I'm not 100% on what the so-called controversial moment near the end of the game is, but have a strong idea.
As I was playing it, and came to the 2D Zeus boss fight, I thought, maybe this is it. Felt like some straight up classic SF or Mortal Kombat shit.
Then you have a first-person combat segment against Zeus, which also felt unorthodox. Maybe it was the internalized non-combat "Fear" segment with Kratos running around in the dark.
But then we got that insane ending to the confrontation with Zeus. Where every player would come to the realization at a different moment that they could keep pummelling the fucking shit out of him, and toy with him, or stop at any time. Out of everyone I talked to, everyone figured that out at a different instant. I mean, it's a small, minor gameplay freedom, but it's a moment that seemed to resonate with everyone I know who's completed the game. You get free reign to ravage a god's lifeless body, and you can't even see it because your vision is completely splattered with blood. That's Kratos' last violent act against another. He's literally blinded by blood. It's insane, brutal, self-reflexive, fun, liberating and so very dark.
So yeah, my vote is for that moment being the foreshadowed controversial apex of the game. :lol
I definitely felt like the game was too short upon completing it. My chief complaints were that the Labyrinth sequence (once you got out on top of the blocks and were forced to make some terribly angled jumps with R1) was awful and dragged on too long, and that the Titans were woefully under-used throughout the game, with at least one more major encounter involving them remedying the situation significantly.
Other than that, just plain WOW. I can't decide what my eyes want for dinner instead, other than Uncharted 2. Just plain gorgeous.
As my first completed God of War game, I can say that it was a complete pleasure to play as the conquering villain (in a sense). To cause so much chaos was totally exhilarating. :lol
Having him become the tool that essentially frees the world of Titans and Gods and restores Hope to the people was kind of a Disney Magic moment. Beautiful, but somewhat out of place.
Question regarding Hercules:
It was amazing to see him voiced by Kevin Sorbo. What a hilarious and perfect surprise. Was the character in previous God of War games?