You raise fair points, ones i'd love to discuss further, when i'm not about to go to bed. I may check back in tomorrow.
I wasn't on the E3 section. I personally still think E3 is really special, but I also know what it's like to sort of be jaded by it after now having been to 13 of them, especially if you're on the inside where you get to see most of the games prior to the show. Also more discussion for later.
And I'm not saying it just has to blow you away presentation wise / spectacle. Certainly Halo 4 and AC3 blew me away from a graphics / spectacle / story perspective. I think you pointing out gameplay is the exact reason why some of those massively marketed games this year sort of fell just short of the expectations, because they perhaps didn't surprise or delight us the way Dishonored or Fez or Journey or Walking Dead did.
That said, any time you discuss expectations vs. how it turned out / surprise vs. disappointment, etc... you inevitably MUST discuss hype, as that's where the expectations come from. If there's no hype (or expectation), you can't be disappointed.
anyways, bed for real, I'll try to write more tomorrow.
appreciate you listening and the thoughts though
Fair points, and I'm headed off to bed as well. One closing thought:
Perhaps those games you label as "surprises" would have been more influential in your thought process had they been hyped more. I find that those subtle surprise games tend to hold up better years down the line than the big hyped monoliths -- I think there's something to that. Be wary of hype.