I'm proud of you solider.Have you seen Joakim's eyes? They're marble white. Even away from the iris, where eyes tend to get redder or yellower, his are solid white. I'm not pointing out the difference in white balance between his and Geoff's shots but specifically the lack of a gradient in the actual colour of the eye.
Pretty much what you might suspect if someone filmed Joakim in one of those light box thingies NVIDIA was going on about recently and then stuck in some eyeballs, for instance.
So I went a-looking for mistakes and found this:
On the top left you see Joakim's eye looking away from the light, on the bottom left looking more or less at it, on the top right Geoff's looking away, on the bottom right looking at it. Someone's pupil is malfunctioning.
Goodbye TeamReal, I'm defecting!
I can't vote anyway *maniacal lol*
#TeamCG
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Okay, TeamCG. Come own up to your foolishness. #trolljima
- Thread starter MormaPope
- Start date
katsubento
Member
Why not... Team CG.
EatChildren
Currently polling second in Australia's federal election (first in the Gold Coast), this feral may one day be your Bogan King.
Do you think Mogren is crying over how the internet is treating him like a big fat phony?
Do you think AI can even feel?
Do you think AI can even feel?
dummydecoy
Member
Joakim dude is real, but I bet Kojima is scrambling to recreate him in 3D now! LOL
D
Deleted member 13876
Unconfirmed Member
With the advancements Kojima is making, probably.
This shit looks better than any film CG ever? No fucking way. Only way this would be possible is if they went the LA Noire route, and if that is the case it invalidates the question since its capturing video of the persons face. If it is true then its the most impressive graphics shown ever no matter the context of the year. #TeamReal
Tricky I Shadow
Banned
I voted TeamCG because its the more fun, superior team.
Its going to end up being real.
Neuromancer
Member
Question for #TeamReal: if he's just a dude, what's the point of the Fox Engine question and weird look at the end?
EatChildren
Currently polling second in Australia's federal election (first in the Gold Coast), this feral may one day be your Bogan King.
...because the joke was that The Phantom Pain is not a Kojima Productions title, and revealing it running on the Fox Engine implies it is.
No matter what that was the first impression I got, the CG theory came afterwards when someone mentioned it in one of the pre-interview threads. It's not pointless without the CG theory, but it was a pretty simple and silly joke driven interview that's intentions are easily understood.
Until the CG theory....
plutoknight
Member
I can't vote in the poll! 
(I'm TeamCG though. Only because I want to beLIEve)
No lie. The first Phantom Pain trailer is what got me addicted to this site and encouraged me to register. Kojima-powah!
(I'm TeamCG though. Only because I want to beLIEve)No lie. The first Phantom Pain trailer is what got me addicted to this site and encouraged me to register. Kojima-powah!
Neuromancer
Member
Ahh I see.
How would using similar tech to LA Noire invalidate the question? CG is CG.
Arozay
Member
TeamCG is being manipulated by a lack of oxygen to the brain
FlashbladeGAF
Member
Wtf
So advancing la noire like tech to bridge the gap in facial animation no longer counts?
That's what most of teamcg has been speculating; joakim a real life person being used as a model for cg.
Team real member starting to back pedal?
Phonomezer
Banned
I can already hear the collective, deep inhale by #TeamReal as they prepare to take #TeamCG inside them.
From the looks of it I think TeamReal are already collecting the pitchforks to kick the TeamCG freaks out.
Basically round 2 of Fox Engine vs Reality
http://gematsu.com/2012/03/kojima-productions-fox-engine-vs-reality
http://gematsu.com/2012/03/kojima-productions-fox-engine-vs-reality
So you're saying that the two teams are going to end up making sweet love to each other?
But will it be real love or CG?
Stillmatic
Member
On the subject of lighting...
If you think this lighting matches up, then they're in the same room.
If not, then they've deceived us at least once, and their house of cards will fall!!
Joakeighley: (didn't alter color/contrast levels at all)
Bonus avatar for playing: (altered contrast)
If you think this lighting matches up, then they're in the same room.
If not, then they've deceived us at least once, and their house of cards will fall!!
Joakeighley: (didn't alter color/contrast levels at all)
Bonus avatar for playing: (altered contrast)
No, bloom is so last gen.
Have you seen Joakim's eyes? They're marble white. Even away from the iris, where eyes tend to get redder or yellower, his are solid white. I'm not pointing out the difference in white balance between his and Geoff's shots but specifically the lack of a gradient in the actual colour of the eye.
Pretty much what you might suspect if someone filmed Joakim in one of those light box thingies NVIDIA was going on about recently and then stuck in some eyeballs, for instance.
So I went a-looking for mistakes and found this:
On the top left you see Joakim's eye looking away from the light, on the bottom left looking more or less at it, on the top right Geoff's looking away, on the bottom right looking at it. Someone's pupil is malfunctioning.
Goodbye TeamReal, I'm defecting!
I can't vote anyway *maniacal lol*
#TeamCG
So now this thread has literally Huelen'd itself.
This thread is an object lesson in overthinking something.
Jake Tower
Banned
moniker
Member
Too bad for them. Kojima is destroying their efforts with a game engine.
StevePharma
Member
I'm on that CG-Boat baby. I don't care about rationalization, I do that enough in my daily life
NeoGAF = BELIEVE.
Usually Jeff is standing next to a guy when interviewing on GTTV. The fact that he didn't now is both a great publicity stunt and 100% fact that this is CG ;P
NeoGAF = BELIEVE.
Usually Jeff is standing next to a guy when interviewing on GTTV. The fact that he didn't now is both a great publicity stunt and 100% fact that this is CG ;P
Always-honest
Banned
Ehh.. That was a joke.... Djeezus christ.
Quite an obvious one.
Anyway:
The "i want to believe" people are not really making a choice on what they think but on what they hope. We all hope cg like this is possible. But saying it IS cg because you HOPE almost sounds scary. Like religion.
Also, this is not a team effort. It's a personal choice. There is no "team" in "i".
SCREW LOGIC AND BASIC COMMON SENSE.
toddhunter
Member
Obviously. I was suggesting the people likening posts about this to things like a scary religion are in fact not all joking.
Always-honest
Banned
Well that part is true.
;p
HolyBaikal
Banned
Well obviously it is CG because Fox Engine and Joakim are running on GW.
How is there such a lack of GW jokes in the thread?
FlutterPuffs
Member
I find it funny that some of Team Real are the ones that act like this thread is a big deal.
TEAM CG MOTHERFUCKERS.
Always-honest
Banned
Can you please tell what part you think is CG? Thanx.
woodsey1982
Member
#TeamCG
I want to believe!!
I want to believe!!
Always-honest
Banned
Your eyes?
Noisepurge
Member
On the top left you see Joakim's eye looking away from the light, on the bottom left looking more or less at it, on the top right Geoff's looking away, on the bottom right looking at it. Someone's pupil is malfunctioning.
Joakim is just stoned.
Can't believe you guys are even discussing this. The dude in the interview being interviewed, is obviously the same dude as the interviewer. They have only photoshoped it to look like to different people. The dude in the phantom pain trailer is CG and look different and clearly is computer graphics.
Conclution: Both interviewer and person being interviewed is real people, and the same dude.
Conclution: Both interviewer and person being interviewed is real people, and the same dude.