• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Legendary Shipping Meltdowns (SPOILERS)

Edit: I never really saw Usagi Drop but my GF loves it and tells me it's adorable, THAT is the ending? Makes Oreimo look like Shakespeare.

Never touching it.
To be kinda fair to your GF, if she's talking about the anime then it's okay since the anime does not have this as the ending. Neither does the live action movie. They both end with the girl staying as a little kid going to school with the guy staying as the surrogate parent.

The manga on the other hand decided to blur the lines between their relationship for something...more. Also, it's all on Rin, the girl. The guy is NOT okay with it at first.

Still weird.
 

Ray Down

Banned
To be kinda fair to your GF, if she's talking about the anime then it's okay since the anime does not have this as the ending. Neither does the live action movie. They both end with the girl staying as a little kid going to school with the guy staying as the surrogate parent.

The manga on the other hand decided to blur the lines between their relationship for something...more. Also, it's all on Rin, the girl. The guy is NOT okay with it at first.

Still weird.

It's weird that Daichi just sort of accepts it.
 

Razmos

Member
Korrasami.
I was firmly a Korrasami shipper from the start of Book 3 onwards and my reaction to it actually happening was crazy.

On a negative side, Samurai Flamenco.
It had the most obvious and sweet gay love story I've ever seen in an anime. My shipper heart was on cloud 9.
And it ended with this scene:
tumblr_n84i8nSSwJ1qbil3do10_250.gif

tumblr_n3602aw3Je1qbil3do10_250.gif


There was even artwork of the two characters married.

And yet apparently in interviews the creators said they were both straight and just friends. It was mind boggling.
It wasn't even subtext.
 
It's weird that Daichi just sort of accepts it.
Yeah I was wondering about that. I know at first he is against it and can't even grasp the idea of seeing Rin as anything more than a daughter but after she tries to run away and then goes and visits her mom he's okay with it as long as she waits til graduation? I was so confused.

Like I could never do that myself! It would just be too weird!
 
Korrasami.
I was firmly a Korrasami shipper from the start of Book 3 onwards and my reaction to it actually happening was crazy.

On a negative side, Samurai Flamenco.
It had the most obvious and sweet gay love story I've ever seen in an anime. My shipper heart was on cloud 9.
And it ended with this scene:
tumblr_n84i8nSSwJ1qbil3do10_250.gif

tumblr_n3602aw3Je1qbil3do10_250.gif


There was even artwork of the two characters married.

And yet apparently in interviews the creators said they were both straight and just friends. It was mind boggling.
It wasn't even subtext.

I saw two episodes and meant to finish this sometime but now I want to dump it in my "dropped" pile out of spite.
 

Andrin

Member
Shipping can be fun, in a sort of 'what if?' way, or to keep imagining what happened with a couple after the story ended, but the obsessive parts of the community are generally awful. Especially when they devolve into stalking and/or threats.

Oh yeah, those that dive into RPF can be rabid. I recall the Darren Criss crazy fans who loved him from his Harry Potter youtube videos basically stalking anything to do with Chris Colfer insisting they were a real couple. The Glee fandom is long dead but I hear there's still those that believe they're a thing and still harrass Colfer on twitter on occasion. I mean, these were the people that were swooning over drunk Blaine trying to force himself onto Kurt. You could tell Colfer checked out of the on screen relationship of Blaine and Kurt pretty quickly (and Glee as a whole kind of)

RPF is a line I'm not really willing to cross. It just feels really intrusive and weird.
And Glee never had the best writing, but they really didn't handle Darren Criss' character well. I bailed early on during season 3, because I could start to see the writing on the wall and wanted to keep my impression of the characters generally positive. I read up on some of the things they did with later seasons recently, and it sounds like they wanted the show to become the textbook example of character assassination, especially when it came to Blaine. If Chris Colfer only turned up for a paycheck at the end I can't blame him, he was generally too good for that show.
 
To give some context to you people who have no idea about how insane this was, here's a page from the comic.

Pv7EEhN.jpg


One of these characters is an innocent victim, the other an abusive monster if you ask some people.
If Ranma had taste he would've settled down with Ukyo.
 

Razmos

Member
I saw two episodes and meant to finish this sometime but now I want to dump it in my "dropped" pile out of spite.
I've just straight up denied what the creators said in my mind. It was far too obvious for the entire show.

It's a good show if you can do the same and their relationship is truly sweet to watch unfold.

Or at least read this if you are interested in it: link
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
He has? I completely dropped FT after a while but I remember a lot of shipping going on when I quit, what's the last been in that series?

The only pairing that actually happened was two random side characters.

There's like 5 or 6 different obvious pairings, none of which have gone anywhere other than 1 of them.

Lucy x Natsu
Erza x Gerard
Gray x Juvia
Elfman x Evergreen
Happy x Charle (the cats)

Levy x Gajeel is the only one that's gone to the point where the characters actually acknowledge it to the other.
 
The only pairing that actually happened was two random side characters.

There's like 5 or 6 different obvious pairings, none of which have gone anywhere other than 1 of them.

Lucy x Natsu
Erza x Gerard
Gray x Juvia
Elfman x Evergreen
Happy x Charle (the cats)

Levy x Gajeel is the only one that's gone to the point where the characters actually acknowledge it to the other.

Gray and Juvia was a confirmation too I believe, at least from what I remember.
 

Garuroh

Member
JohnLock(Sherlock) fans had one when theit ship didn't happen(again) in the last season. They seriously thought there was a "secret" episode where JohnLock was made canon and accused the actually gay writer of queerbaiting.
 
Partly with Pyrrha. And that RWBY is a timebomb in itself for the other fan-pairings.

For those who don't know the series premiered back in 2013 but before that there had been a series of introduction trailers for the main cast. Each girl prior was simply a silhouette which figure was revealed when their trailer released.

The young fandom had already shipped the silhouettes. I'm not joking.

More hilarious was the meltdowns that happened when Weiss's personality was revealed as there had been those who had built up an image of her from her trailer.

But as I said RWBY is just a timebomb waiting to go off.

Not to mention the Jaune hate...

I am talking about the timebomb aspect. Shipping the RWBY members together seems quite popular. I try to avoid that sort of thing, but I know there is some level of fan drama with Blake/Yang/Sun.

I just shake my head at the Jaune hate. Because heaven forbid that screen time is given to people outside the main character group.

Didn't know the shipping began with the silhouettes. Makes me slightly curious to see those meltdowns.
 

Kinyou

Member
After reading PataHikari's post I was sitting here trying to remember the name of that awful fanfic where Ranma's mom gives Ranma and Akane a sword as a wedding gift and symbolically dooms them all. Even as someone who was a huge Ukyo fan I couldn't wrap my head around why someone would write that story.

Ranma as a property made people kind of weird though. I remember a fair amount of backlash just around the idea that the end of the series didn't really solve much beyond implying that Ranma and Akane would eventually get married. Like the entire point of it was to goof around and have fun but because some of the comedy involved people liking each other the internet went crazy and demanded closure on their terms.
What annoyed me about the ending is how close the author got to Ranma and Akane tying the knot and then chickens out at the last second, only to imply a page later the they'll get married eventually. It felt like the author was afraid to really commit to it.

I just hate it when those anime couples never get properly together and constantly pull a bait and switch

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_B13yISVHWI
 

Satch

Banned
I feel that when it comes to reactions towards shipping in Legend of Korra, people not liking ships is more complicated because the relationship writing (not just the romantic ones, pretty much all of them) was pretty awful. People not liking a relationship in the show could be down to them not liking the ship itself or them thinking the execution was terrible. I don't like shipping wars, and would never go out of my way to ship two characters, but the writing in that show was so awful that it made me turn against ships I was okay with before.

For example, I was okay with the idea of Varrick and Zhu Li getting together since they had good chemistry together in the show, however, when they did at the end of Book 4, I didn't like it (like the rest of Book 4's finale) because the writing at the end was so awful, and they managed to make a romantic relationship that basically wrote itself feel tacked on and forced.

"good chemistry"
sis, Varrick literally treated Zhu Li like shit 100% of the time
 
I am talking about the timebomb aspect. Shipping the RWBY members together seems quite popular. I try to avoid that sort of thing, but I know there is some level of fan drama with Blake/Yang/Sun.

I just shake my head at the Jaune hate. Because heaven forbid that screen time is given to people outside the main character group.

Didn't know the shipping began with the silhouettes. Makes me slightly curious to see those meltdowns.

I heard that those fans
cheered when Pyrrha shoved him into the pillar when he was trying to encourage her but unaware of the whole Fall Maiden thing. They really do hate him and from what I have heard a number have accused Miles (his voice actor and RWBY writer) of embellishing his role now that Monty is gone.

As for the fan drama, yeah its bad.

As for the silhouette thing that's the main reason why you see the main fan pairings. But oh man I recall that a number of people thought Weiss was some quiet sad damsel from the trailer and she ended up nothing like that.

What annoyed me about the ending is how close the author got to Ranma and Akane tying the knot and then chickens out at the last second, only to imply a page later the they'll get married eventually. It felt like the author was afraid to really commit to it.

From what I remember the whole wedding thing was hastily put together, they were put on the spot and then the whole thing got bombed by the fiancee brigade when they learned of it through Nabiki. The ending between them though was to show that Ranma an Akane had taken their first real step forward in regards to their relationship.
 

Apzu

Member
Korasami was a big meltdown as was Harry and Hermione not happening.

Yep. When I asked why they gave out some explanations
(fantasies)
and directed me to this trope here.

Speaking of this trope, anyone remember Usagi/Bunny Drop???
Wasn't the last arc just so much fun?!?!?!


Dang it! Here's my tears then.

I just didn't like it!
No no no no no... why did you have to remind me of that? I try to remember Usagi Drop as a story with only 4 volumes that was cancelled before the author could get to her as a teen.

I've always been a fan of Sanji x Robin myself.

You Zoro x Robin shippers out there are trash!
What am I reading? Zoro x Robin will always be way better than Sanji x Robin, even though both don't even make any sense.

You're trash. Zorobin 4 life. Fight me
kcbA35v.gif
 
Cheetara flirted with Lion-O not because she was romantically interested but to boost his confidence in learning his abilities. Wasn't that basically the duty of the order she belonged to. It was a shitty thing to do but she was trying to get results. She liked Tigra from childhood just like he liked her. The feelings were always mutual.
Nothing in the entire show hinted she liked him until the convenient flashback and then she immediately goes "oh yeah shove that tongue down my throat"
 

blakep267

Member
Everything about that ending is a dumpster fire.
It's shocking a creator can absolutely RUIN a series in such a fashion.
The explanation given made it worse. "She's technically not related to him and if you remember back, she didn't want to be adopted. So that's all ok"

Give me a break. Not 5 year old kid can be raised by somebody and not see them as a parental figure for 10+ years and then fall in love

I liked the live action movie better because it showed daichi starting to fall for the little boys mom which always made sense in the anime
 

Linkark07

Banned
Only one I remember is Bleach, and that is because it is the most recent meltdown since the manga ended less than a year ago. Korra doesn't count, Makorra was awful. So the logical choice was Korrasami.

For lol's

Kubo was the perfect troll. I know that, if he writes another manga, I will read it just for his plotkais.
 

blakep267

Member
If any of you watch Kdramas you know the shipping meltdowns can be ridiculous. Cheese on the Trap, K2, She was Pretty. It can be war online with Kdrama fans
 

Sub_Level

wants to fuck an Asian grill.
Bleach is one of the few properties where the anime definitively has a better ending than the manga.

Reasom: The anime ends earlier so therefore is better by default.
 
At the very least the downfall of Sakura into a needy idiot unable to move on gave us one of the best female characters in the franchise.

tenor.gif


Looking forward to see how they ruin her!

I'm going to have to agree with you. Sasuke/Sakura is unbelievably stupid in context (Sasuke literally tried to kill you and everyone you care about, Sakura!) but Sarada is awesome. I even like Sasuke being the mentor to Boruto...even thought he's a totally shitty father to Sarada.

Here's the thing: poor shipping writing doesn't exist in a vacuum. Most of the time, the "bad" ship is the result of poor writing all around. There's a lot of really stupid shit Naruto pulled story-wise. Major villains getting forgiven was a running theme, but Jesus Christ, they really just half-forgave Obito after all the horrible shit he did? I thought Ichigo getting together with Orihime in Bleach was sorta disappointing, but holy shit, it's at the bottom of the list of how fucking awful that manga became by the end. That final arc was utter torture.

Basically, I don't get angry because Person A didn't get with Person B. I get annoyed when the writing around it is terrible and hurts the story. I really liked Felicity in Arrow when I saw her in Season 1, but the general consensus among my friends and family seems to be that her relationship with Oliver completely took over the show in Season 4 and made it objectively worse.

If a ship is odd when you think about it (the time/age-difference-but-not-really? weirdness involved with Jack & Ashi and Trunks & Mai, for example), but it works well with everything else, I'm OK with it. If it's fucking crazy and completely alters a story's themes and people's interpretations of it like with Usagi Drop, then it can retroactively ruin the story. But Usagi Drop is really the only example I can think of because it's so extreme and disgusting. Without that ending, it's a nice little story about an adoptive father raising a child. With it, all of its goodwill and charm is darkened by a cloud of possible pandering to an otaku audience and gross story decisions. It's not that it happens at all; it's that the story treats it as something relatively normal and romantic by the end.

That being said, you can not like or be disappointed in something without it completely torpedoing everything you liked about that show. You also shouldn't place hope into something happening in a story and then be angry when it doesn't happen. That even goes beyond shipping. I see it all the time among Steven Universe fans who get mad that their theories either get shot down or that a story/episode doesn't go the way they wanted to.
 

Ninjimbo

Member
There are still lost souls on the SS IchiRuki.

Goddamn did that one hurt especially when Kubo revealed who they actually ended up with. Maybe Kubo really was trolling all along and made that ending to spite us and Shonenjump.
 

Linkark07

Banned
There are still lost souls on the SS IchiRuki.

Goddamn did that one hurt especially when Kubo revealed who they actually ended up with. Maybe Kubo really was trolling all along and made that ending to spite us and Shonenjump.

Dude, Kubo is always trolling. Do you believe he didn't want to say goodbye to his fanbase by doing the ultimate trolling?

And it worked. And that is why we love him.

And this is coming from someone who was in the Ichiruki ship.
 

LotusHD

Banned
Bleach is one of the few properties where the anime definitively has a better ending than the manga.

Reasom: The anime ends earlier so therefore is better by default.

Anime still went on for too long, should've ended immediately after Aizen's defeat.
 
There are still lost souls on the SS IchiRuki.

Goddamn did that one hurt especially when Kubo revealed who they actually ended up with. Maybe Kubo really was trolling all along and made that ending to spite us and Shonenjump.

But again, in regards to Ichigo and Rukia for as close as they were there was nothing romantic about their relationship manga-wise. I can understand those scratching their heads for Ichigo but with Orihime pretty much baring her feelings (the 5 lifetimes one love speech) it was pretty obvious that another potential end point had been revealed. And like I said prior I figured if Ichigo got with anyone it would be revealed after a timeskip so Kubo wouldn't actually have to write it.

Edit: And also I feel like I'm the only one that actually enjoyed Bleach the entire way through...
 
Top Bottom