Support NeoGAF

[BulletBees]

I don't like how the Marvel movies can't go five minutes without cracking a joke. Nothing seems to have "urgency" when it's just jokes the whole time. That being said I think the Winter Solider nailed the serious tone with humor quite well. If this is what he means by changing the tone to be more like that then I am game. I'm the weirdo who has always liked DC comics and movies more than the Marvel stuff.

 

[Mr. Poolman]

I don't like how the Marvel movies can't go five minutes without cracking a joke. Nothing seems to have "urgency" when it's just jokes the whole time.

Ahh the good old steaks.

 

[vaderise]

Thor 2. I like Thor 2.

 

[DeathyBoy]

Gaf on MOS: MOS sucks why Superman kill lol?
Gaf on BvS: Why is Superman killing mentioned/Batman kills people lol.
Gaf on JL: Why isn't Batman killing people lol?

Gaf is the best place for self entitled film critics to talk shite.

 

[Gordon Shumway]

Thor 2. I like Thor 2.

 

[neorej]

Thor 2. I like Thor 2.

 

[TissueBox]

Hope and optimism? Pfff

 

[Mortimer Brewster]

Which was especially bad, since apparently the script was basically just Secret Origin. Which is an actual good story

*cough Marc Guggenheim cough cough

 

[SpaceWolf]

Thor 2. I like Thor 2.

 

[Blader]

The fuck? Johns is a producer and writer on these films, he's now essentially an even more hands-on Feige. These films very well could still suck, but some of you all are just having knee-jerk negative reactions to the mere uttering of "DCEU" without bothering to actually comprehend what's happening.

I've never really liked Johns' comics for the most part, so while I'm more optimistic about the overall change of direction in the DCEU (and the acknowledgment that they've fucked it for the last three movies), Johns being THE guy in charge now doesn't inspire a ton more confidence in me than when Snyder was THE guy.

 

[neorej]

I'm going to walk out of the theatre if Justice League is going to be The Ezra Miller Stand Up Comedy show.

 

[Sephzilla]

Lets be frank, this could be called DC Reactionary Universe.

No lies detected

 

[Kinitari]

My biggest issue wasn't with the tone of the movies. Dark and gritty is fine. Dark humour is fine. Dark whatever, all fine. Even a Batman who kills? Fine. The issue with me has always been: plot and dialogue.

I can't think of any movies I've consistently been disappointed mid movie with a plot than I have with DC movies after Nolan Batman. Suicide squad made it as far as half way before the plot started being just... The worst, and the dialogue started to get bad much earlier. I won't even touch BvS in this post, aside from mentioning there is a reason half the posts in the thread have made fun of it, and it's not the tone.

Get better writers. That's 90% of the issue for me. No more Martha's. No more... Everyone's lines except Deadshots in SS. No more 1 dimensional villians.

 

[NipplesAndToes23]

Hmm, we shall see. I'm disappointed by Batman v. Superman and Suicide Squad, Suicide Squad more because the trailers were good. I think I still won't end of seeing Justice League regardless unless someone I know can confirm it's good. the trailer didn't do shit for me.

 

[Ross61]

My biggest issue wasn't with the tone of the movies. Dark and gritty is fine. Dark humour is fine. Dark whatever, all fine. Even a Batman who kills? Fine. The issue with me has always been: plot and dialogue.

I can't think of any movies I've consistently been disappointed mid movie with a plot than I have with DC movies after Nolan Batman. Suicide squad made it as far as half way before the plot started being just... The worst, and the dialogue started to get bad much earlier. I won't even touch BvS in this post, aside from mentioning there is a reason half the posts in the thread have made fun of it, and it's not the tone.

Get better writers. That's 90% of the issue for me. No more Martha's. No more... Everyone's lines except Deadshots in SS. No more 1 dimensional villians.

Both Chris Terrio and David Ayer are great writers. So I don't know what to tell you.

 

[Lord Virgin]

Wrong, they should make it darker. No jokes policy in full effect. Mad Max Injustice JL movie plz.

 

[HStallion]

Wrong, they should make it darker. No jokes policy in full effect. Mad Max Injustice JL movie plz.

As long as they don't have Batman raped.

 

[Kinitari]

Both Chris Terrio and David Ayer are great writers. So I don't know what to tell you.

Maybe 'better' is the wrong word. But it's glaringly apparent that they just don't understand how to give the source material any legitimacy. I look at any of the Nolan Batman movies and the scripts are all just so much better. I don't even like Rises/Returns all that much, but I can appreciate that they at least had more substance than basically any other DC movie in the last decade. And I don't think a difference in tone is the Delta here.

 

[Mighty Chin]

Thor 2. I like Thor 2.

As well you should.

 

[Inferno313]

Wrong, they should make it darker. No jokes policy in full effect. Mad Max Injustice JL movie plz.

Mad Max has a lot more fun and humor than BvS though.

 

[shingi70]

Maybe 'better' is the wrong word. But it's glaringly apparent that they just don't understand how to give the source material any legitimacy. I look at any of the Nolan Batman movies and the scripts are all just so much better. I don't even like Rises/Returns all that much, but I can appreciate that they at least had more substance than basically any other DC movie in the last decade. And I don't think a difference in tone is the Delta here.

But those Nolan films are terrible Batman movies, Begins is awesome but the preceding while great films, suck as Batman films if that makes sense.

 

[Rooster12]

I've never really liked Johns' comics for the most part, so while I'm more optimistic about the overall change of direction in the DCEU (and the acknowledgment that they've fucked it for the last three movies), Johns being THE guy in charge now doesn't inspire a ton more confidence in me than when Snyder was THE guy.

Well....Kevin Feige's comics are.........yeah...

It's a different ballgame.

 

[Kinitari]

But those Nolan films are terrible Batman movies, Begins is awesome but the preceding while great films, suck as Batman films if that makes sense.

I think I understand what you're saying, in that - the movies aren't in the same... Scope? As the best Batman source material - like I can't see Doomsday or the like in a Nolan film, at least not portrayed well. And we don't really get a sense of Batman's genius in the movies either, they make him more of an everyman - but a rich one.

I think I don't hold the source material as sacred however, for example I didn't care that Batman was killing people in BvS - it matters more to me that I enjoy the movie and an buying what the story is selling. The Nolan movies were Batman enough, and the plot, directing, and dialogue did what it needed to do to make me 'buy' it.

I was bummed about Ras Al Ghul's nerf, but If they really did a good job representing him, but the movie sucked, then it wouldn't matter to me.

 

[Mr. Poolman]

Okay.

Why do have comic book movies have to be all serious to be considered mature?

I think this idea of "mature heroes" came on full force from the mid 80s. I mean, comics ARE goofy, that is kind of the charm, on comics you can find a blonde norse good who speaks to hippies; and a dog with a cape that can fly and shoot lasers out of its eyes. Even Batman is fun because how impossible it is.

I don't buy this idea that you can't have fun with these properties. There is nothing wrong with a bit of sillyness on your life, and trust me, comics can get really silly.

 

[Ninjimbo]

If it becomes like Marvel's brand of capeshit, I'm out.

 

[George Oscar Bluth II]

Okay.

Why do have comic book movies have to be all serious to be considered mature?

I think this idea of "mature heroes" came on full force from the mid 80s. I mean, comics ARE goofy, that is kind of the charm, on comics you can find a blonde norse good who speaks to hippies; and a dog with a cape that can fly and shoot lasers out of its eyes. Even Batman is fun because how impossible it is.

I don't buy this idea that you can't have fun with these properties. There is nothing wrong with a bit of sillyness on your life, and trust me, comics can get really silly.

 

[Sephzilla]

On that note Batman TAS is the perfect mix of serious and silly

 

[What did he mean by this?]

I pretty much hate this interview. Using a phrase like "fast-forwarding" is not something a Kevin Feige would do. It does not inspire confidence since one of the main complaints was the "fast-forwarding" to the team movies instead of doing solos.

Plus the part about Batman coming to terms with his "branding and near murder of Superman" is confusing. Do Berg and Johns not even watch BvS? This Batman is a stone-cold killer when he feels like it. Ignoring the elephant in the room is not fixing it. Will this Batman just be an entirelg different character all of the sudden in the universe?

Or maybe that a juicy retcon is coming where Batman didnt kill anyone in BvS at all. That flipped then crashed through car? Those goons crawled out the wreckage. The turrets parkes in front of the warehouse? Batman fired concussive rounds that ignited small controlled fires that knocked out the thugs with minor burns. The guy who's head he crushed with the front tire of the Batmobile (or the guy who's head he exploded with a crate)? That was Metallo yo he survived.

I'd ragher DC stic to their guns

 

[Inferno313]

Okay.

Why do have comic book movies have to be all serious to be considered mature?

I think this idea of "mature heroes" came on full force from the mid 80s. I mean, comics ARE goofy, that is kind of the charm, on comics you can find a blonde norse good who speaks to hippies; and a dog with a cape that can fly and shoot lasers out of its eyes. Even Batman is fun because how impossible it is.

I don't buy this idea that you can't have fun with these properties. There is nothing wrong with a bit of sillyness on your life, and trust me, comics can get really silly.

But how will I be able to feel confident about my interests if they aren't DEATHLY SERIOUS?!? I don't want people thinking I'm into silly shit when I'm picking up my favorite DC Cinematic Murderverse T-Shirts from Hot Topic!

There we go. Nice and serious.

 

[Ross61]

I pretty much hate this interview. Using a phrase like "fast-forwarding" is not something a Kevin Feige would do. It does not inspire confidence since one of the main complaints was the "fast-forwarding" to the team movies instead of doing solos.

Plus the part about Batman coming to terms with his "branding and near murder of Superman" is confusing. Do Berg and Johns not even watch BvS? This Batman is a stone-cold killer when he feels like it. Ignoring the elephant in the room is not fixing it. Will this Batman just be an entirelg different character all of the sudden in the universe?

Or maybe that a juicy retcon is coming where Batman didnt kill anyone in BvS at all. That flipped then crashed through car? Those goons crawled out the wreckage. The turrets parkes in front of the warehouse? Batman fired concussive rounds that ignited small controlled fires that knocked out the thugs with minor burns. The guy who's head he crushed with the front tire of the Batmobile (or the guy who's head he exploded with a crate)? That was Metallo yo he survived.

I'd ragher DC stic to their guns

Thought they pretty much said that they will address it and not ignore it.

 

[okdakor]

Or maybe that a juicy retcon is coming where Batman didnt kill anyone in BvS at all.

I'll pay to see their next movie if it starts with Superman waking up from a nightmare screaming. He then describes it to Lois, "you won't believe how stupid it was, Bruce was branding and shooting people, he tried to kill me too. But thanks to you screaming his mother's name he stopped LOL.".
Then they joke about it, thinking he had the nightmare because of the fondue they ate at Bruce's the night before.
They're interrupted by a call from Jimmy Olsen, Perry wants them for a story. Clarks smiles.

 

[Inferno313]

I pretty much hate this interview. Using a phrase like "fast-forwarding" is not something a Kevin Feige would do. It does not inspire confidence since one of the main complaints was the "fast-forwarding" to the team movies instead of doing solos.

Plus the part about Batman coming to terms with his "branding and near murder of Superman" is confusing. Do Berg and Johns not even watch BvS? This Batman is a stone-cold killer when he feels like it. Ignoring the elephant in the room is not fixing it. Will this Batman just be an entirelg different character all of the sudden in the universe?

Or maybe that a juicy retcon is coming where Batman didnt kill anyone in BvS at all. That flipped then crashed through car? Those goons crawled out the wreckage. The turrets parkes in front of the warehouse? Batman fired concussive rounds that ignited small controlled fires that knocked out the thugs with minor burns. The guy who's head he crushed with the front tire of the Batmobile (or the guy who's head he exploded with a crate)? That was Metallo yo he survived.

I'd ragher DC stic to their guns

A quick "Ctrl-F" of the interview suggests that the term "fast-forward" is not uttered once. Are you referring to the part where Johns said they adjusted the Justice League script so it gets to a point of hope and optimism more quickly? Because that sounds like Snyder came up with another dark, broodfest, and that Johns pulled things back in-line, which is exactly the type of thing Feige does at Marvel.

I don't think them saying that they're going to address Batman's violence is a retcon by any means at all, I think they're saying the opposite. Likely further exploring the character development Bruce experiences at the end of BvS where he moves on from his overly-brutal methods. BvS implies that this level of brutality was a new development for this Batman, due to becoming increasingly similar overtime, so it absolutely makes sense for them to explore this and walk him back a bit in this film.

 

[Dalek]

Okay.

Why do have comic book movies have to be all serious to be considered mature?

I think this idea of "mature heroes" came on full force from the mid 80s. I mean, comics ARE goofy, that is kind of the charm, on comics you can find a blonde norse good who speaks to hippies; and a dog with a cape that can fly and shoot lasers out of its eyes. Even Batman is fun because how impossible it is.

I don't buy this idea that you can't have fun with these properties. There is nothing wrong with a bit of sillyness on your life, and trust me, comics can get really silly.

Scott Snyder is a very talented storyteller, I agree.

Unappreciated post.

 

[Blader]

Well....Kevin Feige's comics are.........yeah...

It's a different ballgame.

The only point of reference I (or anyone for that matter) have for Johns is his comics and TV work, so my skepticism toward his impact on the movies is based on my lukewarm reaction to his comics and TV writing. Just like a lot of people's optimism about Johns' impact on the movies is based on their liking his other writing.

 

[What did he mean by this?]

A quick "Ctrl-F" of the interview suggests that the term "fast-forward" is not uttered once. Are you referring to the part where Johns said they adjusted the Justice League script so it gets to a point of hope and optimism more quickly? Because that sounds like Snyder came up with another dark, broodfest, and that Johns pulled things back in-line, which is exactly the type of thing Feige does at Marvel.

I don't think them saying that they're going to address Batman's violence is a retcon by any means at all, I think they're saying the opposite. Likely further exploring the character development Bruce experiences at the end of BvS where he moves on from his overly-brutal methods. BvS implies that this level of brutality was a new development for this Batman, due to becoming increasingly similar overtime, so it absolutely makes sense for them to explore this and walk him back a bit in this film.

The first part is my bad sorry

But the 2nd ...No.
"Such as torturing criminals and nearly killing Superman...and KILLING A BUNCH OF OTHER PEOPLE"
Maybe Im being judgemental or picky, but him saying that last part would put me at peace.
If they cant acknowledge it here, then how could I expect them to 'explore' it in the films?

In fact, that was one of my main problems with BvS in the first place. It had a scene of Alfred criticizing Bruce for branding and all this focus on branding....while Batman is killing people. Talk to him about that, Alfred!

Johns and Berg are being Alfreds.

 

[Reizo Ryuu]

In fact, that was one of my main problems with BvS in the first place. It had a scene of Alfred criticizing Bruce for branding and all this focus on branding....while Batman is killing people. Talk to him about that, Alfred!

Johns and Berg are being Alfreds.

That would seem really stupid and out of place imo, they've been doing this for years, in the branding scene bruce even remarks "we've always been criminals", and this alfred doesn't strike me as the type to be a whiny bitch for years (decades?) on the subject of bruce's kill policy. If he ever brought it up, it's well in the past now, heck he brings up the brand and then never again.

 

[Schweinehund]

If it becomes like Marvel's brand of capeshit, I'm out.

If it's anything like John's comics, it will be serious but not bleak. Probably more along the lines of the x-men films.

Really wish there was a DC unlimited so I could throw out some rec's. Every comic fan should read JSA and his GL run, as well as 52.

 

[Slayven]

There's no "MARTHA" in the comics.

Comics win by default.

Barry allen's Oedipus complex comes close

 

[BKatastrophe]

Barry allen's Oedipus complex comes close

I dislike Barry Allen a whole lot as well, but Oedipus complex is a bit of an overexaggeration, yeah?

 

[sleepykyo]

It wasn't the tone, it was the execution.

 

[broncobuster]

If it's anything like John's comics, it will be serious but not bleak. Probably more along the lines of the x-men films.

Really wish there was a DC unlimited so I could throw out some rec's. Every comic fan should read JSA and his GL run, as well as 52.

For all the Marvel vs DC nonsense, no Unlimited subscription service is the one area where it's like, just copy their service already. MU is awesome.

 

[Slayven]

I dislike Barry Allen a whole lot as well, but Oedipus complex is a bit of an overexaggeration, yeah?

The only way they could build him since his come back is revolving around his mother

 

[shingi70]

The only way they could build him since his come back is revolving around his mother

The show gets annoying in that regard, but the comics hasn't really touched on it since flashpoint.

 

[BKatastrophe]

The only way they could build him since his come back is revolving around his mother

The motivation is more that he wants to find the killer and get justice. In the show, he just wants to get his dad out of prison. Like, is Bruce wanting to find who killed his parents an Oedipus Complex, too?

The show gets annoying in that regard, but the comics hasn't really touched on it since flashpoint.

Also this

 

[Bleepey]

I pretty much hate this interview. Using a phrase like "fast-forwarding" is not something a Kevin Feige would do. It does not inspire confidence since one of the main complaints was the "fast-forwarding" to the team movies instead of doing solos.

Plus the part about Batman coming to terms with his "branding and near murder of Superman" is confusing. Do Berg and Johns not even watch BvS? This Batman is a stone-cold killer when he feels like it. Ignoring the elephant in the room is not fixing it. Will this Batman just be an entirelg different character all of the sudden in the universe?

Or maybe that a juicy retcon is coming where Batman didnt kill anyone in BvS at all. That flipped then crashed through car? Those goons crawled out the wreckage. The turrets parkes in front of the warehouse? Batman fired concussive rounds that ignited small controlled fires that knocked out the thugs with minor burns. The guy who's head he crushed with the front tire of the Batmobile (or the guy who's head he exploded with a crate)? That was Metallo yo he survived.

I'd ragher DC stic to their guns

I agree with you that they should stick their guns. It would be nice for the later movies to explore the death of Robin, I actually think it's kinda cool to see a story be told from film to film. Suicide Squad kinda failed in that regard cos it would have been cool to see what exactly the Joker (and possibly Harley) did to kill the Robin and why Batfleck gives zero fucks.

 

[Just_myles]

edit: lttmp?

the anti-Martha equation.

legion of super Martha

Martha one million

Whatever happened to the Martha of tomorrow

Anyway, Johns is the guy for the job if there ever was one. They need serious course correcting, like now. Mos and BvS were so bad. I hope they figure it out and just get rid of Snyder. Demote his ass to a fight coordinator/director/whatever. Just minimize his role. He totally fucked shit up.

 

[Malyse]

So.

Wonder Woman confirmed a mess?

 

[SJRB]

So.

Wonder Woman confirmed a mess?

...what?

 

[Malyse]

...what?

The pair admitted many of those changes are first going to be first seen in Zack Snyder’s Justice League, which is almost done filming for a November 2017 release. Berg admitted after seeing the reactions to Batman v Superman, they “accelerated the [Justice League] story to get to the hope and optimism a little faster.”

Since they know they fucked up the universe and the fix won't be in till JL, that would imply that WW is unchanged. We also had an unconfirmed rumor that WW was no good very bad.

 

[BKatastrophe]

Since they know they fucked up the universe and the fix won't be in till JL, that would imply that WW is unchanged. We also had an unconfirmed rumor that WW was no good very bad.

By the time Johns had stepped in, wasn't WW already in post?