• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Hat in Time releases in 2 days, yet JonTron still seems to be in the game

Status
Not open for further replies.

robotrock

Banned
C3dC0SwWYAYrIWO.jpg

hahahaha
 

L Thammy

Member
He's a minority you are aware of that right? Lol
I don't really mind if he's in it or not.
Regardless of his position in politics, I could care less if he's in this game or not. But I couldn't believe how out of control this thread has gotten with hate over a game thats been reviewed well so far.

Since its a steam release I'm sure there will be an anti jontron patch for everyone upset about it. So don't worry antiJT gafers you'll get your game eventually.

Being a minority doesn't magically excuse him being a white supremacist or prove that he can't be one. I don't know what ethnicity you are, but let me tell you, non-white people can form all the same thoughts and sentences that white people can, believe it or don't. It is entirely possible for someone to hate their own ethnicity or a range that includes their own.
 
He's a minority you are aware of that right? Lol
I don't really mind if he's in it or not.
Regardless of his position in politics, I could care less if he's in this game or not. But I couldn't believe how out of control this thread has gotten with hate over a game thats been reviewed well so far.

Since its a steam release I'm sure there will be an anti jontron patch for everyone upset about it. So don't worry antiJT gafers you'll get your game eventually.

*ahem*

1. JonTron is half-Iranian, half-Hungarian.

2. Hungarians are often considered white.

3. Iran means "land of the Aryans," and changed its name from Persia as part of its alliance with Nazi Germany.

4. Iran is in the area known as the Caucus region, where the term Caucasian comes.

5. It is not uncommon for Iranians to consider themselves white, especially if they pass as such.

Beyond the fact that you don't have to be white to be a white supremacist, he's clearly not inherently a member of a non-white group - at least ,not by his own classification.
 

Kneefoil

Member
Oh, we're doing this again? Can't say I envy Gears for Breakfast; there's no way out of this in a way that pleases everyone. Except maybe if Jon himself would ask to be removed, but it's probably too late for even that to not upset people.

I wasn't even aware he was in the game, tbh.
I also don't mind him still being in, but that's neither here nor there.
 

Toxi

Banned
This.

I'm not even interested in the game but I'm considering buying a copy just to support the people making this, considering the shit that's probably about to hit them (review bombing and whatnot).
Again, the people who would have a problem with the game over something like this generally aren't the people who review bomb. Review bombing comes with the 4chan-style cesspool of internet culture.
 
This seems like an immensely petty thing to personally hold against a developer

Oh no, people are making decisions about their consumer habits. How petty of them.

Regardless of his position in politics

I frequently question the motives of people who brush aside unamibiguous white supremacist statements as a minor detail.

I think it's wrong to punish the developer

Folks are simply choosing to not buy the game. That's not punishing anybody for anything.
 

Carl

Member
It's true that it's therefore a matter of principle at this stage. Which doesn't lessen the importance of choosing not to support if that's your stance in the slightest.

My principle is the game looks great and that's all that sways my purchasing intention *shrug*
 

Mivey

Member
It would be nice to get a comment from Gears for Breakfast, just anything really.
Then again, they don't seem to do communication well. I'll play it anyway, but it's a bit disappointing.
 

poodaddy

Member
Oh no. A racist in my vidyagaemz? Gosh diggity darn it.

Time to start background checking everyone that's involved in the creation of an entertainment product you consume. I bet there's a lot worse shit out there than JonTron.
Way to come off like a complete and total prick. Others being worse than Jontron doesn't negate the fact that Jontron is admitted and fully out of the closet racist; and in supporting a product that associates with him you imlicitly condone the behavior.
 

RockmanBN

Member
The bar for being a racist and it not mattering is super fucking low right now unfortunately.
I mean people on YouTube forget everything. Tmartn and React Channel have operated like nothing happened after their incidents. Kids and a lot of people don't care.
 
It's up to them at the end of the day. I think this sends a message - "We believe bigoted statements and actions should not have consequences" - and it makes the decision to skip their game in this busy season all the easier.

Cause, effect.
 

jholmes

Member
Gears for Breakfast has shown themselves to collectively possess some very poor judgment many times in the past so I can't say I'm surprised by this. I didn't like that they felt the need to associate themselves with this guy before he told everyone to stop dirtying his gene pool, I'm obviously not impressed that he's still in it.

Those of you who have watched any Roman Polanski movie since 1977, or The Naked Gun any time since 1994, please raise your hands. Now would you kindly make your way outside and stop being hypocrites.

I too remember all those Naked Gun movies released after Nicole Brown Simpson was murdered. Very relevant to the discussion here.
 

Salty Hippo

Member
This seems like an immensely petty thing to personally hold against a developer

they had no control over him revealing himself to be a moron, and if his role is extensive, removing him will be even harder and more expensive to deal with

Removing him would be great, but I feel like most of us here should know how time, money, and resources work enough to not shit on the developer for leaving it alone.


.....but it's always easy to know the right choice when you personally have nothing on the line

Agree 100%.
 
My principle is the game looks great and that's all that sways my purchasing intention *shrug*

The game does indeed look great.

I preordered it months ago.

It is a great game - I played the Beta.

But I can't simply shrug and look away from this because 'the game looks great'.
 

Crossing Eden

Hello, my name is Yves Guillemot, Vivendi S.A.'s Employee of the Month!
Oh no. A racist in my vidyagaemz? Gosh diggity darn it.

Time to start background checking everyone that's involved in the creation of an entertainment product you consume. I bet there's a lot worse shit out there than JonTron.
I read posts like this and my mind just comes back to the question:But guys why is gaming still uncool?
 

Machina

Banned
I dearly hope a lot of people in this thread don't say something stupid in their lives then are forced to be held accountable for it for the rest of their days
 

Mesoian

Member
Those of you who have watched any Roman Polanski movie since 1977, or The Naked Gun any time since 1994, please raise your hands. Now would you kindly make your way outside and stop being hypocrites

Oh please, this is some dumb shit. If OJ murdered his wife during the filming of the naked gunn movies, those things would have been canned for years.
 

Camjo-Z

Member
Due to issues surrounding A Hat in Time brought to my attention by Cerium, I concur that a dialogue needs to take place regarding whether or not it's appropriate to platform this game on GAF due to the JonTron controversy. Mod input would be appreciated.

If the shameful shenanigans of a game's voice actor were grounds for banning discussion of said game on GAF, PaRappa topics would be off-limits by now.
 

KLoWn

Member
Again, the people who would have a problem with the game over something like this generally aren't the people who review bomb.
I'll admit that I usually don't follow who review bombs who and why, but I find that extremely unlikely. There's going to be "Racist! etc etc" reviews for sure.
 

Gaardus

Member
A Google employee outed himself as a racist. I really hope Google deleted and rewrote all of his code, or I'm never using Google products again!
That's a weak comparison, considering that dude was fired, there's a much stronger personal/public connection between a voice actor and the resulting body of work, and someone else can unquestionably provide a drop-in replacement for recorded dialogue.
 

jholmes

Member
Oh, we're doing this again? Can't say I envy Gears for Breakfast; there's no way out of this in a way that pleases everyone. Except maybe if Jon himself would ask to be removed, but it's probably too late for even that to not upset people.

I wasn't even aware he was in the game, tbh.
I also don't mind him still being in, but that's neither here nor there.

There's no way out of this that pleases everyone, either you upset most people or you upset the racists. What a conundrum.
 
Google publicly fired that guy.

I mean, they fired him.

What is your point?

Yeah, but did they delete all of the code he ever wrote? It's not like John Tron is still working for Gears for Breakfast; the only difference is that in this case, his contract was temporary from the start.

I think it's ridiculous to expect a company to spend money and other resources redoing work just because of the views of a former employee / business partner.
 
Those of you who have watched any Roman Polanski movie since 1977, or The Naked Gun any time since 1994, please raise your hands.

I have never watched a Polanski movie, or Naked Gun (I hate that type of comedy, I don't know what terrible thing related to it you are referring to).

I get to complain about a racist piece of shit having a role in a video game now, right?
 
A Google employee outed himself as a racist. I really hope Google deleted and rewrote all of his code, or I'm never using Google products again!

Jon was basically celebrity endorsement for this game. It's very different to have had a sketchy programmer, then to have the face of your game be promoted by a immensely awful racist.

He was pretty firm on black people being genetically inferior to white people. He cited the current state of Africa as evidence to why blacks commit more crime than whites in America. There is not reading of that, that isn't talking about innate genetic inferiority.
 

thiscoldblack

Unconfirmed Member
Why is this guy voicing characters in kickstarter games anyway? Honestly, Games for Breakfast should've seen this from a mile away and should've removed this guy's voice from the game long ago.
 

PSqueak

Banned
This seems like an immensely petty thing to personally hold against a developer

they had no control over him revealing himself to be a moron, and if his role is extensive, removing him will be even harder and more expensive to deal with

Removing him would be great, but I feel like most of us here should know how time, money, and resources work enough to not shit on the developer for leaving it alone.


.....but it's always easy to know the right choice when you personally have nothing on the line

Fine, don't remove him, how about a fucking comment of how the views jon expresses don't reflect that of the developers? How about an Assassins creed styled "people of many creeds worked on this game" minimum effort disclaimer? We're not getting any of that shit yet.

Why is this guy voicing characters in kickstarter games anyway? Honestly, Games for Breakfast should've seen this from a mile away and should've removed this guy's voice from the game long ago.

For Yooka Layle it was because he got connections through Grant Kirkhope during his game grumps days.

For this game it was a stunt casting.
 

Nosgotham

Junior Member
still buying it. if i worried about the personal views of voice actors im sure i wouldnt enjoy ANY games. keep that stuff seperate from my enjoyment if a game tbh
 

Carl

Member
The game does indeed look great.

I preordered it months ago.

It is a great game - I played the Beta.

But I can't simply shrug and look away from this because 'the game looks great'.

Well I'm thankful that I don't let silly matters like this make me miss out on a great game
 
Those of you who have watched any Roman Polanski movie since 1977, or The Naked Gun any time since 1994, please raise your hands. Now would you kindly make your way outside and stop being hypocrites.

Gears for Breakfast has clearly put a lot of heart and soul in to this game, let's not let JonTron ruin that. Let's just mute the volume every time his voice comes on instead.
Never watched a Roman Polanski film or understand what he has to do with a thread on a eugenics spouting racist in gaming ?
 

Zubz

Banned
I really want this game, but I never upped my pledge to the PS4 because they never commented on the issue. I'll download when I know he's gone.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom