Wow reviews were really off on this one. Just got done watching it, Id put it up there in top 3 (maybe 5) comic book movies. Yes, there were times where the upper lip looked a bit off on supes, but if I wasnt aware of moustache-Gate, I wouldnt have known.
Really, really enjoyed it! Perfect cast, good story, good scenes, Good humor. I really dont have any negatives aside from some effects that did look a bit off.
Edit: and for that horrible gif of cyborg, that does not represent what it looks like. His CGI was really good, that gif is missing some serious frames.