Can someone please explain why people hate fedoras? Never wore one, but I don't understand the hate.
I don't live in the US.
I don't live in the US either, but I've seen my share of "fedora'd gentlemen" in the wild.
Why there is hate, or rather the ridicule for fedoras can be a somewhat lenghty explanation. So I'll start with this picture posted earlier in the thread:
In that image there's a man who's stylish and he wears a fedora, no problems there. However there is a large group of people who want to be stylish or "classy" who look at that picture and see it differently, they see that he's stylish because he wears a hat. Therefore, the logic goes, fedora itself is what makes you stylish.
Of course real life doesn't work like that, as the hat is nothing but an accessory on your overall look. But looking around the internet there are tons and tons of people who focus on fedoras alone for their look - it's treated as some sort of "enchanted hat of charisma +2" just put it on and you'll instantly look good. This is wrong and is the root of bad fedora fashion.
There are social connections too as the fedora, or rather the wrong usage of one, has become a sort of a stereotype of certain cultural subgroups. Not only are they regularly connected with the "nice guys", you know the types who are not actually nice, and smug atheists and/or libertarians and such. But that's another issue.
At first the ridicule was targeted at individuals who looked awkward with their awkward style, this is common all over the internet. But as fedora usage gained momentum the ridicule shifted from the individuals themselves more towards the usage of the hat itself. There are cases where this is unfortunate, as even those who use fedoras "legitimately" get grouped with the fedora fetishists.
edit: Of course many times those who wear the hat wrong have the mindset that a hat's a hat. They usually end up with ill fitting fedoras that really don't suit them at all. It's the same with suits for example, unlike what many think you can go wrong with a suit.