I blame a lot of this on the NFS license. I honestly don't give a shit about having licensed vehicles or not, or what their features are. I'm completely fine with having generic cars with stats represented by a few bars.
Burnout Paradise is still my favorite racing game this gen, and it makes me sad to see Criterion fail to live up to its potential on their follow up releases.
I'm with you, but I will say you and I are a rare breed. People like seeing cars they recognize down to the detail in racing games, the same way they like to see real-world weapons in their first-person shooter.
Considering Burnout Paradise barely made a dime, it will be a long time before Criterion get another crack at making a big, main-line Burnout game. It's my favorite racing game of this generation too.
The cynic in me thinks making Criterion work on NFS titles, a franchise that typically sells well, is their way of making Criterion pay them back for all the free DLC they let them put out for Burnout Paradise.
Still, Hot Pursuit was awesome, and Criterion + Police Chases is a hard formula to screw up. Looks like it's time to buy a Need for Speed game again.