• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Armband-wearing Nazi roams Seattle instigating, gets KOed, removes armband and leaves

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bossking

Banned
I agree that Nazi views are reprehensible and that the guy probably deserved to get punched, but this sort of vigilante behavior makes me uneasy. It's just going to enable more vigilantism, and escalate the rate and severity of these attacks.

These guys do deserve to be told to shut the fuck up, and they deserve to be locked up if they attack people. But these things should be done within the confines of the law. Going around the law to fight against Nazis is not the way to do it.

You bet that Nazis right now are using this incident to justify more violence. That'll lead more people to seek violent confrontations against Nazis. On and on and on.

The escalation is in response to neo-nazis themselves escalating. Motherfucker was out in public wearing armbands and harassing people. We had Charlottesville just over a month ago. Neo-nazis are becoming more bold and brazen every god damn day. If anti-fascists DON'T escalate in response, then we all risk getting trampled. There is no other scenario.
 
You walked in here with your ridiculous thesis that responding to things one hates with violence will result in something bad a few years down the road. Completely ignoring the fact that colonizers have been inflicting violence against indigenous peoples, POC for hundreds of years. But now that Nazis are getting their teeth knocked in, it's a problem.

You'd have to be naive or flat out disingenuous to act like this is brand new.

tl;dr - your post was bollocks and you're being called out for it.

No, you don't get it. I explicitly said what you were arguing;

After all, many of your founding fathers were authoritarian a frighteningly idea.
At the core of fascism is nationalism, and I don't know a country that is more entrenched in its own patriotism than America.

But here is the thing- Pointing to how ideological based violence is not the same as being a pacifist. You've misunderstood something here quite deeply. I'm totally with you that the US is a systemic racist institution.

I don't know why you're arguing a point that I am agreeing with you on, to try and disconcern yourself from previous eras where collective prosecution outside the rule of law, has lead to catastrophes. Particularly in the soviet union.

nazis getting punched their teeth in is not the problem. The philosophical reasoning behind it is the normalization of violence over iconography. We're not talking self defense here.
As I said; There is less and less difference between a republican, a conservative, a neo-nazi, a confederate flag supporter. It's not without the realm of possibility to suggest that violence subjugated on one, goes for the others. After all, the argument is that the iconography makes you fully a part of it.
 

Manu

Member
I suggest you take a deep breath, and re-read my first sentence where i said that i don't feel bad that a Nazi who was harassing people got clocked by someone.

It's a slippery slope because if we as a society become ok with the practice of a group following and tracking someone on social media to plan and attack that person, then it sets a precedence that this is ok for any reason. Nazis are dirtbags and deserve all that they get, but doing it this way i think raises alot of questions.

HATE GROUPS ALREADY DO THIS. THERE'S NO SLIPPERY SLOPE.
 

Chjemah

Neo Member
Yeah, what if the Nazis kill someon..






And here's an article of more murders by these far right lunatics for you to gracefully ignore in favor of your hypothetical future murder victim.

Because its just a Tuesday when some Nazi kills some person of color. But its a WHOLE NOTHA LEVEL when a Nazi gets his clock cleaned and "might retaliate".

I find it hilarious that you really think anyone buys this concern trolling nonsense. If it was murder you cared about, you would have been upset long before this.

I said that it's just as likely he'll retaliate with violence as it is he'll stop openly being a Nazi and that I don't see this as a "win" in that regard. Not sure why you think I'm implying Nazi don't/won't kill people.
 
Hahahahahah. It just got better and better the more I scrolled down. Him lying on the floor passed out. Whoever punched him. 👌

🙏🙏🙏
 

Nepenthe

Member
It's fucking sad that it's not even surprising people are caping for Nazis in America

Wasn't there a thread awhile back that said Nazis actually took a lot of their ideology from race laws in America and just ramped the shit up to 20? If that's the case, it makes perfect sense for some moderates and white people to cape for Nazis.

I'd pay a pack of toddlers to beat up hitler-baby.

Teaching them that it literally pays to stand up to shitheads. Raising the next generation right.
 

Nokterian

Member
yd3ul5U.jpg

Holy shit!

giphy.gif
 
I suggest you take a deep breath.

This shit...

I'm not like, freaking out at your poor reasoning or whatever. This attempt to reframe the conversation where yours is the coolly rational one is pretty weak in general. Almost as weak as the explanation that followed it, an explanation that again continues your weird, misguided practice of imagining a hypothetical removed from the context of this specific incident where Nazi beliefs can (and should) be lumped in with other, actually valid ideologies.

then it sets a precedence that this is ok for any reason

No it doesn't and you're not even using these words you're mishandling correctly. You think this raises questions because you're the one raising them.

None of this is happening in a vacuum. That fact is what makes the sucking sound of this gambit you're attempting so loud.
 

Enzom21

Member
Why are you attacking me, and falsely saying I have a history of bitching about how racists are treated? When all I did was share my experience and ask for yours?
I was going to respond to this... but Jesus fucking Christ.
Your other posts prove my point. I never thought I would see a #notallnazis argument, although I’m not surprised it came from you.
 
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.
 

Nekofrog

Banned
I agree that Nazi views are reprehensible and that the guy probably deserved to get punched, but this sort of vigilante behavior makes me uneasy. It's just going to enable more vigilantism, and escalate the rate and severity of these attacks.

These guys do deserve to be told to shut the fuck up, and they deserve to be locked up if they attack people. But these things should be done within the confines of the law. Going around the law to fight against Nazis is not the way to do it.

You bet that Nazis right now are using this incident to justify more violence. That'll lead more people to seek violent confrontations against Nazis. On and on and on.

???????????

They have murdered people who have reached too harassment peacefully in 2017 already. More than once. More than one victim. There have been many links in the thread. They are the ones out there killing people unprovoked. If one of them is out starting shit literally wearing their symbols of hate, you don't take the risk that this white supremacists shit stain might not start stabbing people like they have before, you knock them the fuck out and move along with your day.
 
You act as if every hate group is the same when lots of them use nazi symbols and imagery. It's arbitrarily defined imo when everyone in this thread is simply calling them nazis as if they are aspiring SS members ready to pick the fight back up. I think there is more nuance than that. I think it's a means to justify violence by generalizing them as something people think is there inherent right to destroy as a member of the allies.

Are you asking how a person can differentiate between moderate white supremacists and extremist white supremacists?
 
Wasn't there a thread awhile back that said Nazis actually took a lot of their ideology from race laws in America and just ramped the shit up to 20? If that's the case, it makes perfect sense for some moderates and white people to cape for Nazis.

I believe it's a misunderstanding of what is free speech and the consequences of it.

Yeah, I think these two are the biggest reasons.

Some of these people will refuse to acknowledge what's going on until some arbitrary number of women/POC are killed. Until then it's just "different opinions."
 

BitStyle

Unconfirmed Member
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.
Nope, but if an individual wearing said items was walking around town harassing people and caught hands, I wouldn't be sympathetic to their situation.
 

Chmpocalypse

Blizzard
No, you don't get it. I explicitly said what you were arguing;



But here is the thing- Pointing to how ideological based violence is not the same as being a pacifist. You've misunderstood something here quite deeply. I'm totally with you that the US is a systemic racist institution.

I don't know why you're arguing a point that I am agreeing with you on, to try and disconcern yourself from previous eras where collective prosecution outside the rule of law, has lead to catastrophes. Particularly in the soviet union.

nazis getting punched their teeth in is not the problem. The philosophical reasoning behind it is the normalization of violence over iconography. We're not talking self defense here.
As I said; There is less and less difference between a republican, a conservative, a neo-nazi, a confederate flag supporter. It's not without the realm of possibility to suggest that violence subjugated on one, goes for the others. After all, the argument is that the iconography makes you fully a part of it.

Not self-defense?

Nazis literally want to murder you if you aren't one of them.
 
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.

That seems random. There are a bunch of actions across a wide variety of ideas and situations that I'm favor of, but I would not partake in myself. I am in favor of fighting fires, I would not run into a burning building myself. Perhaps I'm missing your point?
 
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.

I punched a guy years ago in school who had a swastika tattooed onto his arm, but I'll be honest it was because he threw garbage at me as I was walking up the stairs, if that counts...
 

Nepenthe

Member
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.

Haven't met one yet.

Closest was a dude who gave me a look on the street during a conversation with my friend where I said "If Hillary had talked about white people like Trump talked about minorities, they would've demanded Dems to rebuke the rhetoric, nor would they have accepted the excuses that she was just "playing up the base" or "I'm not voting for her for the attacks on white people"."

And had the nigga pulled up on me for that I would've punched him; I don't care that I am 4'11".

Fuck Nazis.
 

Fantastapotamus

Wrong about commas, wrong about everything

You know the old saying, if it walks like a Nazi, talks like a Nazi and dresses like a Nazi it's probably a member of an unnamed hate group using Nazi symbols that's not actually affiliated with the Nazis.

Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.

I wouldn't need to do that cause it's illegal here so I would just call the police.
 

Easy_D

never left the stone age
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.

So I take it you feel yourself belonging to the "other" group seeing as you refer to your fellow board-members as "You gaffers"?

You know the old saying, if it walks like a Nazi, talks like a Nazi and dresses like a Nazi it's probably a member of an unnamed hate group using Nazi symbols that's not actually affiliated with the Nazis.



I wouldn't need to do that cause it's illegal here so I would just call the police.

It's nice living in a country where symbols of hate are banned, isn't it? Swastikas and Nazi Saluts are both banned here as well.
 

Rayis

Member
I feel like they walked right into this Nazi dipshit's trap, he wanted to get punched so that the "violent antifa people" narrative would resonate once more.
 
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.

Haven't had the displeasure of meeting one of those wastemen, but sounds like you'd jump in front of the punch anyway
 

KoopaTheCasual

Junior Member
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.
No, but if a nazi gentleman got in my way and called me an "ape", you can bet your ass I would lay him out cold.

Fuck respectability with people who don't respect my humanity.
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
Anyone who thinks punching a Nazi might make them hateful or violent seems to be missing the fact they already are by being fucking Nazis. You don't walk around with a Nazi armband because you're espousing peace and love. Even them using their free speech is basically using it in the most disgusting and ugly manner possible. Its like going to a child care center and telling the parents you believe in fucking kids and expecting not to get the fucking shit kicked out of you by every adult there and being shocked by that outcome.
 

Beefy

Member
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.

Punched more then a few guys that called me nigger. I guess one of them could be a Nazi.
 

Shaanyboi

Banned
Have any of you GAFers punched a neo nazi? You all seem in favor of using violent actions against these dudes but I'm curious if any of you have actually punched a guy/girl wearing a Nazi symbol, KKK mask, MAGA hat, etc.
I'll let you know next time one comes my way. Thankfully the last attempted alt-right nazi rally in Vancouver resulted in thousands of counter protesters, and only two of the racist shit-pieces bothering to show up.
 

Akuun

Looking for meaning in GAF
The escalation is in response to neo-nazis themselves escalating. Motherfucker was out in public wearing armbands and harassing people. We had Charlottesville just over a month ago. Neo-nazis are becoming more bold and brazen every god damn day. If anti-fascists DON'T escalate in response, then we all risk getting trampled. There is no other scenario.
It's true that nazis have become more brazen and that violent hate crimes from them are on the rise. It's also true that people should fight back against them if harassed.

But if this keeps escalating, aren't we going to start seeing shootouts on the streets eventually? Some people here are already advocating outright shooting the guy instead of punching him.
 

ash321

Member
It's true that nazis have become more brazen and that violent hate crimes from them are on the rise. It's also true that people should fight back against them if harassed.

But if this keeps escalating, sooner or later we'll get shootouts on the streets. Some people here are already advocating outright murder.
Cops shooting black man, white people shooting black man, Nazi just mowdow a women.

Sooner or later ?? You are late to the party.
 

Nekofrog

Banned
It's true that nazis have become more brazen and that violent hate crimes from them are on the rise. It's also true that people should fight back against them if harassed.

But if this keeps escalating, aren't we going to start seeing shootouts on the streets eventually? Some people here are already advocating outright shooting the guy instead of punching him.

Dude. They're already killing people. In 2017 Nazis are killing innocent people in America. Let that sink in. Stop ignoring it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom