Support NeoGAF

[The Karasumori]

Well then, Fallout 3 better prepare an acceptance speech.

 

[Elwood Blues]

What we really need is a vote for the most overrated game of the generation so I can vote for Red Dead and the Uncharteds.

 

[boingball]

RDR, UC 2, TLoU or GTA V would be contenders for me. Don't know which order I give them though.

 

[tino]

1 The Last of Us
2 Uncharted 2
3 Assasan's Creed 2 and Brotherhood
4 Burnout Paradise
5 GTAV
6 Mass Effect 2
7 Oblivion
8 COD4 MW
9 Dragon Age Origins
Heavy rain
fuck it I am replacing my last spot
10 Dead Rising
in that order

 

[level44]

What we really need is a vote for the most overrated game of the generation so I can vote for Red Dead and the Uncharteds.

RDR yes. Uncharted no.

 

[Fantasy Final]

Dark Souls

 

[Nozem]

What we really need is a vote for the most overrated game of the generation so I can vote for Red Dead and the Uncharteds.

Breaking news: people have different tastes.

 

[sono]

Op said "So my question is the following: will Neogaf have an official "Game of the Generation" event ?"

My view is I hope so.

That thread would need to define the voting period and ask for e.g top x for each poster (e.g x=5)

 

[CyclopsRock]

What we really need is a vote for the most overrated game of the generation so I can vote for Red Dead and the Uncharteds.

Yes, it's important that we get an opportunity to vocally tell people that their opinions are wrong.

IMO it's a toss up between Civ 5, The Walking Dead and TLOU. The latter two did things really differently and the former probably got the most hours out of me this gen. The next two would be the Portals and L4D.

 

[beast786]

Uncharted 2
just cause
God of war 3
LBP2
GT
KZ
Witcher 2

 

[Hypron]

Op said "So my question is the following: will Neogaf have an official "Game of the Generation" event ?"

My view is I hope so.

That thread would need to define the voting period and ask for e.g top x for each poster (e.g x=5)

We probably need to wait a few more months/a year for that, there are still contenders that will come out next year (Dark Souls 2 for example).

 

[Ventilaator]

Op said "So my question is the following: will Neogaf have an official "Game of the Generation" event ?"

Seriously. I saw this thread and the amount of posts it had and figured that the topic wasn't "Should we do this?" anymore and this was actually organized and happening.

Nope, it's just people randomly listing off games for no reason.

 

[BPoole]

Dark Souls

 

[Tagg9]

How is Dark Souls so popular and yet only sold ~1 million outside of Japan?

 

[H_Prestige]

How is Dark Souls so popular and yet only sold ~1 million outside of Japan?

Same reason call of duty isn't winning.

 

[EliCash]

Toss up between Bioshock, Bioshock Infinite and Mass Effect for me. Red Dead Redemption was great too.

Also yet to play The Last of Us, MGS 4 or any of the Mario Galaxys though, and I'd probably enjoy them quite a bit.

 

[Fright Zone]

The games that I have enjoyed most this generation are:

Street Fighter IV (and iterations)
Fallout 3
Assassin's Creed II

 

[balgajo]

Mario Galaxy 2
Xenoblade
Skyward Sword
Skyrim

 

[MiamiWesker]

MGS4

 

[The_Lump]

SM Galaxy 2
SM Galaxy 1
Twighlight Princess (it counts)
Portal
Portal 2
Skyward Sword
Journey

(In that order)