Scrooge McDuck
Member
I much prefer the remake Cloud. He looks more ardent, rugged and dirty, like an actual, trained soldier who has been through some rough courses, someone whom I'm willing to entrust my life under. The other Cloud just looks like Advent Children Cloud, a bishounen who put on the soldier uniform as cosplay and has beautiful, shiny skin and smooth, clean silky hair.
To be fair, Infantryman Cloud was kinda wimpy and incompetent. And that's before they put him in a lab to sleep for 5 years.