• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

K-Pop Fanboy/Fangirl |OT7| A Great Trash Leader as Always

llehuty

Member
Damn after a week of SOTY quality releases, GFriend comes out to shit the bed and everyone follows along lol.

I really hope whatever Soshi is doing isn't another party. Otherwise, I'll be joining milkman in mentally binning and storing my Soshi stuff away(and I say mentally coz I don't have any physical Soshi materials lol).
 

Pendulum

Member
SNSD group photo
JulTOcq.jpg

---

Sonamoo's Minjae, Nahyun, High.D, New Sun
 

Gintamen

Member
Boss★Moogle;245276007 said:
How you can go from Hobgoblin to this is beyond me. Wasn't Hobgoblin somewhat successful for them? CLC and GFRIEND comebacks are both very disappointing for me.
IIRC it was successful international, what a massive downer to see them going back to their earlier concept following their group name... So Hobogoblin CLC, "Where are you?"?

Elkie looks much much better with brown hair, so there's a win I guess.

What's there to hate with 9Muses? Oo But then... foxy Kyungri could wear a potato sack and everything would be forgiven still.

Gfriends song is boooring, has the same beats as all their earlier songs.
 

vanty

Member
I definitely prefer Hobgoblin but I like the new CLC song. GFRIEND, on the other hand, is super disappointing start to finish. Not just the single, but the whole album is bland as fuck.
 
Fucking disaster guys. I feel asleep in my chair watching TI. Didn't have time to make a proper top 10 for SHINee on r/kpop. Had to go with the songs I know I love, which made for a pretty solid top 10, but with a * next to it:

1. 1 of 1
2. Married to the Music
3. Tell me What to Do
4. Hello (Glen Check Remix)
5. Juliette
6. Sherlock
7. View
8. Spoiler
9. Dream Girl
10. Love Like Oxygen

Holy crap that's the best CLC track ever released. Maybe k-pop track of the year. When did they turn into Especia??

Not sure it's the best CLC track, but unlike most here, I like it too.
 

broz0rs

Member
That CLC track was unexpected. It sounded like a hit 80's track. The MV didn't match with the song at all though, and their image looks like Oh My Girl's
 

llehuty

Member
All night is fantastic. Not a fan of MVs where you can't hear the full song, but 10 years active is a big enough milestone to go with a more personal kind of approach. I do hope they will release a dance or performance version at some point, though. Fake edit: I see it's actually called documentary version now, good news.

Holiday is cute but unexciting. I liked the subtle references to some of their MVs (that elevator has to be a Hoot reference, and I'm assuming the hand ponpons are a nod to Oh).

Edit: Album is already up on Spotify.
 

No No Eul

Member
I like Holiday. The song is fun and upbeat, and I really enjoyed the choreography.

All Night is certainly good but I'm not sure I'd call it great. Not yet anyway.

The styling in both is a bit of a clusterfuck.
 

neoism

Member
Sadly the song has been hit by the Taeyeon curse, it will debut -100 at Melon.

I really like the pics out of this set, they all look so good.
lol taeyeon curse ?����

the mv is cool but the song is just a meh single all night is much better but the mv without subs.. ��

overall the album isnt there best by any means but its got 4-5 great tracks Sweet Talk is the bes track why couldn't they made that track an mv.. ��

still �� forward to the variety shows and stuff
 

neoism

Member
All Night>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Holiday

Holiday is trash

All Night is good but I'm going to need hear the full version on itunes without all the talking.

yea its definitely the best of the two... holiday is just a generic single. sm never picks the best tracks..😑

994DAF3359844082347102

😍😘😘
 

luso

Member
I like Holiday. The song is fun and upbeat, and I really enjoyed the choreography.

All Night is certainly good but I'm not sure I'd call it great. Not yet anyway.

The styling in both is a bit of a clusterfuck.

I agree, Holiday it's just a fun song and I'm ok with that!
All Night fells musically better, waiting for the no documentary version.
Album has overall a cohesive sound, even if it's not a marvel all tracks are listenable.
 

Niks

Member
Boss★Moogle;245364786 said:
Girls' Generation 소녀시대_All Night_Music Video
Girls' Generation 소녀시대_Holiday_Music Video

I really like both songs but it's kind of distracting to have all the talking on "All Night", I'll have to listen to the CD track to fully appreciate it.
Man I was so convinced it was Sunny saying "I like to party" but I was totally wrong.

Both songs are good. They fit Soshi well.

But, whats with the piss poor IQ in both videos? I know they were going for a 80's look for the promo shots but for the final vid to also have that blurry effect going on?
 
All Night isn't that bad actually. It's listenable but I'm not rushing to put it on my playlist.

Holiday on the other hand... somebody needs to tell Hyoyeon to stop rapping. I was mildly enjoying it then her nasally ass voice came in and ruined the entire song for me. Take out her rapping section and I think I actually enjoy this more than All Night.

Haven't listened to the full album yet but at least I can appreciate the effort Soshi actually put in with this comeback judging from the two MV's and two singles that actually sound decent(minus Hyogre's rap of course).
 

Pendulum

Member
프라이머리(Primary) - 밤꽃 (Night Flower) (feat. 카더가든)_꽃(Flower) ver. Video clip
프라이머리(Primary) - 밤꽃 (Night Flower) (feat. 카더가든)_밤(Night) ver. Video clip

---

Weki Meki 위키미키 - I don't like your Girlfriend M/V TEASER 2

---


---

Both SNSD songs are better than what the teasers let on, but if my assumption is correct and this is the last promotion period before they go on indefinite hiatus
using this rather than disband because they'll probably still officially be in the agency and come back for a reunion tour in another 10 years
, I'd be disappointed if they go out like this. SM/SNSD can do better.
I know it's the middle of the night in South Korea right now, but their chart position isn't what I expected? "Holiday" is at 8 and "All Night" is at 25.

---

edit: New page Sana
 
Top Bottom