• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Factor 5 Animator Claims Studio is Cutting Projects, Needs Funding

dionysus

Yaldog
Mifune said:
Midway layoffs, EA layoffs, and now Factor 5 likely going belly up, and you think this has little to do with the economy.

The whole idea of gaming being recession proof is unfortunately a myth. Maybe sales will still be okay but developers will be hit hard. The gaming industry as we know it has not seen a recession like this before.

Stop thinking the entire economy will go to shit and games will continue to chug along like nothing happened. It's an incredibly naive view.

EA wasn't making money when the economy was booming, same with midway. And F5 produced a crappy game. The economy of course has an effect on these studios. But in F5s case and the other examples you listed, it was not the driving cause for what happened.
 

Mifune

Mehmber
dionysus said:
EA wasn't making money when the economy was booming, same with midway. And F5 produced a crappy game. The economy of course has an effect on these studios. But in F5s case and the other examples you listed, it was not the driving cause for what happened.

If the economy was booming, F5 would not have seen MULTIPLE projects get scrapped. You're right about independent developers, though. They're the most in trouble because of the economy, unless they hook up with one of the big three.
 
Brashnir said:
This is good news for the industry. Developers putting huge budgets into shitty projects deserve to fail. The only way the industry will be averted from this terrible business model is to have bad ideas punished.

It's unfortunate for the guys in the trenches who lose their jobs for these kinds of bad decisions, but it's healthy for the industry.
. . . But than doesn't this also mean we will get lots of clones and "safe bets" in place of creative games that could have gotten some backing had things not been soo effed up? (because it seems like the game industry loves going "me too!" when it comes to money)

Thats has seemed to be a problem this gen on the HD consoles atleast. People go for the "safe bet" because something unproven might end up hurting alot more now than it would have in the past.
 
Mifune said:
Midway layoffs, EA layoffs, and now Factor 5 likely going belly up, and you think this has little to do with the economy.

The whole idea of gaming being recession proof is unfortunately a myth. Maybe sales will still be okay but developers will be hit hard. The gaming industry as we know it has not seen a recession like this before.

Stop thinking the entire economy will go to shit and games will continue to chug along like nothing happened. It's an incredibly naive view.

A few problems with your argument, however:

1) Midway hasn't had a profitable quarter in years and has done nothing but lose money continuously since Redstone made his initial investment 10 years ago.

2) EA has layoffs every single year. The layoffs were more pronounced this year due to EA scaling back Pandemic following the Dark Knight disaster.

3) Factor 5 is but one studio that has either struggled or gone under out of dozens during the last few years.
 

Mario

Sidhe / PikPok
dionysus said:
*Sits in his armchair*

I've been thinking about this. I don't think the economy plays that big a role, after all so far gaming has still proven to be immune to recession.

The layoffs, project cancellations, and publisher/studio closures over the past 6 weeks have mainly been recession related via credit and financing issues.

The impact of the things you talk about will be seen in Q1 next year after what will be a decent enough Christmas for the industry in aggregate, but a washout for individual titles and companies.

The traditional retail videogame model is, unfortunately, broken.
 

Mifune

Mehmber
MassiveAttack said:
A few problems with your argument, however:

2) EA has layoffs every single year. The layoffs were more pronounced this year due to EA scaling back Pandemic following the Dark Knight disaster.

Ah so that would account for 40 of the reported 600 give or take layoffs? Yes, there are layoffs every year, but not 6 percent of the workforce.

Anyway, there's no denying that some of these companies were in trouble regardless of the economy. But likewise there shouldn't be any denying that the economy is making that trouble much worse.
 

jessmo24

Banned
NIntendo please BUy them Out! make them a 2nd party! you neeed hard core.... No wait
Yoi dont need hard core companies But yoru fans want them Please have MERCY on the hard core!
 
God speed, gentlemen. While I didn't like many of their games, there's no questioning the effort put into them, and the current situation is a really shitty one to have to try and find work in. Hope everyone lands on their feet.
 

Brashnir

Member
Black-Wind said:
. . . But than doesn't this also mean we will get lots of clones and "safe bets" in place of creative games that could have gotten some backing had things not been soo effed up? (because it seems like the game industry loves going "me too!" when it comes to money)

Thats has seemed to be a problem this gen on the HD consoles atleast. People go for the "safe bet" because something unproven might end up hurting alot more now than it would have in the past.

sure, while we'll see more experimental offerings with lower-budget titles and from platform holders. Even a "safe bet" with a big budget is still a significant risk for a publisher. You shouldn't expect experimental titles with blockbuster budgets - it's just not a viable model.
 

xfactor

Banned
sprocket said:

As Segata Sanshiro said, someone posted the original post on that blog few pages back on this thread, and we see little to no misinterpretation. the fact that he removed the original post on the blog in the first place already mean something.

guy's just whining about the sad state of his company on his blog, a web site stumble across it and published it out, and guy's afraid of getting into trouble from his company so he delete the post and claim everything just got misinterpreted.
 

Zilch

Banned
Is it really hard to read the whole thread? From reading the original blog post, it doesn't seem 1up's summary was that inaccurate (which is why he took down his original post no doubt).
 
xfactor said:
When you troll the wii by calling it GC 1.5, the karma comes and kick you in the ass.
:lol :lol

Wii Karma . . . will it hit IGN's Matt. C too?

Brashnir said:
sure, while we'll see more experimental offerings with lower-budget titles and from platform holders. Even a "safe bet" with a big budget is still a significant risk for a publisher. You shouldn't expect experimental titles with blockbuster budgets - it's just not a viable model.
You are correct.

This is pretty much one of the big reason's I like the Wii. We atleast have a good chance of seeing something creative on the Wii because of the cost + Limitations in power vs the HD twins. (and 09 is shaping up nicely in that regard)

xfactor said:
As Segata Sanshiro said, someone posted the original post on that blog few pages back on this thread, and we see little to no misinterpretation. the fact that he removed the original post on the blog in the first place already mean something.

guy's just whining about the sad state of his company on his blog, a web site stumble across it and published it out, and guy's afraid of getting into trouble from his company so he delete the post and claim everything just got misinterpreted.
This is very correct.

You don't HIDE misinterpreted statements . . . you SHOW why they were misinterpreted. He is simply covering his ass.
 

Fatalah

Member
The local fox5news station here in NYC had a segment tonight on recession-proof industries. They made a whole big stink about videogames being the 4th best industry to work for in a recession.

I was like "what the hell kind of study is this!?"
 

Quazar

Member
chespace said:
Bummer. Good luck to these guys.

What a crappy time to be dealing with this sort of stuff.

Might be confusing you with someone else but don't you have a cousin that works there?
 

bistromathics

facing a bright new dawn
Black-Wind said:
You don't HIDE misinterpreted statements . . . you SHOW why they were misinterpreted. He is simply covering his ass.

You mean like

http://www.1up.com/do/newsStory?cId=3171691

aw9def.jpg


This is turning into a nice little LJ drama >_>
 

SpokkX

Member
MoogPaul said:
I hear in later patches Lair became quite enjoyable?

It is no classic but is an orignal fun actiongame with some oldschool annoying ideas (escort mission, timed mission...) and framerate problems (not THAT bad but it hurts a flying game)

I really liked it, mainly because it felt original and not generic in any way
 

diffusionx

Gold Member
dionysus said:
EA wasn't making money when the economy was booming, same with midway. And F5 produced a crappy game. The economy of course has an effect on these studios. But in F5s case and the other examples you listed, it was not the driving cause for what happened.

I think this has little to do with Lair. It comes down to credit. Companies need funding to get themselves through patches. Factor 5 released a stinker but if they had 3 or 4 solid projects down the pike, it was easy to get funding to get through development before. How else would Midway be hundreds of millions in debt? Credit was everywhere.

Now, its not. Factor 5 needs money but can't get any, because nobody absolutely nobody is giving it out.

This absolutely has everything to do with the economy, 100%, everything to do with the "credit crunch" and the stress the financial system is under, it shows how embedded credit is to American-style capitalism.
 

ram

Member
jmonteiro said:
Correct, I'm pretty sure Eggebrecht is to blame on that stupid decision (motion controls only). I believe he even admitted to it in some interview. The worst is that even after reviews destroyed the controls he took too long to admit he was wrong and patch the damn game.

that post is quite stupid in many ways.

first - LAIRS main problems were never the motion controls - it was the whole combat mechanic, lack of good targeting, bad mission design (mission start, cutscene, flying, cutscene, flying, cutscene, gameplay) and the bad framerate which are to be blamed.

and btw. LAIR was wholly founded by SCEA. factor 5 was rumored to be working with brash on some superman game and since brash is dead for a couple of month, the game must be halted.

but i wonder, why they never did some psn game. their relationship with sony wasnt bad afterall.
 
Shiggy said:
I hope that Kid Icarus will not be cancelled and that their will be a happy ending for all the employees.
If it means their horrible vision of the next Man Icarus game gets canned then I’m all for it. >_>

Seriously reading about people losing jobs is sadening no matter what.
 

Totobeni

An blind dancing ho
zoukka said:
suxaxis killed Factor 5

:lol yeah like the game was any good with analog stick update , it is still pure shit .

and Sony fully funded that stupid project ( the budget , how much it was ? $20 million ? ) Factor-5 wasted that with crappy game design and broken gameplay .
 

mr jones

Ethnicity is not a race!
Is Lair REALLY that bad? I mean, has anyone here actually played it after the update?

I want to try it, but I can't even find anywhere that rents the damn game. The pictures of it were pretty, and I mean damn! You're flying a dragon! That has to be at least SOMEWHAT fun...
 

kamikaze

Member
so why are there still employees at developers/publishers that think a blog post that mentions his/her company by name won't eventually get picked up by a gaming news site? no employer will ever react positively to an employee talking specifically about work.

people, if you need to vent online, make sure you change the company's name! :D
 

Amir0x

Banned
Well I don't like Factor 5 games at all, but IF it is true I wish the best for all its employees. Shit is hard right now, and it's near Christmas so I know it has to be amplified for individuals facing unemployment.

xfactor said:
When you troll the wii by calling it GC 1.5, the karma comes and kick you in the ass.

When asked to describe the power of the Wii, he correctly called it a GC 1.5. In his context, being someone intimately familiar with the Gamecube's architecture, this is trolling?

It has BECOME a troll for forum members, but he was correct in the original context it was being used. You can't fault him for being accurate.
 
Amir0x said:
Well I don't like Factor 5 games at all, but IF it is true I wish the best for all its employees. Shit is hard right now, and it's near Christmas so I know it has to be amplified for individuals facing unemployment.



When asked to describe the power of the Wii, he correctly called it a GC 1.5. In his context, being someone intimately familiar with the Gamecube's architecture, this is trolling?

It has BECOME a troll for forum members, but he was correct in the original context it was being used. You can't fault him for being accurate.

I agree. Hell, the funny thing is that if F5 did make a Wii game, it has the POSSIBILITIES of looking more like 2 Gamecubes. Well, we might never know now.
 

markatisu

Member
Amir0x said:
It has BECOME a troll for forum members, but he was correct in the original context it was being used. You can't fault him for being accurate.

I do not know why people take offense to the GC 1.5, we all know its between 1.5-2x the Gamecube in power.

What I find offensive is the fact that most developers are not even producing Gamecube 1.0 powered graphics for the Wii.

If its even just a little more powerful why are we not getting more games that resemble RE4 and Metroid Prime, and instead getting games that crap out trying to resemble Sega Bass Fishing
 

Amir0x

Banned
markatisu said:
I do not know why people take offense to the GC 1.5, we all know its between 1.5-2x the Gamecube in power.

What I find offensive is the fact that most developers are not even producing Gamecube 1.0 powered graphics for the Wii.

If its even just a little more powerful why are we not getting more games that resemble RE4 and Metroid Prime, and instead getting games that crap out trying to resemble Sega Bass Fishing

Well game's of RE4 and Metroid Prime's visual prowess were extremely rare during the GCN/PS2/Xbox generation, so even with Wii's slight extra power it would still remain a somewhat rare occasion.
 

Mario

Sidhe / PikPok
markatisu said:
What I find offensive is the fact that most developers are not even producing Gamecube 1.0 powered graphics for the Wii.

A lot of developers aren't being given the budgets to make that happen.
 

bistromathics

facing a bright new dawn
Thomper said:
They didn't? It's still working for me.

Wow you're right. They totally did take it down last night though. Removed from the news page and everything.

aw9def.jpg


Guess it was maybe a case of 'lets double check and make sure we really didn't fuck up'. I was looking forward to some edrama ;_;
 

DuckRacer

Member
mr jones said:
Is Lair REALLY that bad? I mean, has anyone here actually played it after the update?

I want to try it, but I can't even find anywhere that rents the damn game. The pictures of it were pretty, and I mean damn! You're flying a dragon! That has to be at least SOMEWHAT fun...
I haven't played the full game, but I have played the demo on the hong kong store (which has the analog patch.) The controls are a little sluggish (and lock-on isn't all that great), the graphics range from pretty to "oh my god did someone cover the screen with their diarrhea," the framerate is absolutely terrible, which is damning especially for a flight game, the camera can be frustrating, the way objectives/missions/whatever progress is annoying, etc.

It's just a crappy game, and this is coming from a huge Rogue Squadron fan. Everything just feels frustrating... it's like I'm playing an unfinished, unpolished N64 game from 1998.

To be fair, the soundtrack is really good, but that's it.
 
Top Bottom