• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Autumn Anime 2017 |OT| Makes us all rotten

Dragoborne - rise to supremacy- 1

Well bushiroad makes me wish more western focused tcgs would get animations, though if only this was full length. Good introduction of the different types. Good designs and I think I hear enisshiwishi.
DL0LTL3VAAAUkqV.jpg:small
DL0LTKfUQAAnprO.jpg:small
 
Dragoborn - rise to supremacy- 2
DL0NL4vUIAA47h7.jpg:small

Hot warrior and a battle of the witches? Nice. They could have made the dragon look better.
DL0M6u-UEAAYQ5r.jpg:small
DL0M62OUIAAE60n.jpg:small

The plot is compelling why is it stuck at just five minutes, I wanted more.
 

Syrinx

Member
Princess Principal 1

Geographically speaking, I'm not sure how London could act as a nexus between the western and eastern halves of a kingdom.
 
Juni Taisen 2

God, what a boring episode. There's basically two reasons why people would watch Juni Taisen, to see edgy characters that border the line between cool and stupid as hell, and for gratuitous sexy violence.

Episode 2 offers none of that.
 
Sengoku Night Blood Episode 2
DL0QFh8VAAAh7Tt.jpg:small
DL0TVuWVwAAsYvy.jpg:small

Definitely an otome inspired anime, they even had the relationship moments with multiple characters, still on team Hideyoshi (would have agree on the spot) but Toshii was a bit cute in his random blushing scene, when he even lost his footing from it. Hideyoshi needs to compliment him more.
 
Kino’s Journey 01

Something about this threw me off. The first episode of the original series was such a perfect way to start thematically, but the moral here seems a bit, well, kinda shitty.
People are allowed to be judge, jury, and executioner, and it is rules that make people bad? Am I reading that right? It reads like someone big into the NRA would write.
 
Food Wars! The Third Plate Episode 2
DL0aBv4UIAAhMxr.jpg:small
DL0djH1XUAA8Pvv.jpg:small

Look how happy Taku is for Soma and how happy Soma is for his Taku, my earlier claims are clearly supported by evdence. You never see Soma look at anyone else like that.

But regardless I feel like they are kind of trying to get us to the meat of this arc as soon as possible, things just speeding by with the sense of time feeling gone, like all of a sudden he is trying to secure a location and next were there. I did like the taste testing stuff.
DL0d1T8X0AAFrN-.jpg:small

Kuga is hilarious still. Yuki Kaji seems to be having fun playing him.
 

Lain

Member
ID-0 4-12

This was a boring show to watch till the end.
Apart from liking the char designs, finding the CG OK and being happy it was dubbed, everything was kinda painful to go through. I had to force myself to reach the last episode because as the show went on I kept wondering what's their problem? and this was both for the characters as well as the people who directed and wrote the show.
 
Evil or Live Episode 1

Sucked into the Haoliners/Tencent anime thing again, I found this perhaps the most compelling of the ones done so far, thought none have reached kings avatar level yet, but I think this is maybe my third fav. I wish I could read the source.

Shin and Hibiki are actually a nice team though, bailed him out of a huge situation.
DL0kGlbU8AAt-yO.jpg:small
DL0kGnXVoAE2CNG.jpg:small

I guess prison school is becoming a genre.
 

Celegus

Member
Kekkai Sensen




I thought this was Kekkai Sensen: Brotherhood, but it's actually a... sequel? What am I actually watching?

But hey, I liked it! I wasn't exactly a fan of the original (All style, no substance imo), but I realized I actually like the cast? Here's hoping the show actually develops them, this time.

http://webm.land/media/8sO8.webm

I'm totally okay with something that's all style no substance if it's this stylish. Original series didn't make the most sense and dragged near the end, but man oh man this first episode hit all the right buttons for me. The music alone is worth it, even without Bump of Chicken this time around. Can't wait for more!
 
Mahoujin Guru Guru 14

Great episode, maybe the best so far, and I didn't see the twist coming. Also, that preview was legendary. The series is consistently funny.

I always laugh at the dumbest jokes in this show.

Like the fire king
leaving in a car titled 'fire king' and he says he won't reveal his identity quite yet.
LMAO.
 

Kenstar

Member
I enjoyed Blend S 01, the girls are cute and it's mildly funny. I also enjoyed Konohana Kitan 01, for similar reasons. Also the MC in Kitan keeps making that face where they get the diamond shaped mouth like a bird and I can't get enough of it.

These shows will be the ones to sustain me as the days grow darker. I can feel it.

PFoU1eX.jpg
 
I enjoyed Blend S 01, the girls are cute and it's mildly funny. I also enjoyed Konohana Kitan 01, for similar reasons. Also the MC in Kitan keeps making that face where they get the diamond shaped mouth like a bird and I can't get enough of it.

These shows will be the ones to sustain me as the days grow darker. I can feel it.

Love Live! Sunshine Also has some Dia-mond mouths too
 
I thought that was cool.

Quality of the EDM version aside, not many shows have it in them to outright remix their own OPs like that only a few episodes in.

The thing is that most good OP sequences are synced to the music. When you remix the music like this without also changing the visual sequence, it doesn't sync up anymore and so ends up feeling off. The Bites the Dust version of Great Days was a more comprehensive, and hence much better, OP remix.
 

ibyea

Banned
Tokyo Magnitude 8.0 - END

I saw this coming a mile off, infact from the very first episode they began this I could tell what was up
(Camera work always focusing on Mirai from Mari's perspective, the lack of interaction between Yuuki and her.)
but even if I was dissatisfied with how it was handled in the first episode, I guess there was enough hints and nudges to know what the play was and the tradeoff for the finale made up for it (I do wonder how many of those who were watching the show at the time did catch on to it) It did get me teary eyed multiple times and the successive things that
Yuuki left behind. Especially that text message he left for Mirai
was what really got me.

I wasn't sure how I would feel about this show,
I dislike how the death of Yuuki was handled as a is he, isn't he, is he (Infact I burst out laughing when he was "alive" again)
but for a show that I thought would play it safe, it was anything but that. What was a less cynical view towards a disaster than what I'm use to seeing, it starts off as a generic disaster show with some cut corners but then hits an emotional beat towards the end and the overall narrative and characters really moved me and that was something I wasn't expecting when I first jumped on. I'm still not entirely sure if it all felt a little cheap and manipulative by the finale but it left an impression on me.
You will be missed Yuuki :(
7/10

Now I need to watch something upbeat and happy because this is a terrible way to start my day!

I was thinking it was cheap and manipulative in some ways when I watched it, but the sentimentality of the show moved me somehow. It was weird. I personally ended up really liking it.
 

Jarmel

Banned
Bubblegum Crisis-
I have no clue how I ended up watching this, but I did. This is a super old OVA series that started in the late 1980s and it chronicles a group of girls in exosuits called Knight Sabers, who combat Boomers. The show never really explains what Boomers are but they generally appear to be cyborgs provided by a corporation called Genom, although at times the Boomers seem closer to androids. The four girls are Priss, Linna, Sylia, and Nene.
The main girl is Priss who runs a band called Priss and the Replicants. Her VA is Kinuko Oomori who pretty much only did a couple of roles and stopped altogether to focus on her singing career. It's somewhat interesting, not that she gave up on the VA side but her voice itself is very atypical for anime. Her voice has a tone to it that's not quite husky but still a bit rough. She did the singing for a lot of the theme and insert songs as well. The anime at times reminded me of Streets of Fire due to the focus on music and singers, especially the first episode with the concert. Priss is the sassiest so of course she was my favorite of the four. Linna is kind of bland as she's the kind-hearted one of the group but she does get two of the strongest episodes that focus largely on her. Irene didn't deserve that. SHE DIDN'T DESERVE IT. Nene is the rookie and mostly incompetent however the final episode's attention centers on her which ends up making her into a pretty decent character. Her reaction face game is on point. Sylia is the leader and bankrolls the entire operation. She's just sort of in the background and is more the emotional rock than anything else. The main villain and her have a history, in that he murdered her father, but it's never explored beyond just being an event that happens and the two hate each other. There's also Mack who is Sylia's brother and he's the support of the group as he fixes their cycles and mechs but his main characteristic is that he pervs on his sister. I'm about 80 percent sure it's just his sister he's interested in too.
There are 8 episodes in Crisis and after the first three I wasn't particularly feeling the show. Each of the episodes are largely episodic but you could detect a pattern and the minor character deaths were getting old and extremely forced. One woman runs into a building that is in the active process of demolition to get cash she saved up and gets killed, leaving her son without parents. The moment anybody told their backstory, down came the axe. Episode 4 and beyond does a much better job of cutting back on that trope or making the deaths feel more integrated into the episode.
The Boomer story arc, which takes up about four episodes, is definitely the weakest part of the series. Boomers are a fairly boring enemy as they're the generic biomechanical enemy you see in most OVAs from the 1980s. Their designs are bad, they generally don't show much intellect, and most of the fights are straight forward. Episode 5 and 6 are a bit better as they have Boomers that act and look like humans but I was already sick of them by episode 2. The above image is an example of a Boomer that looks human, Sylvie, as she's a sexbot Boomer and her struggle to free herself and her friend was fairly good. It reminded me a bit of Blade Runner with the whole Replicant aspect, which I'm sure was intentional. There was also a morally grey component to their fight as Sylvie and Anri, her friend, just wanted to be free but they were also killing people in the process.
My favorite episodes were the ones that told smaller stories and focused less on some larger picture. Episode 4 was a highlight as it had a mechanic who was victimized by a motorcycle gang and he decides to take matters into his own hands. It's a minor story that happens in this cyberpunk city but because it doesn't involve some grand conspiracy, it's more personal as a result. The audience can see him slowly become more unhinged as the episode progresses and you're not sure whether it's his own psychosis or the machine driving him mad. Episode 7 was another surprising treat as it focuses on Irene's sister who has come for revenge. Funnily enough the plot of this episode happened because Priss's VA, Kinuko Oomori, threatened to back out of the entire anime and they found a replacement. There was such a huge fan backlash though that the producers scrambled and came to terms with Kinuko's agents. I liked though that there were emotional consequences to episode 2. Also, Vision was pretty cool and worked as a good contrast to Priss.
The best episode though is the final one as it follows Nene as she has to deal with Lisa, who is the police chief's niece and a novice reporter. This was a great episode that not only fleshed out Nene's daily life and personality but also why the Knight Sabers fight and how the public views them. Sylia and Lisa have a minor conversation on a couch at night and it gives a good insight into both their views. Not to mention I liked the Nene bullying. The finale was fantastic too with the attack on AD Police Headquarters. Not so much due to the Boomers but because it puts Nene initially into an unusual situation and later with Lisa trying to escape. The character animation in Lisa's segments are phenomenal and the above webm was animated by Takeshi Honda, of Gainax fame.
Can you tell this was made in the 80s? The animation was surprisingly good most of the time as I expected it to be more stiff considering how detailed the mechanical models were. The sakuga general were in spurts but they were enough. I was impressed with the background art which nailed the cyberpunk tone they were going for and some of the later episodes reminded me of Ogura's city work in GITS. You don't see this art style much anymore and Kenichi Sonoda's character designs are a crucial part of that. Why doesn't he still do character design work nowadays? His stuff is so good.
I'm sort of mixed on the series as I didn't enjoy the Boomer content, I didn't completely hate all of it either, but I loved the rest of the episodes. The second half of the series is definitely stronger than the first half. The characters are the strong point of the show which is good but it too often gets bogged down with Boomer fights that I don't particularly care about. It oozes style though from the theatrical musical openings to the cyberpunk design work. The female focus should also be mentioned as we don't see many action anime like this. I can easily see why this was popular in its era. The guy who peddled anime on me, back when I was an innocent child, gave me the VHS tapes but I don't think I ever watched them. I regret that as I would have probably liked this a lot more when I was younger but I still had a ton of fun.
 

Lain

Member
Symphogear 13

I had no idea there was gonna be a 13th episode honestly so it was great to find out, and what a damn good episode to close the season with that fight (I took the last transformation and attack as a homage to Saint Seiya, complete with Pegasus special move) and the obvious, somewhat ominous, foreshadowing/cliffhanger for the next season.

Symphogear was really my anime of the summer.
 

Jotakori

Member
Houseki no Kuni ep1

This is really interesting! The CG throws me way the heck off, and I constantly can't help but think how much more beautiful it'd be if it was traditionally animated but it's still fairly pretty and cool. Very different, but got me curious enough to wanna keep up with it.

Children of the Whales ep1

Loving this so far, it's super gorgeous. I love the world setting, I love the backgrounds, I love the character art and animations. I'm definitely really in to seeing where this goes. Funnily enough, I just watched Gargantia the other day -- the settings feel really similar just sand instead of water, I dig it.

Juuni Taisen ep2 (aka zodiac hunger games lmao)

Super digging this one so far, also really like the OP song. The girls could really use some pants buuuutt y'know, that's anime for you lmao. But today's death really took me by surprise LMAO -- not in who it was, I kinda expected it right off the bat, but how it happened. Like, god damn.
 

XAL

Member
Black Clover Ep 2

Man, this episode is one huge red flag.

It is 98% filler. No I'm not joking.

Starts off with the last 5 minutes of episode 1, then it goes into a completely useless flashback that offers no insight or character development that couldn't be expressed in a sentence or two of spoken dialogue.

And boy if you thought head-dipshit's VO was loud and obnoxious, say hello to the child version of the character with a performance that I can only describe as nails on a chalkboard through a megaphone down a fucking glass hallway - and this kid never shuts up so it's a solid 17 minute test of sanity. The episode ends with about 40 seconds of footage that advances the plot, essentially Asta hits the guy with the sword that you already saw conjured in the first episode and again at the beginning of this episode, then the bros say they wanna be be wizard kings and walk into the sunset... THAT'S IT. That's the entire episode. The Manga creator must have been desperate for filler pages and/or the anime director must be desperate for low budget filler episodes because boy, in either case someone is a troll because they made you wait a week to see if this gets better and you get slapped with a big old time waster that could have been expressed last week as a 30-60 second post credits scene. Like, what were they thinking??

Also the OP and the ED are boring and completely forgettable, just like this episode.

Does anyone know if this series is even worth a damn down the line? Or is this utterly shallow time waster of an episode indicative of future episodes?
Because I don't think I've ever had my time wasted and intelligence insulted quite like this before.


Junebug Tyson Grill Ep 1+2

"I'm smart and badass, here is some back story on why I'm badass and smart - o no i r dead"

I hope this is not a pattern that repeats past episode 2.
 

Shard

XBLAnnoyance
The best I have ever seen claimed is that Black Clover gets decent to goodish down the line, which is not the best of endorsements.
 
Juni Taisen 2

God, what a boring episode. There's basically two reasons why people would watch Juni Taisen, to see edgy characters that border the line between cool and stupid as hell, and for gratuitous sexy violence.

Episode 2 offers none of that.

Well I feel like for this show, the formula is going to be, whomever's backstory they portray and whoever gets the most internal dialogue for the episode
gets killed.

UQ Holder - 2 I still don't like Tota's or Yukihime's VAs but they nailed Kuromarou's. Also looks like they skipped the Shinobu introduction of Chp.2 which is weird because you see her in the ED?

The fight sequences actually have okay animation surprisingly. For some reason, I always though Kirie had purple hair, not sure if she had a pane where she was colored in the manga?
 

mankoto

Member
URAHARA - 02

Precure A La Mode 2 is taking a weird turn. The girls are turning their enemies into sweets and are eating them....

On the upside, this episode didn't feel as random and all over the place as the previous one.

Konohana Kitan - 02
So Satsuki is given the day off because Yuzu has gotten good at her job, but then Satsuki makes Yuzu spend the day with her. It almost defeats the purpose of giving her the day off. Fun episode nonetheless.

At this point I'm just going to assume people aren't working at that hotel by choice.
 

Shard

XBLAnnoyance
Urahara Episode 2:

Better than episode 1 but still lacking in being an actually interesting series still, which is kind of shocking given the tools at disposal.
 

mankoto

Member
Evil or Live Episode 1
The premise is interesting to say the least. As far as everything else? That depends on this whole Shiori ordeal.
 
Kino's Journey 01

Something about this threw me off. The first episode of the original series was such a perfect way to start thematically, but the moral here seems a bit, well, kinda shitty.
People are allowed to be judge, jury, and executioner, and it is rules that make people bad? Am I reading that right? It reads like someone big into the NRA would write.

The series is never interested in expending moral, isn't it? This episode seems to talk about finding a place to belong, and that country happens to be
where damaged killers feel at home, doing the only way they know to live in peace. It's not necessarily a good thing.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Kino’s Journey 01

Something about this threw me off. The first episode of the original series was such a perfect way to start thematically, but the moral here seems a bit, well, kinda shitty.
People are allowed to be judge, jury, and executioner, and it is rules that make people bad? Am I reading that right? It reads like someone big into the NRA would write.

It's that people are intrinsically bad, rules or no rules, and that peace can only be maintained if everyone agrees to it.

It does have an NRA bent though, no lie. I heard the author is kind of authoritarian and loves guns.
 
In response to Kino’s Journey 01:


I just don't get why they made the vibe of the town feel creepy and off, like everybody there was dangerous or something. The people in fact are not dangerous provided you don't kill or steal and then well, pray they kill you quickly at that point.
 
The series is never interested in expending moral, isn't it? This episode seems to talk about finding a place to belong, and that country happens to be where damaged killers feel at home, doing the only way they know to live in peace.
Kino isn't interested in morals, but the text does imply some sort of Aesop fables-esque structure. That being said, I like your reading better than mine about living a place where you belong vs. living somewhere to exploit it, because it fits how the story develops and how it is resolved better than just
rules make people assholes
.

It does have an NRA bent though, no lie. I heard the author is kind of authoritarian and loves guns.
I read this too, and it did give me pause (I'm not sure where though, probably Neogaf). I'll keep watching because I liked the previous series, but I feel gross watching it because of my politics and the current situation in America.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
UQ Holder - 2 I still don't like Tota's or Yukihime's VAs but they nailed Kuromarou's. Also looks like they skipped the Shinobu introduction of Chp.2 which is weird because you see her in the ED?

The fight sequences actually have okay animation surprisingly. For some reason, I always though Kirie had purple hair, not sure if she had a pane where she was colored in the manga?

I assumed she had the same hair color as Asuna does (light brown), but I guess it was always intended to be blonde in color. I kinda thought they were going to speed through this, but its a pretty glacial adaptation in terms of pacing. Given that Shinobu is in the OP I wouldn't be surprised if they change it to make Shinobu join the team even though it makes no sense
since Shinobu doesn't have any powers
 

blurr

Member
Kado: The Right Answer 11-12 END

Kado's tendency distill something simple out of a much more complex and larger concept is probably its most characteristic trait from start to finish. While that sort of simplification does pave way for progression and viewer comprehension at a decent rate, the point at which it becomes intolerant for one is subjective and there is going to be a point eventually if not early on. I've read others talk about how it oversimplifies geo-politics and technical aspect of the fiction, I can comprehend them as subjective issues but I don't see that as an objective flaw/misstep for the show.


Likewise, the last few episodes feature zaShunina's awakening of a "human" side of him reveals an irrational or emotionally driven self. Something he is still unable to understand. Now this isn't something that's made clear in the show and where it gets a bit out of the line. Its tendency to simplify carries on in the character writing aspect as well and this is the point for me, much like geo-politics was for everyone else. That being said, on the flip side, I appreciate the consistency of it which is why I'm going so far as to define it as the characteristic trait of the show. I think in one sense, I appreciate the fact that it doesn't spell it out, whether it was a deliberate choice or just a result of sloppy writing. I did find it odd that zaShunina who was once the most calm and calculative person resorts to force on the matter of Shindo joining the anisotropic, it wasn't until the final episode that it made sense, even if it was his intention all along, it was an unexpected means to achieve it. It was also made clear as to what aspect of humanity he found so fascinating with him exemplifying the perfect clones as someone/something distinct from the original despite holding the same information. I wish they went even more into detail about that though.


Zashunina's logical and calculative approach would have hit a wall early on if it were not for the grand scale of things. Humanity is a lot more calculative about collective well being but when it's an individual, things aren't always so. Humanity was a collective with Shindo being a conduit(another simplification) but zaShunina was alone, if anything he had an enemy in Saraka. Once zaShunina awakened a human side of him, he felt more vulnerable and alone. That is perhaps the price he had to pay for more information. Saraka's reveal as an anisotropic was vital as a plot device to eventually get zashunina to understand that there is no ultimate even if it seems so from a logical point of view. The right answer was to move forward.

Beyond the oversimplification, the ideas and concepts are something I'm continually fascinated the more I think about it. In that sense, this is definitely been an interesting enough show for me from start to finish. I can see myself recommending it.
 
Top Bottom