Dr_Boris_Goltz
Banned
They really are total junk. They feel great but malfunction too easily.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DS4 build quality is garbage. Why would Sony make such a cheap controller?
- Thread starter gatti-man
- Start date
ComputerBlue
Member
The DS4 that came with my console busted after about 8 months. The left rubber was peeling off, the charge wouldn't hold for longer than 2-3 hours and the R2 had to be pressed really hard for it work.
It was under warranty so I payed the shipping and sent it in.
They replaced it with a "refurbished" unit. Except they must have sent me one from the damn broken pile because what I got in return was not only dirty, but the right analogue wasn't centered and the R2 would stick.
So, I had to pay the shipping again to send it back.
Finally they sent me a working one, has some scuff marks but at least it works, for now.
It was under warranty so I payed the shipping and sent it in.
They replaced it with a "refurbished" unit. Except they must have sent me one from the damn broken pile because what I got in return was not only dirty, but the right analogue wasn't centered and the R2 would stick.
So, I had to pay the shipping again to send it back.
Finally they sent me a working one, has some scuff marks but at least it works, for now.
Agree 100%. Sony unfortunately failed in both design and execution.
On the design side:
-The always-on LED is stupid. I had to buy vynil things to hide it. The reflection on my TV is annoying.
-Absolutely unacceptable battery. I suspect caused by the game controller speaker, which is virtually useless, and the trackpad, which is only slightly less useless.
On the execution side:
The rubber on the analog sticks is defective. It's happened on 2 of my dual shocks already. I'm angry about this because Sony won't replace the second one. And this is their fault.
Execution-wise. The X1 controller is much more reliable, feels like it'll last a decade. Functionality-wise: the trigger specific vibrations are a useful addition. Comfort is slightly less than the DS4.
The only thing I like about DS4 is the comfort. I don't know how much this comfort is responsible for all the flaws, but even if it was 100% responsible, then the trade-off wasn't worth it.
The newer models are better yes. They should of just used the DS3's rubber. It can't be that expensive.
Where have you been? The DS4 has got a TON of shit for it's terrible battery life
I'm glad I seem to be one of the lucky ones who hasn't really had any problems, cause the DS4 is definitely one of my favorite controllers. Three controllers (sold two of them with my PS4), the grip on the sticks started to wear a bit on one of them, but it was mainly a cosmetic problem.
Hellshingu
Member
My only complaint is battery life honestly. I've had my controller since launch and haven't had any issues with it at all. I know that I may be an exception but I've only had 1 person I know own finally start having DS4 issues as of last week everyone else hasn't yet.
Although I will say that the materials do feel somewhat on the cheap. This controller is definitely YMMV. Hopefully when they release a PS4 slim they put more money into the controller materials.
Although I will say that the materials do feel somewhat on the cheap. This controller is definitely YMMV. Hopefully when they release a PS4 slim they put more money into the controller materials.
I like to think people with these problems have sandpaper thumbs and grip the controller with all their strength.
It makes me feel better.
I imagine WD40 isn't the best option, because it's petroleum based and AFAIK it's bad for plastic. The best, I imagine, would be something like lubix cube lubricant for puzzle cubes. That stuff can be expensive, though.
I haven't had any problems with my red DS4 yet, but I don't use it that often, just sometimes on PC. I've also already switched out the sticks to Xbox One replacements, because I like the way they feel more. All I can say is that I think they feel much, much better than any other Sony controller.
Tallshortman
Member
I'm not a regular Destiny player but I haven't had any issues with sticks or triggers whereas my DS3 and 360 controllers both had the loose sticks issue after extended use.
Projectjustice
Banned
It is the shittiest controller this generation. How can the Wii U Gamepad with a touch screen on it out last it in battery life is beyond me. The plastic is cheap and the analog sticks are terrible. I wish I could use my Wii U pro pad on my PS4.
NoblesseOblige
Banned
I've had my DS4 for a year and can't really think of any complaints other than maybe it creaks a little? But functionally it's been just fine. The sticks haven't peeled, the triggers still work, and the battery has never gone low in a game session.
Nuclear Detergent
Member
Every time I see one of these threads my first thought is that there must be some regional differences in the product line. Like you, I feel that the DS4 is a big improvement on the DS3, which is a god awful controller both in terms of ergonomics, design and materials used.
The one complaint I have is that the battery life could be improved.
I wonder how many people in here with perfect controllers use stick covers (of course the sticks won't go bad if you use that, come on now()
I keep saying people say this, do you have any proof that this is true? Bought a White DS4 in January, R2 and sticks already bad.
yeah I'm sure people are eating their controllers, that must surely be the only reason they could ever go bad
Screw it, people want to downplay it, then we will probably never get a actual quality controller.
Sure you aren't chewing on it between rounds champ?
LegendofDragoonLives
Member
They still didn't fix this? I thought they would have by now so I could buy the classic DS4 by September. Uhh...
DS4 is the best controller ever to me. I dont really understand the recent backlash against it when everyone was praising it as the best controller when the PS4 first came out.
Its main problem imo is the battery life. It's absolute shit. Second would be the durability of the analog sticks. Mine are fine, but I know that if I were really rough on them like some people are the skin would just rip off.
Its main problem imo is the battery life. It's absolute shit. Second would be the durability of the analog sticks. Mine are fine, but I know that if I were really rough on them like some people are the skin would just rip off.
Predwolf
Member
Thousands of hours on a launch controller here, it's held up better than all of my DS3s. Stick deadzones are crisp and tight, pads aren't flaking, no squeaks or rattles. This is with 300+ hours of BF4, 200+ of CoD:AW, and dozens of other games.
I went through three SIXAXIS' in the first two years of my PS3 ownership, and three DS3s since they came out.
I went through three SIXAXIS' in the first two years of my PS3 ownership, and three DS3s since they came out.
| Praxis |
Banned
I went through two or three 360 controllers because I used to have my thumbs angled down with my nails in contact with the rubber, it was really bad with a stressful game like Trials. I have since made a conscious effort to only have the pads of my thumbs on the sticks at all times and haven't had the problem since.
Mr Fahrenheit
Member
Besides the stick covers rubbing off mine is still pretty much perfect. It's still worlds better than the 360 controller.
TheRealTalker
Banned
my launch controllers had rubber issues
eventually bought 3 coloured varieties and I haven't had a issue with anything since
eventually bought 3 coloured varieties and I haven't had a issue with anything since
staticneuron
Member
My launch DS4 had no issues until a few months ago when the R2 trigger started sticking. My second controller since launch has been fine.
I hear people have had worse issues but I am not sure if the amount is widespread. With 20 million PS4's out there it would be hard to find out just how much of the general base is represented by the vocal minority here on forums. Especially since people normally don't tend to scream it from the top of roofs or on forum when their devices work as expected.
I hear people have had worse issues but I am not sure if the amount is widespread. With 20 million PS4's out there it would be hard to find out just how much of the general base is represented by the vocal minority here on forums. Especially since people normally don't tend to scream it from the top of roofs or on forum when their devices work as expected.
Third is that it continues the tradition of stacking every button possible on the front meaning you either take your thumb off the aiming stick or you claw.
Senseless in 2005. Silly in 2015.
I've criticized every mainstream controller for doing this. Very happy to see Valve and MS finally addressing the issue.
That's before my quality control criticisms.
cyberheater
PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
It's a good controller apart the unbelievably shitty battery life. It might as well be tethered the amount of time I have it plugged it.
Newtype-001
Member
I always thought the build quality was way better than the ds3. The only sucky thing is the shit battery life it has.
Just to speak i havent had any of the sticks ripping or squeeky triggers.
Just to speak i havent had any of the sticks ripping or squeeky triggers.
hydrophilic attack
Member
I think I've been lucky. My two controllers (I have two so I can keep playing while the other charges) survived my getting a platinum in Olliolli 2, so they will likely survive anything.
Playing a lot of final fantasy xiv on my ps4 controller, the launch controller r2 sticks, it has no spring. Square is an iffy response, the dpad is shot.the stick rubber is off. I need to play using this one plugged in.
Got a second one... Within 3 months neither of them have rubber on the sticks....
After four years the only issue with my ps3 controllers is one of them the right stick doesn't centre correctly.
My nes controllers are fine though... Only issue I've ever had with controllers aside from the ps4 was a GameCube controller not centring the left stick after 5 years lol
Got a second one... Within 3 months neither of them have rubber on the sticks....
After four years the only issue with my ps3 controllers is one of them the right stick doesn't centre correctly.
My nes controllers are fine though... Only issue I've ever had with controllers aside from the ps4 was a GameCube controller not centring the left stick after 5 years lol
Remember when the #1 complaint about the GamePad wasn't teh screen, it was the "pathetic 4 hour battery life"?
I've owned a Wii U since launch. My latest Wii U is the Zelda edition one, bought at launch in 2013. Issues I have experienced:
- Short Battery life
- Wiggly holder for the stylus (fixed with a tiny piece of construction paper)
PS4 Controller issues I've witnessed:
- Thumb pads peeling
- Triggers sticking/breaking
- thumbstick wear and tear (getting looser)
- Poor battery life (seems great at first, but the battery deteriorates at a pretty rapid rate. My friends controller can only hold a charge for an hour now. He has to play plugged in practically all the time)
Xbox One controller issues:
One used controller has something "broken" in the right trigger, but it was busted when I bought it and I only paid $10 for it. The trigger still works, you just have to shake it every once and awhile to shift the broken piece of plastic inside or whatever so it doesn't block the button press.
All new controllers for the system (both what it came with an otherwise) have had zero issues so far. I use all 3 consoles about an equal amount of gaming hours.
Fixed the Wii U gamepad battery life with the officially licensed bigger battery. I hear some 3rd party battery life extenders do a good job too. I get almost 8 hours out of it now.
This generation, the PlayStation 4 has created the worst quality controller of the 3 main home console makers. I give them credit that it "feels nice" when first held, but it doesn't matter how it feels if it can't even hold up under normal play. Meanwhile, the GamePad has always been comfy despite the size, and has had no wear and tear (no surprise. Nintendo's build quality is almost always top of the line for console makers. Only the slider on 3DS's and the thumbstick on the N64's seemed to ever be issues for them). The Xbox One controller has been flawless outside of one that was broken before I bought it. PS4 is just all sorts of issues.
Xbox One > Wii U GamePad > PS4 DS4.
Just my opinion, and this is based both on comfort and durability.
If we throw in the Wii U pro controller, it's then Xbox One > Pro Controll > GamePad > DS4
But, I left it out since it's not bundled with the console. It would probably be a wash between Xbox One and the Pro Controller (or the pro getting a lead due to the insanely long battery life), but as a controller it lacks the proper options on the trigger. Be nice if you could switch between digital and analog for preference - but if you're only going to have one, at least have the better of the two. Not that iit's been an issue with the games they have so far.
I've owned a Wii U since launch. My latest Wii U is the Zelda edition one, bought at launch in 2013. Issues I have experienced:
- Short Battery life
- Wiggly holder for the stylus (fixed with a tiny piece of construction paper)
PS4 Controller issues I've witnessed:
- Thumb pads peeling
- Triggers sticking/breaking
- thumbstick wear and tear (getting looser)
- Poor battery life (seems great at first, but the battery deteriorates at a pretty rapid rate. My friends controller can only hold a charge for an hour now. He has to play plugged in practically all the time)
Xbox One controller issues:
One used controller has something "broken" in the right trigger, but it was busted when I bought it and I only paid $10 for it. The trigger still works, you just have to shake it every once and awhile to shift the broken piece of plastic inside or whatever so it doesn't block the button press.
All new controllers for the system (both what it came with an otherwise) have had zero issues so far. I use all 3 consoles about an equal amount of gaming hours.
Fixed the Wii U gamepad battery life with the officially licensed bigger battery. I hear some 3rd party battery life extenders do a good job too. I get almost 8 hours out of it now.
This generation, the PlayStation 4 has created the worst quality controller of the 3 main home console makers. I give them credit that it "feels nice" when first held, but it doesn't matter how it feels if it can't even hold up under normal play. Meanwhile, the GamePad has always been comfy despite the size, and has had no wear and tear (no surprise. Nintendo's build quality is almost always top of the line for console makers. Only the slider on 3DS's and the thumbstick on the N64's seemed to ever be issues for them). The Xbox One controller has been flawless outside of one that was broken before I bought it. PS4 is just all sorts of issues.
Xbox One > Wii U GamePad > PS4 DS4.
Just my opinion, and this is based both on comfort and durability.
If we throw in the Wii U pro controller, it's then Xbox One > Pro Controll > GamePad > DS4
But, I left it out since it's not bundled with the console. It would probably be a wash between Xbox One and the Pro Controller (or the pro getting a lead due to the insanely long battery life), but as a controller it lacks the proper options on the trigger. Be nice if you could switch between digital and analog for preference - but if you're only going to have one, at least have the better of the two. Not that iit's been an issue with the games they have so far.
I believe they did change the rubber material on the sticks to one that was slightly rougher and less "grippy," but it sounds like people are still having issues with it wearing down.
Super_Cobra
Member
Aside from the rubbers falling off the controller has been pretty solid.
The DS4 at my Best Buy is absolutely destroyed. It's missing several buttons but amazingly the sticks are okay, though it looks like someone tried to pry them out, possibly to replace their own messed up sticks. The Xbox One pad 6 feet away feels a little wonky from abuse, but is intact and works fine. It could just be that it was replaced at some point though.
Nuclear Detergent
Member
I can't say anything about the Xbox One controller, but the Wii U Gamepad is just awful in terms of responsiveness. The large dead zones in the sticks puts way behind the DS4 in terms of quality. But then again, I haven't experienced any of the problems people are reporting with DS4, outside the short battery life.
Again I would like to raise the idea of regional differences in the product line. Wasn't there talk of some units being produced in Japan as well as China?
LastOne2100
Member
My two launch DS4s are still going strong - except that both of them have sticky shoulder buttons.
That said, I am pretty gentle with them and don't use them that heavily.
The Wii U Gamepad is definitely a hell of a lot worse for me.
That said, I am pretty gentle with them and don't use them that heavily.
The Wii U Gamepad is definitely a hell of a lot worse for me.
None of the games on the GamePad necessarily require precision in responsiveness. There are (from what I can tell) 3 zones of usage, and it works the same in every game. DS4 may have more responsiveness, but I'd take sticks that don't break and get loose versus that.
But it's really preference. Sony's controllers are cheaply put together and don't last.
th4tguy
Member
Take a number 2 pencil and scratch a line at the part of the trigger that lines up against the bottom of the controller while unpressed. Do this then flex the trigger a few times. Repeat these steps once or twice more and youre good. I did this about a year ago and haven't had any more issues.
TheInternetNomad
Member
I take good care of my shit and never had an issue with any controllers, hell my original snes controllers are still in great shape... but both my launch ds4's are losing the rubber on the sticks.