I just need Wolf and Ice Climbers for everything to feel "complete." I don't know why but I have a need for that kind of, I guess, closure. Ivysaur and Squirtle would be amazing too, but on the same token I think a fully evolved Grass starter with more staying power (in terms of probably not ever being cut) would be amazing to fill this odd hole that Pokémon representation has at the moment.
But Smash 4 was good to me in terms of newcomers. Almost ridiculously so.
Villager: I am a HUGE Animal Crossing fan, so imagine my dismay when, after Brawl, Sakurai stated that a Villager character would be out of place in Smash. I always thought this was a silly thing to say when you have all manner of cartoon characters bonking each other, and the spirit of Smash isn't should you fight, it's can you fight. Then, Villager is the first newcomer announced for Smash 4! Needless to say I lost all my shit when the camera panned down to an AC village.
Rosalina: Super Mario Galaxy 1 is my favorite Mario title of all time. Aside from it being objectively great, I have a lot of nostalgia for the music and the hub world. Rosalina is also an amazing character in every sense. I knew she'd been making more game appearances, but I never dreamed she'd make it into Smash. Of course, my "aha" moment in the trailer was when the launch star appeared. I think her reveal is one of my favorites (plus it happened around Christmas time so it felt extra festive).
Greninja: Huge Pokémon fan, so I was happy to see a gen 6 Pokémon at all. In my perfect world, Sakurai would have selected Chesnaught to be the gen 6 rep (I still weep at the idea of what might have been), but Greninja is cool too and I feel he's secured his spot forever.
Robin: I got back into FE with Awakening, so I was hoping we'd get a rep from this game. I was resigned to it being Chrom, though I really wanted Robin. Even on my little fan made roster, I had Robin with gender swaps, though I didn't think it would actually happen. Then the fuckin trailer came (also at a time when Gematsu was gospel) and I don't think I've ever had such a loud reaction to a game trailer. Such a reversal of expectations.
Palutena: Uprising is currently among my games of the generation, so I was obviously excited about the inclusion of the Goddess of Light. While it's kind of a bummer that the VA couldn't do her in Smash, I think her replacement did a decent job. But I can still sense that they made her speak less in battle because of how jarring it might have been to hear a new VA, which is a shame because I would love a Palutena in Smash with more sass. Also kinda disappointing is her situation with special moves, but it is cool that they all come from Uprising miracles.
Pac-Man: Pac-Man has a special place in my heart, being one of a couple games my grandfather would play with me when I was growing up. I was interested at the prospect of him joining in since Namco was helping with development. The crowd reaction at the roundtable when he was revealed at E3 2014 was crazy and put a huge smile on my face. He turned out even better than I imagined, and I hope he's here to stay.
Bowser Jr.: This was a character I didn't even know I wanted. I wasn't opposed to him joining in, I just wasn't hyped about a paintbrush moveset or a tiny Bowser clone. But once again, Sakurai showed me that he can spin moveset gold from straw. The Koopalings are an amazing touch as well. It was a huge surprise and a pleasant one.
Corrin: I know some were probably upset about this inclusion, but it's easily my most hyped out of all the DLC newcomers. The third parties are cool and amazing and I'm happy for the fans, but I was really lamenting the fact that the cool protagonist from Fates would certainly miss the Smash boat, being too old by the time the next title comes around. But Sakurai apparently likes the character as much as I do! Corrin and Robin will definitely compete for my most played FE character.
Basically, I love Smash 4, and the roster is immaculate. I have three newcomers I'm rooting hard for (Chorus Kids, Inkling, and fully evolved Grass Pokémon starter), but honestly if I could just get my vets back the current roster would be the GOAT for me. Even without them, it still kind of is.
Thank you Sakurai, so very much.