew

Banned
was digging through my saved forum pics folder and came across this, which seems oddly fitting after the 5 month or so gap:

attackonwarawara9lj4j.png

kudos to whoever made it :D

also, the less we talk about k.rool the happier I am ¬.¬

It says Nibel right on the image :p

Also wow this thread exploded while I was asleep.
 
This is crazy elitist/hipstery lol

But Sunshine literally plays nothing like any Mario platformer, 2D or 3D - including 64. It really feels more like adventure-platformer of late 1990s-early 2000s than an actual Mario game - all because of level design and world structure.

And that's a shame since Sunshine has the best Mario controls ever. I would kill for any other 3D Mario game with Sunshine controls.
 
Alright we've debated Skyward Sword's controls, whether 3D World is a real 3D Mario or not, let's see...what do you guys think of Federation Force?

I want to see how this turns out. Despite not being the desired Metroid game, I'll still play it because I trust Next Level Games to deliver something fun from this.
 

GamerJM

Banned
Galaxy>3D Land>Galaxy 2>3D World>Sunshine>64

Haven't played 64 and Sunshine in a long time though, maybe it'd be 64>Sunshine if I played them again. Honestly even though they're at the bottom I'd prefer a 64/Sunshine style Mario to a "3D ____," one again, with the former it feels like there's still a lot of room to improve whereas I don't feel like we need another 3D Land/World game again. A Galaxy 3 that expands upon Galaxy 1 and 2 in terms of scope would be awesome though.

I'm not a fan of more open level design in general though. And even though Sunshine's controls are a ton of fun to mess around with thanks to the FLUDD (which is really why the game isn't at the bottom), as a kid I had a bit of a hard time grappling with the controls in 64/Sunshine.
 

MagnesD3

Member
3D World feels as "2D" as both Galaxies.

"True 3D Mario fans" are just Super Mario 64 fans. If they are fans of Super Mario Sunshine, then, well, they don't actually like Mario platformers but rather like action/adventures with platforming elements.

Not really 3d world feels so darn cramped and unexplorable that they dont feel like worlds at all but like levels from a 2d mario game (Which I find extremely unmemorable). The Galaxy games have a sense of grandeur and soul to their levels, many of the places you go actually feel like its own little world unlike 3D world which always feels like going from point A to point B.
 

Mpl90

Two copies sold? That's not a bomb guys, stop trolling!!!
Guys, I could come from the future

1447277105256s.jpg


1447277179038s.jpg


1447278586499.png


There's a thread about a supposed Direct leak on /v/

This...this looks strangely real.

EDIT: Since this is a rumour, manage with caution. It could perfectly be a fake.
 

Litri

Member
Well why would you buy and play a game if you don't like what you're seeing from it lol.

Perceptions... I recently bought NFS for PS4 thinking it would be the NFS Underground I wanted. Well, it was only partially it and i'm greatly dissapointed but oddly I liked what I saw from it on trailers.
 
People saying 3D World/Land aren't 3D Mario are crazy. They are platformers, feature Mario and Mario is able to move in 3 spatial dimensions, therefore they are 3D Marios. Maybe the other 3D Marios had a lot more in common with each other than Land/World but that doesn't make them more 3D Mario.

My personal ranking is:
Galaxy 2 > 3D World > Galaxy > 3D Land > 64

World > Wii > Land 2 > 3 > U > Lost Levels > New > 1 > Land > New 2 > 2

Sunshine omitted as I haven't played it.
 

Mr-Joker

Banned
It'll be a fun game with a lot of TLC (because Next Level) that will get torn apart by the neckbeards on this forum because it isn't EXACTLY what they want. I expect tons of bitching without ever playing it.

I have this image ready for when the game releases.

6c3.jpg


Honestly I am willing to give Federation Force a chance and I trust Next Level to deliver on creating a fun game.
 
Top Bottom