Luminous_Reaver
Neo Member
But A has unrealistic Unreal 4-looking reflections.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Okay, TeamCG. Come own up to your foolishness. #trolljima
- Thread starter MormaPope
- Start date
But A has unrealistic Unreal 4-looking reflections.
Voice of Reason
Banned
Its definitely CG Kojima is the best I love u koj
TheNamelessOne
Member
I think there is enough conclusive evidence to remove "potentially" from the thread title.
Fixed.
efyu_lemonardo
May I have a cookie?
Hero_of_the_Day
Member
scytherage
Member
Expectations like this are the kind that bring massive disappointment. Even if that were really CG, what does it mean? More cutscenes? Will stuff that looks like that even be in gameplay? It's one head. Put in all the other elements and I'm sure they'll start taking shortcuts then it won't look like that anymore.
Been posted a billion times throughout this thread:
I'm new to the thread so forgive me for repeating what has probably been said a lot, but those eyes give the CG away. I don't think I've ever seen a human do a slow half blink like that, unless they were purposely trying to.
That's still some really impressive stuff though.
Gouda Jouji
Member
This thread. What.
Ace Harding
Member
In all seriousness, can't someone prove or disprove this with actual analysis? Or is that not possible?
FlashbladeGAF
Member
Anyone know what the deal is with the shadow of the railing here:
couldnt find a similar image, but is it too much to hope that its actually the supports in the wall that are casting the shadow instead
yeah maybe... oh well.. maybe it's the PS3 version
Plus those eyeballs are huge. Thought they were going to pop out.
He is the trollking we all deserve.
Supreme Stephan
Member
I feel like I'm in the Matrix.
toddhunter
Member
Just woke up and this is still going hey?
All we can really see are the eyes and mouth. The eyes do not move properly and consistently when he blinks.
His mouth? He never opens it whilst always speaking clearly. Nor does he have a tongue beyond two frames... when it overlaps his teeth through the corner of his mouth. And also breathing? His nose is taped up so he needs to breathe through his mouth.
Everybody try at home. Hold your nose, keep your teeth together and conduct a three minute interview. Your lips still need to move in an exagerrated motion. It isn't possible, not even close.
It is CG.
All we can really see are the eyes and mouth. The eyes do not move properly and consistently when he blinks.
His mouth? He never opens it whilst always speaking clearly. Nor does he have a tongue beyond two frames... when it overlaps his teeth through the corner of his mouth. And also breathing? His nose is taped up so he needs to breathe through his mouth.
Everybody try at home. Hold your nose, keep your teeth together and conduct a three minute interview. Your lips still need to move in an exagerrated motion. It isn't possible, not even close.
It is CG.
Fried Food
Banned
Lol this is great
Rickenslacker
Banned
Now this looks more convincing but the chin gives it away, makes it obvious why they bandaged Joakim up.This thread. What.
couldnt find a similar image, but is it too much to hope that its actually the supports in the wall that are casting the shadow instead
yeah maybe... oh well.. maybe it's the PS3 version
I think he was referring to the awful shadows.
Speedwagon
Michelangelo painted the Sistine Chapel. Yabuki turned off voice chat in Mario Kart races. True artists of their time.
Just_myles
Member
Duane Cunningham said:
It's not that, I prefer it when they simply just show the cinematic trailers. I like what they did with Snake Eater. Although I can't recall if they did any teaser trailers or something akin to what they are doing now. I don't understand the point of what Kojipro is trying to do with this. I guess I will find out when everybody else does.
Duane Cunningham
Member
This thread. What.
Wow, other than the dithering on the texture on his cheek, that's a pretty solid Kojima model. Hell, if they can do this, pulling off Mogren isn't out of the realm of possibility. Background is obviously 2D, but what can you do.
NoirVisage
Banned
It's all but confirmed, just got off the phone with Joakim. The twist? He doesn't even exist! I was taking to myself. The phantom pain strikes again.
Yes. I've never been "tricked" before, I could always tell what was CG and what wasn't. But if this was CG then it marks the first time I believed I was watching something real when it actually wasn't.
Crazy...
LOL dude, I'm dying on my end right!
Duane Cunningham
Member
If this is CG, it not only tricked a ton of people, but it tricked a ton of people who are carefully scrutinizing it!
StalkerUKCG
Banned
Joakim blinks a lot, I don't see people blink that much. CG makes the renders blink to simulate reality but it always looks odd.
I kind of think its CG, not sure either way but put me down for those who will eat crow if its real.
I kind of think its CG, not sure either way but put me down for those who will eat crow if its real.
PaulExcellent
Member
BurnOutBrighter
Banned
It's definitive now. Well done, DetectiveGAF. The FOX engine is truly a marvel to behold.
Yup, and the animation is actually pretty bad, soulless.
You're right, this is impossible. Not sure why people think it's not CG.Just woke up and this is still going hey?
All we can really see are the eyes and mouth. The eyes do not move properly and consistently when he blinks.
His mouth? He never opens it whilst always speaking clearly nor does he have a tongue beyond two frames... when it overlaps his teeth through the corner of his mouth. And also breathing? His nose is taped up so he needs to breathe through his mouth.
Everybody try at home. Hold your nose, keep your teeth together and conduct a three minute interview. Your lips still need to move in an exagerrated motion. It isn't possible, not even close.
It is CG.
lazer_bean
Member
i think the "Moby Dick" name has more to do with the book than the film maker because there is a whale in the gameplay trailer (and the studio logo too)
Because they think there isn't a noticeable leap next generation. lol
SlipperyFishes
Banned
Get Digital Foundry on the case
I'm not saying that you can't do it, I'm saying that I can't. Trying it in the mirror I can get close to no movement if I go super slow and just let my eyelids relax, but even then there's some muscles flinching. But if I try to go at the speed of that .gif? My bottom eyelids move just as much as my upper eyelids.
NoirVisage
Banned
its a clothe bandage, NOT duct tape -__-
PaulExcellent
Member
efyu_lemonardo
May I have a cookie?
eh, after watching the HQ version on gametrailers rather than the shitty youtube video I'm back to being a skeptic.
That's how good it is. Amazing right?