Lol no. The combat is amazing, agreed, but everything else is shit!
I mean, of course the person you replied to is wrong and I said it already in this thread but the character creator in this game is the best I've ever seen. Just in the way that everything you decide from the character's weight, to their arm length has an impact on gameplay. The sheer variety of characters you can create in the game is remarkable. I also think the plotline is done well. I like how mysterious and world changing dragons are in Dragon's Dogma, which is more akin to classic RPGs. So it's not just the combat but that's definitely the biggest draw.
In terms of world building, quest writing, choice and consequence, Witcher 3 craps on it from the highest heavens.