That "box office draw" aspect is unfortunately true, and is a direct consaquence of these casting practices. Who would you say is the most famous Asian actress in Hollywood right now? Hannah Simone? Lucy liu? Maggie Q? Chloe Bennet?
According to google it is Zhang Ziyi Fan Bingbing Gong li Michelle Yeoh and Arden Cho
Insert Guardians of the Galaxy Who.Gif
4/5 of those actresses are over 35 and i had only previously heard of one. Michelle Yeoh.
it sounds like sucks to be an Asian American actor whether you're Eastern Asian, Middle Eastern, brown/South Asian, or Southeast Asian
A bunch of classicaly trained actors doing Blaxpotation movies because we couldn't do anything else basically.
I know I'm merely speaking from personal and anecdotal experience but you're kind of proving my point here.
I don't know what to say when Arden Cho is in a list with gong li and Michelle yeoh.
This isn't thay hard. The "box office draw" will remain true when you typically keep casting white actors in Asian roles or when you cast for Asian stereotypes. What asian actors want are meatier roles. You can't be a box office draw if you're never given the opportunity to be one in the first place.
I just googled "most famous asian actress hollywood" and thats what came up. Lucy Liu didnt make the list. Which is strange since she is currently or was recently working as co lead on CBS' Sherlock and had been an A-List celebrity in the past.
Surprised after all these years Hollywood hasn't asked why people like Han in fast and furious series so much.
Maybe having an Asian dude that is just a dude has some merit?
What? Krysten Ritter isn't attractive?
At least Middle Easterners have a history of getting roles playing Hispanics.
(Filipinos too)
My 8 yr old son is half Chinese. I make sure we watch shows like Fresh of the Boat, Kim's Convience. I want him to be exposed to variety as much as possible. I wish there was more though.
Watch Asian dramas together. You can probably find them subbed on the net.
Yeah, I know there are reasons. Trends are changing too, though mainly because Hollywood is trying to pander to China. Asians are doing best in TV right now, though it's still not great.The Asian American demographic was also easily ignorable for most of TV/Movie history. Asian Americans were 0.75% of the population of the US back in 1970. In 1950 that number was 0.2%. And that was for the entire Asian continent. Once you start subdividing by ethnic origin (Chinese, Indian, Filipino, etc) you were dealing with relatively tiny communities.
We're now about 40 years into mass Asian immigration in the United States. If you figure that immigrants tend to identify with their home country over their adopted country, most of the US born Asian Americans are GAF age or younger. I would imagine that these are the Americans who want to see themselves in the movies and on TV (their parents are happy watching Bollywood or cinema from Hong Kong, Korea, etc). Now is the time to prove to Hollywood that there is a market for those characters and stories. Because, being realistic, white, black and latino moviegoers largely don't care either way about Asian representation unless they are approaching it from a social justice perspective that encourages diversity in general. Those aren't their personal stories.
I do think that things will gradually get better in regards to Asian representation in Hollywood. Especially as American demographics continue to shift. It just takes way too long.
I mean, she's not ugly, but Krysten Ritter isn't exactly a babe, either.
i do feel like it's important both ways though. Like, there should definitely be stories where asian characters can just be... characters who happen to be asian, but (as the recent glut of asian-american comedy/sitcoms seems to tell) it's also important that there be experiences that are uniquely asian, or asian-american (or asian-australian, asian-english, whatever).
Like, the other day I saw a clip from Fresh Off The Boat i think where the kids were marvelling at a dishwasher actually being used to wash dishes because they thought it was effectively an under-the-counter drying rack because their parents had them handwash the dishes even though they owned a dishwasher. That was incredibly relatable and I busted my gut laughing at it because dude, that was me and my little bro.
I would never have seen that kind of thing when I was growing up.
I mean, she's not ugly, but Krysten Ritter isn't exactly a babe, either.
I am not a big fan of the show but LOST was surprisingly progressive on this aspect. Also you guys should watch "Crazy Ex-grilfriend", another show that uses a very attractive Asian lead as the main love interest, which definitely stands against the typical desexualized Asian stereotype.
i do feel like it's important both ways though. Like, there should definitely be stories where asian characters can just be... characters who happen to be asian, but (as the recent glut of asian-american comedy/sitcoms seems to tell) it's also important that there be experiences that are uniquely asian, or asian-american (or asian-australian, asian-english, whatever).
Like, the other day I saw a clip from Fresh Off The Boat i think where the kids were marvelling at a dishwasher actually being used to wash dishes because they thought it was effectively an under-the-counter drying rack because their parents had them handwash the dishes even though they owned a dishwasher. That was incredibly relatable and I busted my gut laughing at it because dude, that was me and my little bro.
I would never have seen that kind of thing when I was growing up.
I mean, she's not ugly, but Krysten Ritter isn't exactly a babe, either.
My 8 yr old son is half Chinese. I make sure we watch shows like Fresh of the Boat, Kim's Convience. I want him to be exposed to variety as much as possible. I wish there was more though.
The Asian American demographic was also easily ignorable for most of TV/Movie history. Asian Americans were 0.75% of the population of the US back in 1970. In 1950 that number was 0.2%. And that was for the entire Asian continent. Once you start subdividing by ethnic origin (Chinese, Indian, Filipino, etc) you were dealing with relatively tiny communities.
We're now about 40 years into mass Asian immigration in the United States. If you figure that immigrants tend to identify with their home country over their adopted country, most of the US born Asian Americans are GAF age or younger. I would imagine that these are the Americans who want to see themselves in the movies and on TV (their parents are happy watching Bollywood or cinema from Hong Kong, Korea, etc). Now is the time to prove to Hollywood that there is a market for those characters and stories. Because, being realistic, white, black and latino moviegoers largely don't care either way about Asian representation unless they are approaching it from a social justice perspective that encourages diversity in general.
I do think that things will gradually get better in regards to Asian representation in Hollywood. Especially as American demographics continue to shift. It just takes way too long.
The actual middle-eastern characters are usually far more offensive than the typical "good stereotype" east Asian characters. Not trying to dismiss the problems in show biz with regards to how east Asians are portrayed, I'm just saying the problems are very different.
Asians need to take tbe black people route and make their own shit. Hollywood won't ever give you the shot you want.
Just like i said before, you think the message of GitS will be white washing? Let WW underperform and it will be "welp women can't carry big budget action movies." That will be the message.
Hollywood only caters to white males. Everyone else will have to force their way in. Black people have opened the door but we still are in the lobby so to speak.
Yeah, I know there are reasons. Trends are changing too, though mainly because Hollywood is trying to pander to China. Asians are doing best in TV right now, though it's still not great.
It's just disheartening when I say Asians don't get much sympathy and then someone tries to shoot that down. You can't hold up blacksploitation films and imply Asians should just do that when the industry is completely different today. Asians still only make up 5-7% of the US population.
Hell, even Israeli actors have to play Arab Islamist terrorists. It's that recurring bullshit with how in every show about the war on terror, every Middle Eastern character is either a terrorist, a secret terrorist for plot twist purposes, or a mole for the terrorists.The actual middle-eastern characters are usually far more offensive than the typical "good stereotype" east Asian characters. Not trying to dismiss the problems in show biz with regards to how east Asians are portrayed, I'm just saying the problems are very different.
I am not a big fan of the show but LOST was surprisingly progressive on this aspect. Also you guys should watch "Crazy Ex-girlfriend", another show that uses a very attractive Asian lead as the main love interest, which definitely stands against the typical desexualized Asian stereotype.
What? Krysten Ritter isn't attractive?
I am not a big fan of the show but LOST was surprisingly progressive on this aspect. Also you guys should watch "Crazy Ex-girlfriend", another show that uses a very attractive Asian lead as the main love interest, which definitely stands against the typical desexualized Asian stereotype.
Hollywood Shuffle still resonates
Edge of Seventeen had that to an extent, what did people think of that film? Hayden Szeto was pretty great.
More of a side note here. Maybe my Canadian Brothers and Sister can chime in.
We are much more exposed to diversity up here. In BC at least you will see lots of diversity in TV Commercials. Interracial couples are quite prominent. It helps with perception and that perception will help with the future generations.
Yet another example of a Black Independent Film funded for $100,000, $60,000 of which was funded from Robert Townsend's own credit cards, and grossing 5 million dollars and proving yet again there's a market for Black films in the 80's.
I think an Asian American could remake Hollywood Shuffle with a Asian American focus and do a very smart yet scathing social commentary on Hollywood right now and be successful.
Great film, I still thought the Asian character was better in some respects, and still a stereotype in others. Dude doesn't even kiss the girl.
Yet another example of a Black Independent Film funded for $100,000, $60,000 of which was funded from Robert Townsend's own credit cards, and grossing 5 million dollars and proving yet again there's a market for Black films in the 80's.
I think an Asian American could remake Hollywood Shuffle with a Asian American focus and do a very smart yet scathing social commentary on Hollywood right now and be successful.
I don't think it's all that much better in Canada. We just happen to have different dominant minority demographics. Vancouver metro, and the GTA are minority-majorities where Chinese, Indian, and other Asian ethnicities make up a big portion of the population. It seems natural that an Indian Canadian would see more representation than an Indian American if you are watching the news or Canadian broadcasting. There are proportionally a lot more Indian Canadians than Indian Americans.
Hispanics should play Hispanics.At least Middle Easterners have a history of getting roles playing Hispanics.
(Filipinos too)
Huh something I never considered was how African-Americans have formed a solid foothold in pop cuture that Asian-Americans haven't quite formed. I hope eventually they can get to that point in movies and television. Master of None was a good step in the right direction and I think Netflix would be a great outlet for such ventures.
I mean, she's not ugly, but Krysten Ritter isn't exactly a babe, either.
Love Crazy Ex-Girlfriend. The Expanse is another show that has a ton of Asian characters who just happen to be Asian.
I mean, she's not ugly, but Krysten Ritter isn't exactly a babe, either.
Hispanics should play Hispanics.
what are some of these roles?
I can only think of one Asian American film like you suggest, Better Luck Tommorow directed by Justin Lin, with Sung Kang and John Cho. I didn't think it was very good but it has a good rotten tomatoes score. Interesting enough, MC Hammer put up some money for it and is credited as a producer.
M Night Shyamalan is already self-funding $5-10M films. There's no reason why he couldn't push for one of the lead roles to be someone who wasn't white. Given how much Split made, he can continue to do what he wants for the foreseeable future.
Well there is a wide disparity in terms of American socio-cultural status between African-Americans and Asian-Americans. Asian-Americans are largely new to the US having a fraction of the shared history that African-Americans who are the descendants of slaves centuries back. Additionally, while there is great diversity within the black community in the US, there is no real 'Asian' united block. Chinese Americans have a different history than Japanese Americans who have a different history than Filipino Americans who have a different history than Indian Americans, and vice versa, yet all are termed as Asian Americans.
Then you have just sheer population. Prior to 1990, the Asian American population was below 3%, it is now over 6% but still is half that of the African-American community. By terms of underrepresentation, latino and hispanics make up almost 20% of the US, meaning 1 in 5, and yet are almost entirely invisible in terms of politics, media, sports, music, culture, arts and television. Things will slowly change, but even then look how many people think Kumail Nanjiani is Indian when in reality he is Pakistani.
It'll change. Rapid demographic change means that by 2030, more than 25% of the US will be either hispanic, south asian or east asian.
Surprisingly Power Rangers was one of the better ones in this regard. Underprivileged Asian families aren't often shown.
One of my favorite things about Rogue One was how diverse the cast was and not in a pandering way at all. Too bad GAF hates that movie so much.
What? Krysten Ritter isn't attractive?
GAF never ceases to amaze