Agreed. Crab agree with me less, please. I don't want to get a bad reputation from my first game.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Harry Potter [Mafia] |OT| Yer a werewolf, Arry
- Thread starter SalvaPot
- Start date
Agreed. Crab agree with me less, please. I don't want to get a bad reputation from my first game.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
I don't see anything strange. What is it?
Christina Mackenzie
Member
Never mind then, might be just me.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
b?n?n?sp?c?pr?nc?ss: ?r? y?? R?t?a - y?s ?r n?.
A wild vowel appears!
Christina Mackenzie
Member
Very well, you say you can help us with the Horcruxes. You've been poisoned and die on N6. We've only D5 and D6 to recruit your help. Most likely both Blarg and myself will die N5 and N6. That leaves Kalor alone on D7.
I'm going to politely decline your assistance with regards to the Horcruxes. I can't speak for Blarg or Kalor so you'll have to ask them.
It's unlikely the 3 of us can hunt the Horcruxes in 2 days. I don't want any information you have about them. Is that enough to prove our intentions?
Are you serious? ...
Something about this bothers me, did you try to gather some reactions? Are you looking for someone to react to this playful phrasing?
Also you forgot to convince Kawl of your intentions.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
?t's ? c?ns?n?nt ?n d?sg??s?, d?h. ?t w?s ? "d" b?t th? t?p f?ll ?ff.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
? m??n, ?t's f??rly ?bv???s wh? K?wl ?s ?t th?s p??nt...
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
just to pop out of the game for a bit, this is probably something you should handle via PM. Might not be a bad idea editing that away, you can have special Crab compensation
Christina Mackenzie
Member
Crab if BSP or anyone else doesn't claim Rita we should have a plan for other lynch targets.
I already checked with SalvaPot before carrying it out but I'm ok if you want to reconfirm it with them.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
? kn?w, b?t ? h?v? ? h?nch ? w?nt c?nf?rm?d ?r d?n??d.
No, it reads like you are trying to convince me to offer my information for free. But that's kind of wifom lite. I'm not sure I buy you being able to do/know the information you gave evidence of above for every single person in the game. Which is the only way a full name claim for everyone makes sense.
The piece of information is the knowledge of someone who holds/held a horcrux earlier in the game.
I'm also not convinced it falls completely on the 4 of your shoulders. The existence of the sword and other information leads me to that. Which makes the withholding of information by yall all the more frustrating.
Yeah, Stupefy is currently an unknown factor. Granted, from a wild guess perspective it is more likely that Scum would have it to inhibit conversations, but spells in this game seem to be aligned with the lore character that would have used them. Fortunately the HP Wiki has a list of who has used the spell in the books:
I am not going to write out the full list in case you havenr read the books, Click Here and Scroll Down if interested.
Namely, there are only a few Scum/Neutral characters who have used the spell, and half of them are confirmed to have had another spell (Umbridge has the marking, Bellatrix had Crucio). So Stupefy is likely a town spell, in my estimation.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
? ?gr?? w?th K?wl. ? w?nt t? kn?w th? pr?c?s? d?t??ls ?f th? ?lt?rn?t? w?n c?nd?t??n b?f?r? ? tr?st ?ny?n?. My r?l? ?s q??t? p?ss?bly ? H?rcr?x f?nd?r, ?nd y?t h?w th?y c?ntr?b?t? ?r n?t ?s n?t ?n my r?l? PM. Th?s str?k?s m? ?s s?sp?c???s.
Hey bud! You leave the claiming of my role to me! I'm a dead man walking any how. I'm a loose cannon with no regards for the rules and nothing to lose!
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
?ls?, St?p?fy ?s m?r? ?nn?y?ng th?n ?nyth?ng ?ls?. ?f ?t ?s ? t?wn r?l?, j?st st?p ?s?ng ?t, pl??s?.
The problem I've got with Stupefy as of now:
If it's town aligned, why chose those targets? Blarg, me, Enker, Crab? Why not hit Blarg all day, everyday? He was the most useful while he was stupefied...
Also Blarg and me were simultaniously Crucioed which would be a pretty BIG coincidence after all we had 25+ player at that time.
If it's town aligned, why chose those targets? Blarg, me, Enker, Crab? Why not hit Blarg all day, everyday? He was the most useful while he was stupefied...
Also Blarg and me were simultaniously Crucioed which would be a pretty BIG coincidence after all we had 25+ player at that time.
Christina Mackenzie
Member
Need help with the ?
I agree with Kawl. I want to know the precise details of the alternate win condition before I trust anyone. My role is quite possibly a Horcrux finder, and yet how they contribute or not is not in my role PM. This strikes me as suspipcious.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
Christina Mackenzie
Member
Retroid misinterpreted the alternate win condition. That's how I knew he was one of us. I also made the same mistake when reading it. The way it was worded sounds like it applies to us only but I checked with SalvaPot and that was not the case.
Sorry but I don't think I can do anymore to convince you.
Right now, the Death Eaters have to decide who is a better target tonight, Blarg or me. I don't think it's avoidable but I don't want to make it easy for them either. It's unfortunate I chose it as the key.
Frankly I could post the whole PM in it's entirety and I'm sure there are those among you who would still doubt it.
Let's see what Blarg says. If we're confident one of us can survive the night then I'll go over it with him.
Sorry but I don't think I can do anymore to convince you.
Right now, the Death Eaters have to decide who is a better target tonight, Blarg or me. I don't think it's avoidable but I don't want to make it easy for them either. It's unfortunate I chose it as the key.
Frankly I could post the whole PM in it's entirety and I'm sure there are those among you who would still doubt it.
Let's see what Blarg says. If we're confident one of us can survive the night then I'll go over it with him.
Lord of Castamere
Member
We don't know that Crab and Enker are town. Your narrative is flawed. Blarg is Blarg, of course he was gonna attract attention that night. You're a coincidence but idk. Why would scum risk hitting two people the same night, and why didn't they continue doing it with another role after hypers death?
One of the two of you will survive the night. If we do have a second killer then LoC might protect either of you.
If you are so sure to not achieve this condition, why do make it such a big secret? "V" is dead and one horcrux gone, do you still think scum will resurrect him if they know?
I don't see a reason why you would need to spare us the details of Sirius' involvement in the horcrux search. He wasn't even around anymore when they came up.
LoC can be roleblocked tonight.
TheAwesomePossum
Banned
Oh, do tell.
Christina Mackenzie
Member
14 TheAwesomePossum - Blaise Zabini [confirmed] http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showthread.php?p=188770901#post188770901
20 Blargonaut - Albus Dumbledore [confirmed]
21 Kalor - Ron Weasley [confirmed]
24 Christina Mackenzie - Hermione Granger [confirmed]
25 Lone_Prodigy - Sirius Black [confirmed]
Here's another freebie. Death Eaters will no doubt try and cast doubt over TheAwesomePossum but both Blarg and I were there when he accidentally posted his role PM in it's entirety.
Maybe I've made too big an assumption about my hints but I am in essence a role investigator.
20 Blargonaut - Albus Dumbledore [confirmed]
21 Kalor - Ron Weasley [confirmed]
24 Christina Mackenzie - Hermione Granger [confirmed]
25 Lone_Prodigy - Sirius Black [confirmed]
Here's another freebie. Death Eaters will no doubt try and cast doubt over TheAwesomePossum but both Blarg and I were there when he accidentally posted his role PM in it's entirety.
Maybe I've made too big an assumption about my hints but I am in essence a role investigator.
Just here to say that NO communication outside this game thread is allowed unless you have a role that gives you access to a secret thread on Gafia. As long as that is clear you can post anything you want that doesn't break the game general rules. No PM's, no outside forums, nothing like that.
If me or nin find you are violating this rules you will be modkilled in the spot. WITH MAGIC.
Carry on 8D.
If me or nin find you are violating this rules you will be modkilled in the spot. WITH MAGIC.
Carry on 8D.
TheAwesomePossum
Banned
Yup, can confirm. You can tell by looking at the post because it's edited, a no-go in forum Mafia. If you're still suspicious of me, then you are being deliberately anti-town.
Christina Mackenzie
Member
It's the Hogwarts confirmed list.
Christina Mackenzie
Member
You're still mad because I tried to get you lynched? It's mafia, people make shit reads.
I saw it as well. It could have been made up though...but I doubt it.
TheAwesomePossum
Banned
When I said "you", I meant everyone in general, not you specifically.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
H?v? y?? ?nv?st?g?t?d m? y?t.
Christina Mackenzie
Member
And that tells me it's time to go to bed. See you in 12 hours or so... maybe...
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
T??s?.
Lone_Prodigy
Member
I feel like Gorlak is not helping us. He didn't answer my question about his roleblock last night, and as a neutral survivor his best bet is to align with town or risk being lynched. I don't think the Horcrux crew needs to reveal any more information: my reads and claims list match up pretty well with them and it's just an extra layer of verification.
Pandas has been on my suspect list so I have no problem going for him.
Also my role PM has no information about other players or Horcruxes. So thanks Blarg and Christina for going to bat for me.
While Kalor, Christina, LoC, and Blarg are high on the Death Eater list, we do have LoC's protection, Blarg's protection if he chooses to use it, and Gorlak's roleblock if he wants to be useful to the town.
Pandas has been on my suspect list so I have no problem going for him.
Also my role PM has no information about other players or Horcruxes. So thanks Blarg and Christina for going to bat for me.
While Kalor, Christina, LoC, and Blarg are high on the Death Eater list, we do have LoC's protection, Blarg's protection if he chooses to use it, and Gorlak's roleblock if he wants to be useful to the town.
Sorry guys, but I have talked with other game moderators and what TheAwesomePossum did by posting his Role PM, accidental or not, is clearly against the rules and we clearly said multiple times it was just not allowed and the way its been used presents an unfair advantage. Please be more careful next time, this goes to all the players. I am sorry but I'll have to modkill him.
TheAwesomePossum, Blaise Zabini, has mysteriously disappeared.
Players:
02 [m] MagnumBoy20xx - New
03 [m] Kawl_USC - New
04 [m] Rynam - New
05 [m] TheExodu5 - New
07 [m] Arkos was replaced by Flatearthpandas
08 [f] bananaspaceprincess
10 [m] Gorlak
12 [m] Flame_AC
13 [-] Enker
16 [m] Matt Attack
18 [m] Crab
20 [m] Blargonaut
21 [m] Kalor
23 [m] Lord of Castamere
24 [m] Christina Mackenzie
25 [m] Lone_Prodigy
26 [m] roytheone
Eliminated Players:
01 [m] Retroid - New
06 [f] Swamped
09 [m] TheWorthyEdge
11 [m] Hyperactivity
14 [m] TheAwesomePossum
15 [m] Burbeting
17 [m] Rats Off To Ya
19 [m] kingkitty
22 [m] TheGoddamn
27 [m] Zippedpinhead was replaced by Miracle
28 [f] Sawneeks
17 players remain, majority will be reached with 9 players.
TheAwesomePossum, Blaise Zabini, has mysteriously disappeared.
"Yeah, Zabini, because you're so talented... at posing..."
Ginny Weasley
Welcome to Hogwarts! Now, where to put you?
You are Blaise Zabini
Blaise was prejudiced against Muggles, Muggle-borns, and those who were accepting of them, as made clear when Pansy Parkinson accused him of finding Ginny attractive, Blaise said he would never touch "a filthy blood traitor like her" However, he also did not seem to hold a high opinion of followers of Voldemort, either; in the same conversation, he taunted Draco on his father being outed as a Death Eater. It seemed he was so arrogant that he was more or less indifferent and dismissive of everyone, regardless of status.
You have the power to VOTE! Once per Day you can use the command VOTELAYERNAME to vote against another player.
You are aligned with Hogwarts.
You win when all Death Eater aligned players have been eliminated.
Players:
02 [m] MagnumBoy20xx - New
03 [m] Kawl_USC - New
04 [m] Rynam - New
05 [m] TheExodu5 - New
07 [m] Arkos was replaced by Flatearthpandas
08 [f] bananaspaceprincess
10 [m] Gorlak
12 [m] Flame_AC
13 [-] Enker
16 [m] Matt Attack
18 [m] Crab
20 [m] Blargonaut
21 [m] Kalor
23 [m] Lord of Castamere
24 [m] Christina Mackenzie
25 [m] Lone_Prodigy
26 [m] roytheone
Eliminated Players:
17 players remain, majority will be reached with 9 players.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
Unfortunate. We all make mistakes. I hope Scrafty can find room in FFMafia for Possum still.
flatearthpandas
Member
Well goddamn. Not what i wanted to get home to see.
Blargonaut
Banned
k back brb catching up on slander
Matt Attack
Member
Sorry to see you go, Possum. I hope you can join another game.
Anyways, I'm pretty confused right now about how to proceed. It's good that we got a pretty sizable group of essentially confirmed townies though. Blarg's analysis of the Daily Prophet articles is interesting. I don't think I'd like to vote for Pandas based on that, but it is something worth thinking about. Regarding Horcruxes, I think it's pretty likely the Horcrux win condition applies to all of town, even if most of us didn't know about them at the start. It would seem really weird lore wise if it didn't apply to everybody, not to mention the fact that certain roles (I still think Crab detects Horcruxes) would be weird if it only helped a smal group of players.
Thinking back to Sawneeks and her ability, do we think it's possible that we have multiple swords in play? Most players should be Hogwarts, so it isn't unreasonable to imagine that more than one player got a sword (assuming Sawneeks used her ability each night). She didn't receive any feedback as to whether or not her sword delivery was successful, so there's little reason to think she'd stop trying to hand them out.
I'd still also like to know how the mass name claim will help. Knowing that you guys are probably town helps, but it still seems pretty dangerous for the rest of us.
Anyways, I'm pretty confused right now about how to proceed. It's good that we got a pretty sizable group of essentially confirmed townies though. Blarg's analysis of the Daily Prophet articles is interesting. I don't think I'd like to vote for Pandas based on that, but it is something worth thinking about. Regarding Horcruxes, I think it's pretty likely the Horcrux win condition applies to all of town, even if most of us didn't know about them at the start. It would seem really weird lore wise if it didn't apply to everybody, not to mention the fact that certain roles (I still think Crab detects Horcruxes) would be weird if it only helped a smal group of players.
Thinking back to Sawneeks and her ability, do we think it's possible that we have multiple swords in play? Most players should be Hogwarts, so it isn't unreasonable to imagine that more than one player got a sword (assuming Sawneeks used her ability each night). She didn't receive any feedback as to whether or not her sword delivery was successful, so there's little reason to think she'd stop trying to hand them out.
I'd still also like to know how the mass name claim will help. Knowing that you guys are probably town helps, but it still seems pretty dangerous for the rest of us.
This isnt a TV show where theres only so many characters. Literally everyone, including myself, who is currently a ??? on the board has over 30 Hogwarts related names to choose from, and theres no way to disprove any of us. Scum will pick obscure characters to make sure theres no double claim. And obscure is now believable - Possum was Blaise Zabini and I had totally forgotten who that even was.
Plus Crab said its a bad idea, so thats good enough for me. If he wanted me to reveal my name Id do so immediately though. This game isnt going places right now.
Plus Crab said its a bad idea, so thats good enough for me. If he wanted me to reveal my name Id do so immediately though. This game isnt going places right now.