-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Overwatch Mafia |OT| Keep Your Vote On The Payload
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
heya peeps, im out for most of today so i cant talk as much as i would like, here is all i can say before in out the door.
yeah, mazre i did personally scumread mazre and wanted to tentatively push for his lynch (legit surprised it worked), barry i more saw others going in pretty hard on him and didnt have any objection to his lynch.
would you say Fran is the one looking shifty?????..??.??
y'know, cuz hes a switcher, he shifts things aro- ah forget it.
if we are going to lynch one in this list, my vote (which i will actually place when i get home tonight) would be on Xam, my scum read of him shot way the hell up with ty4ons vehement defense of him.
yeah, mazre i did personally scumread mazre and wanted to tentatively push for his lynch (legit surprised it worked), barry i more saw others going in pretty hard on him and didnt have any objection to his lynch.
would you say Fran is the one looking shifty?????..??.??
y'know, cuz hes a switcher, he shifts things aro- ah forget it.
if we are going to lynch one in this list, my vote (which i will actually place when i get home tonight) would be on Xam, my scum read of him shot way the hell up with ty4ons vehement defense of him.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
looking at the terrible joke i realise i should clarify, i actually townread fran, i would not want him lynched today.
melonrabbit
Member
Perhaps this is a form of surrender.
From Blarg too? He didn't even try.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
wow, nothing?
slow day i guess.
vote: Xamtheking
slow day i guess.
vote: Xamtheking
Oh Xam.
*Rubs bellies*
I would rather gor for barry. He was on several scum lists, stopped posting all together. Yet here we are :/
Bit of a frustrating situation there since he's been subbed. Do we let Blarg have a grace period?
We've given him a ~40 hour grace period already...
Xamtheking
Member
This could totally just be a long con from Blarg
I would not put it past him
I would not put it past him
melonrabbit
Member
OK. I'm up.
Catching up. Oh, wait fuck all has happened with Blarg and Cherry.
And Xam and Bronx have only shown up to cast shade on those 2.
If we don't go inactive. We should go Ty.
Catching up. Oh, wait fuck all has happened with Blarg and Cherry.
And Xam and Bronx have only shown up to cast shade on those 2.
If we don't go inactive. We should go Ty.
Ty4on.
What's the rule about inactivity at this stage of the game? Do we get replacements this late?
melonrabbit
Member
Of our remaining unconfirmed (via AB's list) We have:
Town
Kingkitty
Stan
Scum
Ty
Fran
Xam
Unsure
Bronx
Cherry
Blarg
...is Blarg and either A) up to something with this silence or B) sincerely doesn't know he subbed in. Maybe a power play or a stipulation of his PM (similar to Splinter). Those familiar with OW lore does this fit?
I kinda think at least one of our inactives is another neutral.
Town
Kingkitty
Stan
Scum
Ty
Fran
Xam
Unsure
Bronx
Cherry
Blarg
...is Blarg and either A) up to something with this silence or B) sincerely doesn't know he subbed in. Maybe a power play or a stipulation of his PM (similar to Splinter). Those familiar with OW lore does this fit?
I kinda think at least one of our inactives is another neutral.
Bullshit. If I was this inactive, my ass would've been already lynched. Wanna know how? CAUSE YOU FUCKS ALREADY DID IT TO ME IN POKEMON MAFIA.
But nah, Cherry & Blarg get the benefit of the doubt for....some reason.
Did you just scum read a confirmed townie?
I agree with your point though. There's no reason we should give Cherry or Blarg a pass for being inactive. Their actions in the past (or, Barry's actions in Blarg's case) were still scummy.
What everyone think about this regarding AB role:
AB post his 3 more likely mafia before deadline. At the night phase he hides behind one of them. If he is still alive we have another possible townie. If he dies we know that one of the 3 is scum and we confirm splinter and melon. Giving 3 possibilities gives scum 33% chances to hit AB which isn't so bad. I will not switch any of the people AB post and if you still don't trust me I still have only a 33% change to select AB's target for the switch. It's a more aggressive way instead of the defensive one that was said yesterday and either way it give us some kind of read.
AB post his 3 more likely mafia before deadline. At the night phase he hides behind one of them. If he is still alive we have another possible townie. If he dies we know that one of the 3 is scum and we confirm splinter and melon. Giving 3 possibilities gives scum 33% chances to hit AB which isn't so bad. I will not switch any of the people AB post and if you still don't trust me I still have only a 33% change to select AB's target for the switch. It's a more aggressive way instead of the defensive one that was said yesterday and either way it give us some kind of read.
A. I wasn't in that game.
B. Making a mistake in one game and repeating it in the next doesn't seem like a particularly sound strategy.
C. Lynching for inactivity day 1 is different from lynching for inactivity day 4.
what does your belly feel about Bronx-Man?
Not reading scum just now. Though by no means a sure read.
AbsolutBro
Member
It's not a bad plan. Though I prefer mine still since it confirms two players instead of just one. It also assuages that nagging little voice that says "what if nin and cabot are lying?"
I think Eze's kill confirms to me that nin isn't scum. I still think he may be a neutral SK, and if there are 2 NK we should lynch him to be sure, but if he really is we won't know that way. Why go for someone who you read town when we can go for our scum reads? It's an attacking way of playing instead to keeping it defensive.
Not so sure about AB telegraphing his play.
Nin/Cabot seem pretty solid for now, the plan doesn't stand to gain us much and offers scum a pretty decent chance at a double-kill.
Choosing 3 targets beforehand - if AB + one of his targets die in the night we won't know if he was doubled on town or he hid behind scum and scum killed one of the town. Additionally if there is a scum in the group of 3 AB selects scum has a better than 50% chance of landing a double kill (they know they don't need to target the scum player if there's one in the trio.
Nin/Cabot seem pretty solid for now, the plan doesn't stand to gain us much and offers scum a pretty decent chance at a double-kill.
Choosing 3 targets beforehand - if AB + one of his targets die in the night we won't know if he was doubled on town or he hid behind scum and scum killed one of the town. Additionally if there is a scum in the group of 3 AB selects scum has a better than 50% chance of landing a double kill (they know they don't need to target the scum player if there's one in the trio.
You're still suspicious of me aren't you
I didn't thinked of the first possibility. The second I was ok. 50% chance of getting hit was what we had with the previous plan.
I think we should think of a way to gain something from this.
We're ahead, why should we take a risk like that? If Nin really is a serial killer and AB dies tonight we could have 3 kills forcing lylo after just two mislynches (assuming two scum if Nin is sk).
Gotta fix this nasty post.
I remember the discussion on how to get info from a weak doctor dying really not getting anywhere apart from megastacks. We could maybe do something similar with Splinter protecting AB's target.
It was the weak doctor, not the naive.
I remember the discussion on how to get info from a weak doctor dying really not getting anywhere apart from megastacks. We could maybe do something similar with Splinter protecting AB's target.
I like the idea of AB naming his top 3 or 4 targets.
If scum want to kill our most suspicious players for us then I'm all for it.
The other plan confirms two players that aren't worth confirming. Nin killed scum. Cabot is confirmed by nin.
Cabot is clearly town anyway. I didn't need a cop check to tell me that.
If scum want to kill our most suspicious players for us then I'm all for it.
The other plan confirms two players that aren't worth confirming. Nin killed scum. Cabot is confirmed by nin.
Cabot is clearly town anyway. I didn't need a cop check to tell me that.
...in this case really simple roles that they can't use...
You gonna at least try giving some type of reason for this vote?
You seem to be coasting all game, actively avoiding taking strong positions, participating in few conversations, posting regularly with nothing to say.