Reluctant-Hero
Member
Well, that certainly clears things up. /Thread, right?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Persona 4 Golden review thread: The Highest Reviewed Game of All Time and The Future?
- Thread starter Curufinwe
- Start date
Well, that certainly clears things up. /Thread, right?
Dr.Palutena
Member
I see a 9 and an 8.5 there! Totally not a fanboy!
He didn't review Innocent Sin? No wonder Eternal Punishment is Japan-only.
Thread will be updated as new reviews hit, even if Tom Chick gives it 1/5 it will be included.
zerokoolpsx
Member
Dale North is somewhat biased lol. Need more reviews though from other reviewers.
FantasticMrFoxdie
Mumber
Should have known. Destructoid's integrity is about as empty as this bag of Doritos.
we.are.the.armada
Member
Game of the infinity.
I hope you guys like the color yellow.
I hope you guys like the color yellow.
LMAO, exactly what I thought.
Supermanisdead
Member
Fanboy or not, those are accurate scores. Persona is god.
I dont get it, when there are reviewers giving low scores to games, people bitch that the reviewer doesn't know the game or really just doesnt like the game. Now the complete opposite happened that a reviewer really loves the series gives the game a high score and people are still bitching? ok...
zerokoolpsx
Member
JeTmAn81
Member
That too. Turn-based RPG's work really well in a touchscreen-only environment. I can't wait for more high-profile titles to start turning up on smartphone OS's. I bought GTA III for a dollar on Android the other day.
haha, yeah. GAF seems to hate reviews in general, so they must be bitched about no matter what. Personally, I'd prefer reviews from fans of the series the game belongs to.
Dr.Palutena
Member
Bitching? I think both just creates the same skepticism.In this case, I think any skepticism is grown from the title of this thread as much as the reviewer right now.
And lots of new voice acting, completely reworked shuffle system, new personae and abilities for every char, combat changes, changes to the fusion system, etc. it's a monstrous update
aliencowz7
Member
That already puts it at the top of RPGs released this year as well as a better overall package and value then the vast majority of other games released in 2012. A 10/10 with small stuff added and nothing detracted is still a 10/10.
Started playing review code last Tuesday and I'm only 20 hours in (just got to
dungeon). Aside from the new S-links I suppose most of the new content is backloaded because it feels mostly the same so far.
Which is to say amazing if you loved Persona 4 as much as I did. The visuals really pop on Vita.
Rise's
Which is to say amazing if you loved Persona 4 as much as I did. The visuals really pop on Vita.
How big is the game? Would it fit on a 4 GB memory card?
we.are.the.armada
Member
Sounds perfect already! Oh and you're wrong, there's a lot more to it, but I can see how downplaying the game works to your agenda of hoping the worst for Atlus.
Haha!
buddha0991
Member
well, he has a good reason to be angered at atlus...
It's hardly a secret. I've said it constantly.
I'm still right about The Golden though. I've been saying those things since June. Arena wasn't out then.
If you convince yourself that it's a lot more than that, you're just setting yourself of a fall.
You're damn right it does!
Away from my vita at the moment but something like 3.5 or 3.8 gigs. Should be fine with a 4g card.
cj_iwakura
Member
I'd play the broken record and reiterate that I'd vastly prefer Eternal Punishment(which is also the better game), but reviewers hated Innocent Sin, so I'm sure they're ecstatic.
-Stranger-
Junior Member
For the first time i actually want a Vita...
Any owners out there, are they worth it at this point?
Persona 4 is one of my fav games of all time.
Any owners out there, are they worth it at this point?
Persona 4 is one of my fav games of all time.
buddha0991
Member
Objectivity is a thing. I loved Persona 4, but it was by no means perfect. It has various plot problems, and if you look up what Persona 4 might have originally been, it is actually kind of disappointing how it turned out, despite it being one of my favorite games...
Also, not to throw a wrench into "perfection", but.....New Chie voice, hah.
Also, not to throw a wrench into "perfection", but.....New Chie voice, hah.
What was Persona 4 supposed to be originally?
I'm more partial to orange, but yellow is fine. :3
Thanks. It would be nice if it fit on the 4 GB card that comes with AC Liberation Vita bundle. That way I could get the digital version of P4G and delay buying a 32 GB memory card till sometime next year.
buddha0991
Member
All the people quick to bash Dantis forget he has had the game for months now.
Errr no. It's not a completely different game, but you're not "right" for having a dissenting opinion. I've played through the Japanese release as well and am mid way through a second play through and there is lots to love about Golden.
I'm sorry that the changes hurt your purist sensibilities.
cj_iwakura
Member
Yes, they changed the gameplay a lot, and most of the updates make the easiest Persona even easier. Goody. The game will be broken city.
At least Eternal Punishment's update added to the story.
I'm actually not certain you'd be able to fit the game on the memory card. All memory cards use a bit of space for whatever reason, so the entire 4GB isn't user accessible.
Then he should play it. There's a lot more new than two social links.
BlazingDarkness
Member
Birthday Present
Yeah, but only if you like playing games. If you like reading about them and predicting the future and so forth then no, probably not worth it
we.are.the.armada
Member
Thomas Haliburton once said, "When a man is wrong and won't admit he is, he always gets angry."
Dantis, the game has plenty of extra content, and you're just as wrong about it today as you were then. Furthermore, if you project your problem onto Persona 4 Golden and hope that it bombs, how does that help you? Such bitterness should be beneath us.