Almost none of the things you described (except perhaps the spider tank) could have developed from having seen more of it, though, since they are statements about GG's pedigree rather than about Horizon.
Still, it is always good to approach something from someone you didn't like before with caution. Guerrilla has had some changes in staff for the project, but it is obviously not a guarantee that the game will have good quests and a good story. That's what reviews generally are for: to get a close-to-final verdict on the quality of such things as story, gameplay functionality, and quest design, since you can't show off the depth of the story or the variety of quests off very well (though in some way you can do a better job than GG has done until now) in preview footage without spoiling those aspects for the player. TL;DR always wait for trusted impressions and reviews if you are uncertain about a game.
Nah, I'm sold on the game enough to take the risk. Like I said, if nothing else, I expect to find the world enticing and interesting. If the game fails in all other aspects, but succeeds in that one, I will be satisfied.
But that just means I'm easy to please, since I'm allowing them a ton of room to fuck up, mostly because I expect them to.
And if that's what they want you to think and you are wrong will you then say well we saw that twist coming a mile away?
No?
How the heck did you jump all the way to this conclusion LMAO. The point is you cannot judge a plot based on assumption at a very high level. How it unfolds, is told, and the twists and turns along the way, the execution are what matters.
Saying the Plot is generic is Nothing criticism. The god fathers plot is simple and been there done that, but it's still an all-time great
Well, you keep using "World's greatest literature" as a defense for why I shouldn't assume this will be crap, and now used a specific example with Godfather, so if you're argument isn't "it could be some of the worlds best writing, wait until it's proven it's not", I'm genuinely not sure what you're trying to say here.
The criticism I'm putting forth (which is the wrong word to use anyway. I don't know the story yet, I have nothing to criticize. What I'm putting forth is an
expectation) isn't that the plot is generic, but that the plot will be shallow and predictable. I expect that the bad dictator guy will just be an paper thin asshole, for example, with no greater depth to him beyond that he is an asshole. Which might be fine for this game if they play it off right, but you know, not the Godfather.
It could be some of the world's greatest writing, sure, the same way I could win the lottery today, but I'm not counting on it.