• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Polygon: Xbox Scorpio will be a ~6 TFLOP system (v PS4K's 4.14), unveil soon, Fall 17

WadeitOut

Member
those initial rumblings were just vague musings. this leak was a lot more specific and illicit more specific responses that COULD result in feedback

...Right. But the Neo leaks had very specific information and came out FIRST.

This idea of Microsoft releasing a controlled leak of specs AFTER the Neo stuff is 10/10 on the derp scale IMO.
 

icespide

Banned
...Right. But the Neo leaks had very specific information and came out FIRST.

This idea of Microsoft releasing a controlled leak of specs AFTER the Neo stuff is 10/10 on the derp scale IMO.

it being a controlled leak doesn't have to have anything to do with timing of Neo leaks. hell they could both be controlled leaks

I just remember waking up that day and seeing multiple sites with lots of details on Scorpio stuff it felt like a damn review embargo had lifted haha
 

sangreal

Member
it being a controlled leak doesn't have to have anything to do with timing of Neo leaks. hell they could both be controlled leaks

I just remember waking up that day and seeing multiple sites with lots of details on Scorpio stuff it felt like a damn review embargo had lifted haha

the kotaku article said they had an unveiling w/ developers last week so that is why there is an avalanche of leaks

We hear that the folks at Xbox have yet to finalize the specs for 2017’s Scorpio, although they briefed third-party publishers on the device during a secret event last week, according to a source.

no need for a conspiracy
 

gaming_noob

Member
It's either part of their marketing (controlled leaks) or MS was caught off guard with how far along the NEO is and had to react by giving the devs more info about their own. I don't remember who it was but a Sony insider here hinted that the latter may be the case.
 

icespide

Banned
the kotaku article said they had an unveiling w/ developers last week so that is why there is an avalanche of leaks



no need for a conspiracy

uh it could still be an intentional leak. that doesn't really change anything. there's no conspiracy. controlled leaks happen all the time
 
IGN unlocked interview with Phil Spencer, they asked him if the console itself was profitable because of all the price cuts and he dodged the question and was like "well uhh, the Xbox division as a whole is profitable so that's good"


Yeah, that's vague but I wouldn't take that as a solid proof.
 

Bastables

Member
Plus their surface book line is making apple fans jealous. MS isn't exactly sitting around doing nothing interesting in the hardware space. Some things may not be super successful but it isn't from a lack of effort.

Seems legit.....

Despite not hitting the market until the middle of the last quarter, Apple sold 2 million units of its iPad Pro, exceeding sales of the Microsoft Surface, which came in at 1.6 million units for the quarter, according to IDC estimates. The research group called the iPad Pro the big winner in a declining tablet market which fell 10 percent year over year.


http://www.theverge.com/2016/2/1/10886720/apple-ipad-pro-outsold-microsoft-surface-sales
 

WadeitOut

Member
Seems legit.....

Despite not hitting the market until the middle of the last quarter, Apple sold 2 million units of its iPad Pro, exceeding sales of the Microsoft Surface, which came in at 1.6 million units for the quarter, according to IDC estimates. The research group called the iPad Pro the big winner in a declining tablet market which fell 10 percent year over year.


http://www.theverge.com/2016/2/1/10886720/apple-ipad-pro-outsold-microsoft-surface-sales

Doesn't really change the fact that the Surface Pro/Book are superior products. But people still buy Bieber albums. Clearly knowledge/taste aren't contagious.
 

Bastables

Member
Doesn't really change the fact that the Surface Pro/Book are superior products. But people still buy Bieber albums. Clearly knowledge/taste aren't contagious.

So they're not jealous because you condescendingly think you're above the imbecile masses?

non sequiturs eh.
 

longdi

Banned
Is surface pro really superior to iPad pro..? It's just another ultra book with touch digitiser, apple pen seems to fulfil that task similarly well.
 
So they're not jealous because you condescendingly think you're above the imbecile masses?

non sequiturs eh.
What he's saying is that brand power and recognition are not equal to objective traits of usability, performance, and flexibility. Similar to how McDonald's is the number one fast food restaurant across the globe, it doesn't mean that McDonald's can objectively be called better tasting or better for you than Chipotle or even Five Guys/In& Out for that matter.

Apple has been a market share leader in the tablet market for a decade. Even when objectively superior products are being released, they still need time to crack the market mind space.
 

gus-gus

Banned
If they announce it at this e3, I think a good launch period would be spring next year latest. I can't see them announcing it anytime after gamescon, that would just be a little out of place especially if launches late next year. At that point I would think the next chance would be at a Microsoft event sometime in spring.
 

AmyS

Member
Maybe this has been discussed before, but lets say MS sells this box at cost.

How much would this 6 tflop box cost?

A console with a 6 tflop gpu isn't enough detail to know how much the box will cost to manufacture, or what it'll cost at retail.
 

etta

my hard graphic balls
Maybe this has been discussed before, but lets say MS sells this box at cost.

How much would this 6 tflop box cost?
No way it will cost more than $499.
I have doubts they ever want to launch another console at $499. But maybe they can bundle a bunch of already released Xbox One games with it like Gears of War 4, Sea of Thieves, Ori and maybe a Forza. Maybe that's too many.
 

Bastables

Member
What he's saying is that brand power and recognition are not equal to objective traits of usability, performance, and flexibility. Similar to how McDonald's is the number one fast food restaurant across the globe, it doesn't mean that McDonald's can objectively be called better tasting or better for you than Chipotle or even Five Guys/In& Out for that matter.

Apple has been a market share leader in the tablet market for a decade. Even when objectively superior products are being released, they still need time to crack the market mind space.
Literally a repeat of the non sequitur argument :

1, poster argues surface pro/book be making people jelly

2, I reply pointing out idc based report that has apples newest tablet out selling various surface sku combined, with which one can infer "they're" not jealous at all.

3, salty non sequiturs about how plebs don't know quality when it's infront of them ensue.

Note the implications the "weaker" ipad pro out selling "powerful" surfaces.
 

SRG01

Member
No way it will cost more than $499.
I have doubts they ever want to launch another console at $499. But maybe they can bundle a bunch of already released Xbox One games with it like Gears of War 4, Sea of Thieves, Ori and maybe a Forza. Maybe that's too many.

The problem is that there's almost no way a 6 TFLOP Polaris can be less than $499 considering that PS4K will most likely be $399 at 4.14 or so. If they released it a full year after the PS4K and if yields were high enough for MS to negotiate a lower cost, then sure.

The biggest cost for the new chip would be the inclusion of eSRAM in the die. Emulating eSRAM is lower on the scale of probabilities as eSRAM can do some operations at extremely high speeds that emulation wouldn't be able to match.
 

Bsigg12

Member
The problem is that there's almost no way a 6 TFLOP Polaris can be less than $499 considering that PS4K will most likely be $399 at 4.14 or so. If they released it a full year after the PS4K and if yields were high enough for MS to negotiate a lower cost, then sure.

The biggest cost for the new chip would be the inclusion of eSRAM in the die. Emulating eSRAM is lower on the scale of probabilities as eSRAM can do some operations at extremely high speeds that emulation wouldn't be able to match.

It will be in the $399-499 price with a Fall 17 launch. That is absolutely attainable with a ~6TF build next year, which is possibly why Microsoft is rumored to have it pegged for next year.

I doubt we'll see eSRAM if they go the route of HBM2. Creating methods in the hypervisor to be able to act like eSRAM for games released prior to a Scorpio support requirement seems like a route Microsoft is much more likely to take.
 

Ushay

Member
I wonder if this leak will hurt Microsoft in the long run...

Hypothetically speaking what if NEO was going to be revealed at E3 at 4+TFLOPS... This might push Sony to upgrade the console further... better cpu/better memory? closing the gap to 6TF while also being the first to market.
Honestly I doubt Sony is worried at this stage with the state of play. They have competition trounced, all they literally need to do is not fuck things up and they are on cruise control.
 

SRG01

Member
It will be in the $399-499 price with a Fall 17 launch. That is absolutely attainable with a ~6TF build next year, which is possibly why Microsoft is rumored to have it pegged for next year.

I doubt we'll see eSRAM if they go the route of HBM2. Creating methods in the hypervisor to be able to act like eSRAM for games released prior to a Scorpio support requirement seems like a route Microsoft is much more likely to take.

What's the bandwidth of HBM2? If it's high enough, I agree that something in the hypervisor may work.
 

AmyS

Member
As a PS4 owner since launch (skipped Xbox One entirely) I'm really excited about Scorpio's potential and glad that Microsoft is apparently doing this for 2017. There's nothing better for the console market than competition, and I wasn't thrilled about the thought of having to wait until 2019 or 2020 for new consoles.

I'm 90% sure I'll pre-order both the Neo and Scorpio, especially given they're not meant to launch at the same time (early 2017 and late 2017, respectively). If NX turns out to be really disappointing (I hope not but, Nintendo) then I'll know that since I'm looking forward to a new console still, Sony and Microsoft will be there.
 

BeforeU

Oft hope is born when all is forlorn.
alright, exactly two weeks from now. We will be 1 sleep away.

Excited, fucking excited
 
Why did Occulus create a separate device for Samsung, because it is from a tech perspective closed like you don't have different manufacturers building different Xbox's.

They didn't. Samsung builds the phones and the shell. Most of the Occulus contribution was in the software stack on Android.

But yea, the Windows Store opening for the Xbox One is basically making it a Steam Machine.

Not really. Games can't be sold as Windows Store apps at all on One. If Scorpio is a full Windows 10 box that you can install any software you want including Steam, Origin, GoG, etc, that is a totally different prospect.

Why do people keep saying this? MS JUST got into the hardware game not too long ago and is improving over time. They are learning and adapting. Why would they want third party to create hardware for them in the console space to dilute the quality and add their own bullshit apps and custom store to?

They've been making console hardware for a decade and a half and it continues to cause them trouble. It's not that strange for them to change things up. They just killed their Windows Phone hardware.

So with the 6TF target in fall 2017, what do you guys expect will this thing cost?

At least $499.

No way it will cost more than $499.
I have doubts they ever want to launch another console at $499. But maybe they can bundle a bunch of already released Xbox One games with it like Gears of War 4, Sea of Thieves, Ori and maybe a Forza. Maybe that's too many.

What if it isn't a console? What if it's a PC with full Win 10 and has 16GB of RAM, an SSD AND a mechanical drive, plus high end fit and finish? Maybe MS cares more about profit per unit. That could easily be in the $800 range.
 

etta

my hard graphic balls
What if it isn't a console? What if it's a PC with full Win 10 and has 16GB of RAM, an SSD AND a mechanical drive, plus high end fit and finish? Maybe MS cares more about profit per unit. That could easily be in the $800 range.
Because they will sell about 2000 units of that.
 
This system will be between $399-$449 and that last number is a high prediction. MS knows that launching a system at $499 is a death wish.

It has also been stated that releasing a 6 teraflop system in fall 2017 at that price point is attainable. It's a big thread so not everyone will read all the info provided.
 

Leyasu

Banned
If they announce it at this e3, I think a good launch period would be spring next year latest. I can't see them announcing it anytime after gamescon, that would just be a little out of place especially if launches late next year. At that point I would think the next chance would be at a Microsoft event sometime in spring.


It pains me to say it. But I don't see this coming until September next year .... Launching with halo 3 anniversary.
 

darkinstinct

...lacks reading comprehension.
The problem is that there's almost no way a 6 TFLOP Polaris can be less than $499 considering that PS4K will most likely be $399 at 4.14 or so. If they released it a full year after the PS4K and if yields were high enough for MS to negotiate a lower cost, then sure.

The biggest cost for the new chip would be the inclusion of eSRAM in the die. Emulating eSRAM is lower on the scale of probabilities as eSRAM can do some operations at extremely high speeds that emulation wouldn't be able to match.

HBM2 is like eight times faster than ESRAM. 196 GB/s peak to 2.048 GB/s peak. A single stack of RAM is at 256 GB/s still faster than ESRAM. Emulation is no problem. And just because it has more TFlops doesn't mean it is more expensive. The APU in a console is 30 % of its production cost.
 
What he's saying is that brand power and recognition are not equal to objective traits of usability, performance, and flexibility. Similar to how McDonald's is the number one fast food restaurant across the globe, it doesn't mean that McDonald's can objectively be called better tasting or better for you than Chipotle or even Five Guys/In& Out for that matter.

Apple has been a market share leader in the tablet market for a decade. Even when objectively superior products are being released, they still need time to crack the market mind space.

On the other hand, who is to say people consider those features more important than the connectivity and interface of the Apple device? I would say there is an issue of diminishing returns in terms of the value of having higher spec tablets for a lot of people. It is also not surprising though, Apple has become a far more successful brand than MS. MS pretty much lives on its monopoly in the software space, rather than the strength of its brand.
 
It pains me to say it. But I don't see this coming until September next year .... Launching with halo 3 anniversary.

A H3 Anniversary really doesnt make sense. And MS&343 would screw it up anyway.

But at least its not wrong to expect another Halo announcement at E3 besides Halo Wars 2 stuff when i read this sentence from the latest Weekly Bulletin:

The Halo Wars 2 team is anxiously gearing up for E3, where the game will indeed be playable. There’s also – well, I can’t talk about more just yet.
 

darkinstinct

...lacks reading comprehension.
Nope, that's fall 2018.

They have their tech in place, they have the story laid out, all they really have to do is two years of creating Masterchief levels. It can easily be done. And I don't think MCC sold good enough to warrant another remake. It's not like Halo 3 looks bad nowadays, especially after getting the 1080p/60 treatment. I really don't see that game being able to sell again after having rereleased it three years ago (in late 2017).
 

Leflus

Member
A H3 Anniversary really doesnt make sense. And MS&343 would screw it up anyway.

But at least its not wrong to expect another Halo announcement at E3 besides Halo Wars 2 stuff when i read this sentence from the latest Weekly Bulletin:
Halo: Spartan Fisticuffs, baby!

(Secretly hoping for a Halo RPG game)
 
Top Bottom