I loved this one of my favorites, i wish you will too.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Manga News/Discussion |OTX| Attack on Titles
- Thread starter dramatis
- Start date
- Status
I loved this one of my favorites, i wish you will too.
hipsterpants
Member
TWGOK 260
wat
just garbage. can we return to comedy-harem hijinks please
wat
just garbage. can we return to comedy-harem hijinks please
cosmicblizzard
Banned
To be fair, Nononono is actually relatively well-researched for someone that knew absolutely nothing about ski jumping. The one thing that he messed up in terms of research had nothing to do with ski jumping.
Hellsing321
Member
dakkumauji
Member
astrogamer
Member
Those eyes. They burn
Hell, Nononono was kinda ok in a dumb sort of way until it... well y'all know what happened. I never touched Elfen Lied manga and the anime... somehow never felt like watching it since the "wrong sort of crowd" usually hyped it (aka teens liking "edgy" stuff").
Even before that, I can remember it went wrong half way through the story where Lynn Okamoto's breast rubbing fetish shone through, THAT moment was still the pinnacle abviously, no one can deny that. The sports part was actually decent for what is was.
OminoMichelin
Member
I REALLY didn't remember elfen lied's art being so bad :/
It was really obvious for people who read the manga after watching the anime.
There's dumb and there's DUMB. Totally different things.
Akito it's been 15 minutes. I um, I gotta give up, but I swear I gave it an honest try. I can't solve this. We still cool though.
imagine if the second dumb was bolded.
Well, one is so bad you want to smash your head against the wall constantly and the other one is actually entertaining, but quite rare. I'll let you figure out which is which.
Lemme, wait, ok. I get what you're saying as a concept. You're saying a couple of things.
1. There's dumb
2. There's another type of dumb
See till here I'm good. I agree with this. Like, intentional and not intentional, or logical and not logical, right? I may not pinpoint exactly which two types you mean, but this should be enough. I can at least think up some possibilities.
3. There's a correlation to quality in the difference between the two types
Here I'm out. I tried any combination of two dumb manga that I know. I always have some more manga that can disprove any correlation. However I cannot give the specific examples without fear for my life.
1. There's dumb
2. There's another type of dumb
See till here I'm good. I agree with this. Like, intentional and not intentional, or logical and not logical, right? I may not pinpoint exactly which two types you mean, but this should be enough. I can at least think up some possibilities.
3. There's a correlation to quality in the difference between the two types
Here I'm out. I tried any combination of two dumb manga that I know. I always have some more manga that can disprove any correlation. However I cannot give the specific examples without fear for my life.
You've grabbed my attention like Elfen Lied, now you need to spill the beans.
Angry Grimace
Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Shokugeki no Soma, Nisekoi and Fairy Tail?
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
The quality of difference is whether which type of dumb is dumb enough to make you laugh and keep on reading.
I think the more apt way to think about it is that there's a difference between "too dumb to enjoy" and "dumb but still enjoyable."
Basically, KNIM and Nisekoi.
I have no idea if this means shots fired
All you guys are saying is that one is more enjoyable than the other which is what I could decipher from the very first post. I'm starting to think you guys are just as clueless as I am
I really can't, but it's something like this
and it involves putting me in danger of very specific peeps here (naming them will be the same as naming the series in question)
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Eh, there are perceptible differences in what is dumb enough for me to enjoy. Ridiculous fanservice, like HSDK, is dumb enough for me to enjoy, and something deathly serious to the point of ridiculousness like Holyland is capable of creating the dumb I enjoy. However, dumb stuff that's just straight up offensive, or just have characters I think are incredibly dumb (like naruto) I would just drop pretty fast.
So basically there's no discernible line aside from subjective opinion about the enjoyability of the thing.
I think that's probably the case since nobody said anything besides the first line there. So you put forth some weird claim that nobody even said about inherent quality.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Well yeah, but isn't everything subjective when it comes to opinion?
Sekai Seifuku Sekirara Jogakkan EX1
just as ponpo got an anime, solune gets a oneshot tucked away at the end of a manga series
just as ponpo got an anime, solune gets a oneshot tucked away at the end of a manga series
It's the difference between Code Geass and Guilty Crown.
Dr.DMAT vol.1-2
This was pretty great. I really don't like blood, medical stuff and all the things like that but I still managed to read it and I'm glad I did. It's neat to have a medical manga where the characters don't stay at the hospital, this way we can get intense scenes in various places. The characters are all enjoyable so far and pretty much every chapter was good. There's some comedy in this, which I didn't expect, but most of the time it's pretty serious and some scenes can be a little tough (like the guy dying right before Hibiki's eyes). It also reminded me of Kokou no Hito because sometimes the authors like to use some visual metaphors which adds another dramatic layer to the situations.
The art is also pretty good. Definitely following this series.
This was pretty great. I really don't like blood, medical stuff and all the things like that but I still managed to read it and I'm glad I did. It's neat to have a medical manga where the characters don't stay at the hospital, this way we can get intense scenes in various places. The characters are all enjoyable so far and pretty much every chapter was good. There's some comedy in this, which I didn't expect, but most of the time it's pretty serious and some scenes can be a little tough (like the guy dying right before Hibiki's eyes). It also reminded me of Kokou no Hito because sometimes the authors like to use some visual metaphors which adds another dramatic layer to the situations.
The art is also pretty good. Definitely following this series.
dakkumauji
Member
well he pretty much already has an anime called Noragami!
Actually, it looks like they are now so nevermind!
Seriously though, that's why I was saying it's just more apt to think of it as the "too bad to enjoy" and "so bad it's good" categories. It's just up to the person on where the line is, not something inherent to the things. I think OPM is pretty dumb but enjoyable, for instance. Same for things like Dragons Rioting.
BassForever
Member
Yep, foxy and fishman > gaara v rock lee
Oh, hey! I like Noragami. It's that thing with Arara- I mean, no, whoops.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Am I the only one here who reads noragami?
Because you guys should get in on that. Even though the story telling can be pretty messy at times.
Because you guys should get in on that. Even though the story telling can be pretty messy at times.
Urban Scholar
Member
Ok so...I read saint seiya the lost canvas. How's saint seiya episode G?
thesaucetastic
Unconfirmed Member
Hajiotsu. 6
Welp I thought this was ending, but I guess we still have time for the cliched amusement park date.
Usotsuki Boyfriend 1-2
Is this the shoujo and wholesome version of Aunt Tits
Welp I thought this was ending, but I guess we still have time for the cliched amusement park date.
Usotsuki Boyfriend 1-2
Is this the shoujo and wholesome version of Aunt Tits
dakkumauji
Member
On my list. Too many things come up for me to burn through my backlog and Ookiku is such a long series as it is.
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
edit: wait, misread the title.
ColossalLazy
Member
I am watching it and its pretty good, so I am holding out to reading it until the anime ends.
Kono Oto Tomare! 12
Why is she acting all cute all of a sudden. Hopefully it doesn't turn into some huge chika harem.
I read the first 4 chapters or so yesterday, didn't really hold my interest tbh. The description set my expectations up differently. I might give it another shot when a few more chapters come out.
Why is she acting all cute all of a sudden. Hopefully it doesn't turn into some huge chika harem.
I read the first 4 chapters or so yesterday, didn't really hold my interest tbh. The description set my expectations up differently. I might give it another shot when a few more chapters come out.
dakkumauji
Member
you have me slightly interested
Antiwhippy
the holder of the trombone
Nah, it's nothing major. Just misread which utsotsuki manga the poster from the previous page was talking about.
For noragami itself, while I don't think it's amazing (some parts seemed too rushed just due to the structure of it), I still think that it has some really great art with fun action, plus it gets going once it introduced more of the concept of partner weapons and they delve more into the nature of the main character.
Also has this chick, just to drum up more interest.
ColossalLazy
Member
Also has this chick, just to drum up more interest.
She is voiced by Miyukichi in the anime, so its a plus.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked