• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter of Anime 2013 |OT -4| It's not my fault!

Community's choice! What should the next numbering of the |OT| format be?


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Is Horizon really that good?

It has a very weak beginning especially with how they keep switching character perspectives at the start, but it becomes a lot better at around episode four or five though.

Additional wiki reading is probably needed if you want to understand everything otherwise, it is a really fun ride.
 
penguin drum 1

my-brain-is-full-of-fuck.jpg


is not drawing the unimportant people in crowds a trend or named technique or something, i've seen if before in at least one show

rock and roll

ALIS in Wonderland

did he kiss the sister('s body)?

with no anti-dub bias i can say that the voice acting is kind of awkward

I am intrigued enough to continue
 
penguin drum 1

my-brain-is-full-of-fuck.jpg


is not drawing the unimportant people in crowds a trend or named technique or something, i've seen if before in at least one show

rock and roll

ALIS in Wonderland

did he kiss the sister('s body)?

with no anti-dub bias i can say that the voice acting is kind of awkward

I am intrigued enough to continue

Please report back for every episode.
 

Westlo

Member
Holy fuck at those Horizon novels.... That shit if never going to be fully animated, especially since the author is still churning out a lot of novels.
 

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
Bit the bullet and signed up for Hulu Plus to finish Ah! My Goddess. Commercials aren't bothering me nearly as much as I thought they would, mainly cause I like to browse GAF even while watching anyway. And they were over midway through typing this post.

They honestly aren't all that bad, half the time I get the survey to skip the commercials.

Find a decent writer on GAF and submit this to those light novel competitions in Japan. It'll be a big hit.

Shit man, if I knew how to write in Japanese I would do it.
 
Toradora! 1-3
I don't like Taiga at all, and it's not just because she has no boobs. I'd hate her even if she had tits the size of her head. I like the other characters though, so I hope Taiga gets better.
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
Space Brothers movie

Maybe it's because I used to be such a space fanboy, but I feel like the movie captures a lot of what I want the show to capture. Yeah, there are so many changes and the ending is basically a "we need to end this movie even though the manga will probably take 20 years to get to this conclusion" type of ending, but I feel like the moments where they try to be earnest works fairly well.

I guess to avoid series spoilers, I'll just talk about generalities, but it has such a great opening intro sequence:
RKiFal.jpg

If you are a NASA history dork, it's like someone made an AMV with space footage, but added some production values and graphics to make it look really slick. Funny enough, it reminded me of the early CoD tech porn montages (or maybe the CoD:WaW montages) but used to much better effect.

Probably the biggest worry I had was that this would be cheap, because it's a Japanese movie. I don't think this is too much of a spoiler:
1rW66l.jpg


So at least they film on location. Thank god. And speaking of which, the English is actually passable. It's what I wish they did for the anime... but if the anime is for children, then I suppose forcing children to read subtitles for large sections of the anime is a non-starter. Still, I'm glad it's not a bunch of Japanese people pretending to be white people while speaking Japanese and trying to get us to believe that it's English. Everyone is race and language appropriate - thank god.

qvVeyl.jpg

The space porn is good. I'm sure if this was some big budget 200 million dollar movie, it'd look better (I guess there's a moon landing sequence in one of the Transformers films?), but I thought it looked great.

8z6UHl.jpg

3d Serika is still always hungry.

Oh, and the biggest surprise to me was this:
6F5rjl.jpg

I really can't believe they got
Buzz Aldrin to show up and the way they use him fits exactly with what happens in the anime as well. This scene totally makes up for the shitty ME3 ending and makes me wonder if he literally just phoned in the "my sweet" moment in that shitty, shitty game.
I'm not going to say he'd win any kind of acting award, but he actually gave a decent and inspiring speech about space exploration. In English no less.

I also like that they basically expect the Japanese audience to know who he is. Either you recognize him as one of the most famous human beings in the 20th century or you don't. And if you don't, you probably wouldn't be watching a movie called Space Brothers anyway.

I'm really surprised. The last Japanese movie I watched was Usagi Drop, which turned out fairly well, and this came out pretty good too. Too bad about that MariMite movie. lol
 

Dresden

Member
Space Brothers movie

I really can't believe they got
Buzz Aldrin to show up and the way they use him fits exactly with what happens in the anime as well. This scene totally makes up for the shitty ME3 ending and makes me wonder if he literally just phoned in the "my sweet" moment in that shitty, shitty game.
I'm not going to say he'd win any kind of acting award, but he actually gave a decent and inspiring speech about space exploration. In English no less.

I also like that they basically expect the Japanese audience to know who he is. Either you recognize him as one of the most famous human beings in the 20th century or you don't. And if you don't, you probably wouldn't be watching a movie called Space Brothers anyway.

I'm really surprised. The last Japanese movie I watched was Usagi Drop, which turned out fairly well, and this came out pretty good too. Too bad about that MariMite movie. lol

Yo that shit is straight up hype.

Makes me want to see that and the Thermae Romae movie.
 

Narag

Member
I wonder why there's never been an ongoing/long running LN adaptation. Maybe that stuff just isn't as easy as arranging panels from a manga.

I'd imagine they exist more to promote the LNs with show popularity being a side bonus. Also, I wouldn't want LN filler!
 

Articalys

Member
For anyone who's seen both the Space Brothers live-action movie and has kept up with the anime so far, could you please guesstimate about how many minutes of the movie take place after where the anime currently is now?
 

cajunator

Banned
penguin drum 1

my-brain-is-full-of-fuck.jpg


is not drawing the unimportant people in crowds a trend or named technique or something, i've seen if before in at least one show

rock and roll

ALIS in Wonderland

did he kiss the sister('s body)?

with no anti-dub bias i can say that the voice acting is kind of awkward

I am intrigued enough to continue
Yes.
This show is as fucked up as you think it is.
Welcome to Penguin drum!
Ikuharaaaaaaa!!!!!!!!



Toradora! 1-3

I don't like Taiga at all, and it's not just because she has no boobs. I'd hate her even if she had tits the size of her head. I like the other characters though, so I hope Taiga gets better.

Taiga starts out as a shitty kugiloli and ends up an adorable sweetheart.
Well, mostly.
 
Also, cause it's always fun to see how much material Horizon actually has:
There is the encyclopedia to help you understand the world, society and terms used in the series...

No idea if it's any good, but I can appreciate an author putting so much work into creating a world that they got so much material out of it and such a reference is needed.

(But I hope the quality merits it, so it's not a waste of people's time, ha)
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
I had no idea such a thing existed. And Buzz is in it. That's surreal.
It was a jaw dropping moment for me. lol

Yo that shit is straight up hype.

Makes me want to see that and the Thermae Romae movie.
It's good. I'm not going to say it's the best thing ever, but it captures the spirit of the anime and does it in a way that makes sense for a movie (outside of the ending).
 

Syrinx

Member
Ah! My Goddess 25

Drinking booze at a playground. That's why Urd is so awesome.

The disappointment at a cliched "character becomes young again" plot dissipated as soon as I saw just how adorable Urd was as a child. And she isn't adorable in a moe way, either. It's more that she just acts like she was actually kid again. Her little romance with that kid was primo hhnnnnnggg material. And that scene at the end where grown up Urd gives him that kiss on the forehead...yeah. Best part was Keiichi watching with that "The fuck is going on with this?!" face.

Minor question: How the hell did tiny Belldandy not get blown off Keiichi's shoulder when he was on his motorcycle?

Won't be able to catch 26 tonight. Going to bed. Looking forward to seeing it.
 

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
That's a cool looking book.


I sincerely hope you're right.

She does get better. I think. Well I remember liker her more and more as time went on. Maybe.

Ah! My Goddess 25

Drinking booze at a playground. That's why Urd is so awesome.

The disappointment at a cliched "character becomes young again" plot dissipated as soon as I saw just how adorable Urd was as a child. And she isn't adorable in a moe way, either. It's more that she just acts like she was actually kid again. Her little romance with that kid was primo hhnnnnnggg material. And that scene at the end where grown up Urd gives him that kiss on the forehead...yeah. Best part was Keiichi watching with that "The fuck is going on with this?!" face.

Minor question: How the hell did tiny Belldandy not get blown off Keiichi's shoulder when he was on his motorcycle?

Won't be able to catch 26 tonight. Going to bed. Looking forward to seeing it.

26 is a good one. Skuld becomes a bit more bearable after it.
 

Syrinx

Member
She does get better. I think. Well I remember liker her more and more as time went on. Maybe.



26 is a good one. Skuld becomes a bit more bearable after it.

Oh shit, how did I forget that in my post?
If nothing else, her being grown up will get rid of that ungodly shrill voice of hers.
 

Ultimadrago

Member
Space Brothers movie

Maybe it's because I used to be such a space fanboy, but I feel like the movie captures a lot of what I want the show to capture. Yeah, there are so many changes and the ending is basically a "we need to end this movie even though the manga will probably take 20 years to get to this conclusion" type of ending, but I feel like the moments where they try to be earnest works fairly one.

I'm really surprised. The last Japanese movie I watched was Usagi Drop, which turned out fairly well, and this came out pretty good too. Too bad about that MariMite movie. lol

This is now on my very brief list of live-action adaptations to check out.
 

Extollere

Sucks at poetry
This is now on my very brief list of live-action adaptations to check out.

I'm gonna check it out too. Hopefully it's more entertaining than the show, which I dropped after about 8 or 9 episodes. I also dropped the Ace Attorney movie halfway. It was okay, actors were chosen well, but the mood was all wrong. It went from lighthearted comedy/drama to wannabe serious/dark drama. That and it was boring as hell.
 

Westlo

Member
There is the encyclopedia to help you understand the world, society and terms used in the series...

I heard the author wrote a fuckload of notes for the Horizon Team @ Studio 8 during the production of both seasons. He was really involved in the process of the anime, and it was still confusing as fuck at first.
 
I heard the author wrote a fuckload of notes for the Horizon Team @ Studio 8 during the production of both seasons. He was really involved in the process of the anime, and it was still confusing as fuck at first.

Well one of the main problems was that they faithfully adapted the first chapters which was written with switched character perspective hence why it made no sense. They could have easily went with a method that actually explained stuff but instead choose to just follow the novels. It still works out in the end.
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
This is now on my very brief list of live-action adaptations to check out.
Woot!
I'm gonna check it out too. Hopefully it's more entertaining than the show, which I dropped after about 8 or 9 episodes. I also dropped the Ace Attorney movie halfway. It was okay, actors were chosen well, but the mood was all wrong. It went from lighthearted comedy/drama to wannabe serious/dark drama. That and it was boring as hell.
I don't know if it's "better" than the show inasmuch as the movie takes the best parts of the manga and chooses to focus on those moments rather than try to adapt every single thing possible.
(Okay, maybe I am saying that it's better than the show. lol)
If you did like what the show was about though, this is a good version of that story.


Well I'm sold.
Yeah, I was afraid to show the movie's big hand, but I realized this would be the only way to get people to watch the movie so I don't feel too bad about it. lol
 
Horizon is good stuff ...i think every make sense but one thing i'm sure is that the author sure has an open mind that has no limits ...

bring it on season 3 !
 

Ultimadrago

Member
Ben-To 1

Well, that was something! I'm watching this on sonicmj's indirect recommendation. I read some bare bones on the premise and for the most part its first episode played out as I expected, but that didn't prevent me from having some fun seeing people beat the crap out of each other for a cheap meal. I'm sure it wouldn't be out of place to desire even crazier fights from here on out as Yō learns what it truly means to fight over supermarket discount food.
 

Milamber

Member
Horizon is good stuff ...i think every make sense but one thing i'm sure is that the author sure has an open mind that has no limits ...

bring it on season 3 !

Impossibru! The next book pulls out so much awesomeness that S3 has to be 26 eps at the least!

Season 1 - Setup
Season 2 - Taking the first step into adventure
Season 3 and beyond - ...


hZEz6.gif
 

jbug617

Banned
Toradora! 1-3

I don't like Taiga at all, and it's not just because she has no boobs. I'd hate her even if she had tits the size of her head. I like the other characters though, so I hope Taiga gets better.

I feel she gets better as the show goes on as she opens up to other people.
 

Westlo

Member
Impossibru! The next book pulls out so much awesomeness that S3 has to be 26 eps at the least!

Season 1 - Setup
Season 2 - Taking the first step into adventure
Season 3 and beyond - ...


hZEz6.gif

How many episodes are we looking at for what is available right now?

Also is it anywhere near concluding?
 

Extollere

Sucks at poetry
Nausicaa's score is so good!

Main Theme

Holy Shit. I'm gonna have to watch this movie.

I've posted this before, but the song Sadness M-26, has constantly been in my playlist since viewing Gunbuster. To me, it's a perfect cinematic track that encompasses the feeling of death and sacrifice. I love me some downer music <3
 

Milamber

Member
How many episodes are we looking at for what is available right now?

If they will be faithful to the books? Optimistically I'd say, counting what we have now also, 120~160 eps. It's still ongoing though.


Also is it anywhere near concluding?

Author didn't say and no proper translations of the last few books to tell.
 

cajunator

Banned
Ben-To 1


Well, that was something! I'm watching this on sonicmj's indirect recommendation. I read some bare bones on the premise and for the most part its first episode played out as I expected, but that didn't prevent me from having some fun seeing people beat the crap out of each other for a cheap meal. I'm sure it wouldn't be out of place to desire even crazier fights from here on out as Y&#333; learns what it truly means to fight over supermarket discount food.

Dude....this show is sooo fun
Its the silliest shit ever.
Ice witch is a goddess.
 

wonzo

Banned
TWGOK Tenri Arc 2 END

twgoktenri2.jpg


It's seems pretty weird they'd leave such a pivotal plot point to two OVA's bundled with the Limited Edition prints of the manga but whatevs. The ED had BASED YUI, doll loli, shogi, sumire, akari, the worthless hinoki, and sexswimming hair. S3 GET HYPE.

couldn't give a shit about the kanon ova tho
 

B-Dubs

No Scrubs
TWGOK Tenri Arc 2 END

twgoktenri2.jpg


It's seems pretty weird they'd leave such a pivotal plot point to two OVA's bundled with the Limited Edition prints of the manga but whatevs. The ED had BASED YUI, doll loli, shogi, sumire, akari, the worthless hinoki, and sexswimming hair. S3 GET HYPE.

couldn't give a shit about the kanon ova tho

You mean the one where they were all studying? That was actually kind of important too...
 

Westlo

Member
Holy Shit. I'm gonna have to watch this movie.

Yeah that's some good ass music... think I might make Winter a watch all the Ghibli movies season... since the only one I've seen is Spirited Away.

If they will be faithful to the books? Optimistically I'd say, counting what we have now also, 120~160 eps. It's still ongoing though.

Well this shit is never going to get fully animated lol. It has to eventually drop off in sales and even if it maintained it I'm sure Studio 8 will grow sick of it eventually.
 

Westlo

Member
TWGOK Tenri Arc 2 END

It's seems pretty weird they'd leave such a pivotal plot point to two OVA's bundled with the Limited Edition prints of the manga but whatevs.

Well I'm guessing at the time they made it the possibility of a 3rd season was fuck all, how were they to know that Shogakukan were going to throw more money down the drain for a 3rd season.

Anyway the OVA came with the L.Es.... so.

7. The World God Only Knows #20 (89,698 /89,698)
28. The World God Only Knows Limited Edition #20 (42,877/42,877)

So nearly 43k own the Tenri anime while fuck all bought the anime seasons lol.... wonder what the price is on the L.E... obviously nowhere near an anime volume... I mean 450 yen for a manga volume and 7500 for an anime volume and they wonder why it's hard to attract manga fans...

Also what has the anime now covered in term of manga chapters for TWGOK? Anyone got a list?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom