Seriously? First link is the survey hijack thing again, second is nothing but referring to earlier posts (i.e the first link again?)
I did say "just for fun", the timing amused me.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Legend of Zelda Mafia |OT| A Lynch to the Past
- Thread starter Sawneeks
- Start date
I still don't remember Overwatch
melonrabbit
Member
Vote count ?
hmm mabby ty too
kyan is confused many lynch but only one is kill
Kyan still scummy
melonrabbit
Member
I honestly thought you had already voted.
I did as well actually.
Explain the survey hijack as W/W
no is town
;_;
I hoped I had managed to switch it up a bit when I decided to bus everyone still alive on my team.
A vote on Bronx probably.
What are you feeling right now?
That makes three of us
Fluff and more fluff. Didn't stand out to me at the time. When you brought it up I still didn't think much of it and actually it seems a weird thing to focus on.
Apologies for the vanishing act, but classes started up again yesterday for me
Scum reads are still the same with Nin and Stanley tied to most likely to be scum.
You are not even here most of the time mate.
I don't mind you voting for me but you will have to put in some more work into those posts.
AbsolutBro
Member
What the shit is going on here?
So he just accidentally posted the same fluff as a scum mate, thinking it was a bigger topic?
By "at the time" did you mean D1 or D2?
It's a gut read. Something about his recent posts feels off. I can't place my finger on it tho.
melonrabbit
Member
Peace.
I am aware of the game I've played.
Sophia gives me much pause. As do you. You don't feel authentic. Your busing of each other seems unusually half-hearted. We've joked about the odds, but likely a vocal and prominent figure in the thread is scum. I worry there is two.
Melon posted fluff and acohrs latched on for more fluff. That's all I see. I don't understand why teammates can't or wouldn't do that, it's the free-est posting period of the game. You seem to have completely written melon off as a suspect based on that one fluff post, I don't get it.
"At the time" means D1. Obviously we didn't know acohrs was scum then but even when you brought it up again on D2(?) it looked like nothing to me.
It can't be manufactured either? why can't it be manufactured.
I can easily see acohrs just not reading the in game thread and posting that.
Generally tone wise melon also seems ok. Scum!melon will try to be quite aggressive and have this awkward connection to the game, as if she's not really playing the same game. Quickly reading over mini mafia A) She's way too serious, never joking B) She's rarely, if ever, doubting her reads and tunnels when she needs to. In mini she went hard after me when the tide started to turn against me. Kinda reminiscent of scum!Splinter who'll find a target and go hardcore against them.
She's obviously not going to play scum quite like she did in mini again, but from the last live mafia I played against her as scum she was also quite serious and pushed hard for a specific vote (don't quite remember for whom) on D1.
This one is the one I keep coming back to. Why do I have a bad feeling about this post, Ty?
Talk more about your worries
Aren't you supposed to tell us
But it's no fun that way! Gosh, you drama killer. ;_;
It feels like he just tried to justify any which way melon flipped there. Like if she flips scum he can go "Oh, see? She played it differently from Mini Mafia.", and if she flips town "Oh see? Told you she was playing differently from her scum self."
melonrabbit
Member
I thought we were still talking about pizza.
melonrabbit
Member
But in all seriousness, please be a little more specific as what more you'd like.
It could, but why would it be manufactured? It doesn't make sense to manufacture something that small.
I don't think acohrs would miss it had it been his mate either.
-------------------------------------------------
Then vote for me. You've scum read me since D1
This is hilarious coming from you. What I always come back to reading you is why every read you make is drowning in doubt.
The gist of the read is still that I think she's town and I argue the potential flaw because that read hinges on her scum game being mostly unchanged.
Sure. Why not? Carpe Diem and all. Plus I'd be a hypocrite given I told someone (AB I think?) something similar on Day 1 anyhow.
Vote: Ty4on
I know you of all people aren't lecturing me on post content.
I wish she cared more about the game (and I still wanna hear more about your worries), but melon's shade towards me feels like Overwatch:
http://neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=228677632&postcount=2204
Not quite Overwatch levels, but there's joy in her posts. I don't think she'd be acting like this knowing I'm town/neutral and that she carefully has to move votes towards me.
http://neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=228677632&postcount=2204
Not quite Overwatch levels, but there's joy in her posts. I don't think she'd be acting like this knowing I'm town/neutral and that she carefully has to move votes towards me.
melonrabbit
Member
Is a strong, risky or emotional response?
The two of you are acting strangely. Ty, you've been holding back and being cautious, as previously pointed out by Splinter. You criticized me in Mini Mafia for not being curious or inquisitive and here I would hold you to the same standard. You've been vocal, yes, but not as attacking or biting as I expect from you.
Sophia can't make a stance--and simply saying that statement is very troubling to me. She has been very easy on me, holding back criticisms and not willing to call a spade a spade. I'm more comforted by the consistency of Cabot calling me on my bullshit. I don't consider her attempt finally getting around to voting for you now authentic. Especially, when it was just pointed out.
I feel like collectively there's something crucial missing in both your play style.
Those would be my feels.
Risky, as I'll probably die on this hill one way or another. Emotional, because he dared me to vote for him.
Zelda Fact of the Day #8: Did you know the world record for beating the Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is 17 minutes and 13 seconds? Now you know!
Current Vote Count:
nin1000 (1)
bronx-man 1924
*splinter (1)
kyanrute 1987
terrabyte20xx (0)
cabot 1990 (2136)
nin1000 2137 (2238)
melonrabbit (4)
absolutbro 2046
magnumboy20xx 2055
cabot 2136
*splinter 2203
stanleypalmtree (1)
ynnek7 2067
ynnek7 (0)
nin1000 2077 (2137)
ty4on (2)
sophia 2235
nin1000 2238
Majority is 7
Day 3 Ends in:
Vote Count can be found HERE
Current Vote Count:
nin1000 (1)
bronx-man 1924
*splinter (1)
kyanrute 1987
terrabyte20xx (0)
melonrabbit (4)
absolutbro 2046
magnumboy20xx 2055
cabot 2136
*splinter 2203
stanleypalmtree (1)
ynnek7 2067
ynnek7 (0)
ty4on (2)
sophia 2235
nin1000 2238
Majority is 7
Day 3 Ends in:
Vote Count can be found HERE
melonrabbit
Member
I care.
I, like splinter, don't see much of anything to this exchange and you're 'they should not interact like this' strain of logic seems to be coming from what you believe is a rational place.
However there was nothing rational about acohrs and CCS doing their self votes and rugby nonsense.
Therefore your train of thought isn't rock solid. This was the first time acohrs started a game as scum. I don't think your argument is on steady ground.
That read was pure bull BTW. I try to make genuine-ish reads as scum, but really struggled to make one of the townies still alive so I tunneled in on you.
My activity in this game has resembled my scum game, I am aware of that. It's not on purpose. I kinda yo-yo and after Pop some of the drive is missing and at the same time I'm very cautious of not making the same mistakes that I've made as town in the past. The biggest is town reading a scum so I kept doubting and reading my town reads. There's also not that much that has grabbed me. I've struggled to get something substantial from reading Sophia (being this indecisive is weird from a scum or neutral PoV as well) and elsewhere my scum reads have been quite inactive so there's not much grabbing me.
Sure I can rationalize that one. Acohrs was playing CCS and of course playing that inexperienced townie card. That's why I felt quite strongly CCS was town. From my PoV it looked like acohrs kinda got trapped. He was playing along with CCS and being goofy and had to respond to that selfvote. He was probably thinking that he'd keep being silly. Too wolfy to be a wolf and he'd gain trust from CCS.
I don't think it's irrational, especially not in the heat of action. Acohrs played like that in Pop and it worked. He didn't selfvote, but he was being silly and fluffy and talked a lot to CCS. It's also worth noting this sequence:
Sorry mate, only just got back and fed after rugby
I'm not sure. I can't remember who said it earlier, but I kind of support lynching either you or Ty, because there's been a lot of discussion around the two of you, and whichever way you flip the information will be very interesting.
That and I still don't have any good scum reads.
I don't particularly think you guys are scum, but I don't have anyone else that I think is scum either. In the absence of a better lead so far, there's a certain sense to lynching the people who are most discussed so that when they flip we find out the most.
I was refereeing, it was very good fun
Splinter summed it up in #700
CCS was planning to vote for acohrs, acohrs plays along and managed to make CCS vote for me instead.
This looks silly on the surface, but it's rational as fuck IMO. He's manipulating CCS: