• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Preacher S2 |OT| The Gang Visits New Orleans - Mondays 9/8c

TheOddOne

Member
121uhf.png

 

RatskyWatsky

Hunky Nostradamus
Nice OT! Love the colors of the key art~

I thought season one was decent but nothing special - hope they can make the leap in season two!
 

vaderise

Member
I hope this season is a lot closer to comic storyline.
Herr Star makes me excited gor this season, i hope it delivers.
 

KAOz

Short bus special
I hope this season is a lot closer to comic storyline.
Herr Star makes me excited gor this season, i hope it delivers.

I hope they reach the point where Herr Starr tries on different hats.

Or make a Brad Pitt and Patrick Stewart joke.
 

Grizzlyjin

Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
Nice OT.

I keep forgetting that Season 2 premieres this summer. Seems like it is flying under everyone's radar. The 13 episode order has me a wee bit worried. But Season 1 had some really fun moments, and I enjoyed Tulip and Cassidy. I guess I'm in.
 

Cptkrush

Member
I thought season 1 was incredible. Between this and American Gods, TV shows got weird, and I'm fully on board. I even read vol 1 before checking out the show and I still loved it, especially when it all came together at the end.

Anyone know if this'll be on Hulu as it airs or will it be delayed until the season is over again?
 
Its quite a step down from the comics but still I think Joe Gilgun is fucking amazing and is really doing his part to make this watchable.

Ruth Negga has been fun too. Hopefully it sticks a bit closer to the script this season. the killer plot on the road was dope, which should likely be up next chronologically if they're doing it that way.
 

LotusHD

Banned
I thought Season 1 was great despite hearing comic readers continually tell me otherwise, but yea, I can see that Season 2 is likely where the show will definitely hits its stride.
 

skybald

Member
Thanks to reading Preacher Book One 4 months ago, I felt deep into the hole of comic reading. Book One is still my favorite comic read so far. I bought Book Two. I have the highest of hopes.
 

TheOddOne

Member
- Sepinwall: ‘Preacher’ Season Two Becomes The Show It Should Have Been All Along.
Fortunately, the first three episodes of the new season get straight to road-tripping, taking Jesse, Tulip, and Cassidy from the backroads of Texas to an Indian-themed (as in Mumbai, not Apache) casino to a series of jazz clubs in New Orleans, each stop theoretically taking them closer to finding the Almighty and calling Him to account for all that’s wrong in the world, while also having them run afoul of cops, gangsters, a secret global conspiracy, and the Cowboy (Graham McTavish from Outlander), sprung from Hell at the end of last season to go after Jesse — who’s currently playing host to a half-angel, half-demon called Genesis that gives him power called the Word of God, which can make anyone do whatever he says — with guns so accurate and deadly, they can lay waste to immortals just as easily as to regular people.

Preacher is almost instantly a livelier and more satisfying show as a result of the change. Catlin and company are still mixing and matching parts of the comic like the Cowboy with their own stories and characters, but the tone is much more light-hearted, and Jesse is now an active rogue rather than a sad sack struggling through a role everybody knows he’s no good at. There were stretches in the first season where Negga’s vigorous performance as the casually homicidal Tulip (still the character most improved in translation from page to screen) was the only reason to stick around; now that Jesse has a mission, and he and Tulip and Cassidy are working together and keeping slightly fewer secrets between them, episodes feel more evenly distributed, so that when our misfit heroes split up, it can be fun to follow any of them, alone or in pairs.
To a degree, Preacher resembles Starz’s American Gods, which also adapts a beloved work by a star of the ’90s comics scene, which also arguably devoted too much of its first season to setting up the story rather than just telling it, and which shares a vibe of, “I don’t quite understand what’s happening, but it looks really cool and is played with such energy that I’m just gonna go with it.” And we’re still in such early phases of this new Preacher story that it’s hard to predict whether the show has found a new and improved quality level or is just charged up at the start of another year. (Season one was at its strongest early on, before it became clear there wasn’t enough life in Annville to sustain 10 hours.) But it feels more like, well, a TV show — one that better understands its strengths and its weaknesses, and that is actually going somewhere, narratively as well as physically, after being stuck in an uninteresting place for too long.
The thing Preacher is now seems much more entertaining and sustainable. I just wish it had gotten us to this thing much sooner.
- Collider: ‘Preacher’ Season 2 Review: Road Tripping at the Gates of Hell.
Still, interested viewers — especially those who were burned out or disappointed by Preacher’s first season — should feel heartened by the show’s return this year (including the cartoony premiere episode, directed against by Seth Rogan and Evan Goldberg). Despite its narrative issues, it’s too stylish and unique to write off, and its cast is incredibly strong across the board. Still, it’s uncertain whether or not the show can really get off the ground and get going this year, even as the trio hit the road. Once burned, twice shy.
- Indiewire: ‘Preacher’ Review: A Bloody Search for God in New Orleans Uncovers a More Focused and Colorful Season 2.
[With Jesse still taking much of the main focus, this newest season of “Preacher” benefits from his sense of singular purpose. Having an overarching goal and a shortened list of distractions has left the humans and immortal beings in his inner circle with the perfect antidote to a world where God is missing and an honest mistake can trap a teenager in Hell. There are plenty of miles on the odometer still left to travel, but few shows have done a better job tidying up the roadmap.
 
Watched the first three episodes of season 2. It is way WAY better than the first season, for what it's worth, and I'm a huge fan of the source material.
 

hydruxo

Member
I watched like 3/4ths of the first season and got kind of bored, so I might just read up on a recap and hop in with S2.
 
I've still got the last 2-3 episodes on my DVR from last year. Guess I should finish them off if season 2 is supposed to be better.
 

Obscura

Member
Glad to see those reviews. I seem to have enjoyed S1 more than most fans of the comic but I know the show could be considerably better than it is.

That first review made me remember how much I dislike the Saint being called "The Cowboy". I really hope they give him his proper title.
 

jrcbandit

Member
Can I just skip season 1? I got tired of it after 3 or so episodes and disliked how it was almost nothing like the comics.
 
Can I just skip season 1? I got tired of it after 3 or so episodes and disliked how it was almost nothing like the comics.

If you read the comics, you can totally skip the rest of the season. I think the big takeaway that's different from the books is:

Arseface is trapped in hell and serves the role of "John Wayne" for Jesse.

Also, a big plus of the first few episodes of season 2:

They "fix" Arseface's origin from the first season.
 
Nice, I'll have to check this out.

The first season, while more underwhelming than not on the whole, had some very cool moments and characters (especially Cassidy). What was good about it is enough for me to come back and see how a 2nd season turns out.
 
I thought season 1 was incredible. Between this and American Gods, TV shows got weird, and I'm fully on board. I even read vol 1 before checking out the show and I still loved it, especially when it all came together at the end.

Anyone know if this'll be on Hulu as it airs or will it be delayed until the season is over again?
Legion was another recent, fantastically weird show.
 

Obscura

Member
If you read the comics, you can totally skip the rest of the season. I think the big takeaway that's different from the books is:

Arseface is trapped in hell and serves the role of "John Wayne" for Jesse.

Also, a big plus of the first few episodes of season 2:

They "fix" Arseface's origin from the first season.

Regarding spoiler #2: So happy to hear that. What they did to him in S1 was character assassination of the most egregious kind.
 

HStallion

Now what's the next step in your master plan?
I thought the first season was terrible and not simply as an adaptation of the comic but as a show in general. It's pace was meandering at best, the characters seemed drastically shift from episode to episode (Jesse especially), it seemed to think shock value made up for those weaker elements and so on and so forth. I have little hope this second season will actually be good even if it adheres closer to the comic book but I'll give it a few episodes before I drop this show for good.
 

RangerX

Banned
I tried to get into the first season but it was so radically different from the story it was adapting that I don't know why they didn't write something original. Props to Gilgud for doing a decent west of Ireland accent though rather than the usual stereotypical shit.
 

Platy

Member
As an adaptation, Season 1 sucked.

But I was having fun all around with the crazyness.... but it was a pre-american gods world =P
 
Looking forward to the show returning, everything I've read about the 2nd season has me confident it will be an improvement over the first and I liked the 1st season.
 

Parch

Member
I hope the writing is better and the show actually has some sort of direction.
I'm kinda surprised the show got a 2nd season.
 

TheOddOne

Member
- A|V Club Review: Preacher steps on the gas in season 2, and finally starts going somewhere.
Those are relatively small gripes; overall, Preacher recovers a lot of ground from the first season, thanks in part to improved pacing. And it’s really just looking better than ever, from the costuming to the sun-washed cinematography and gorgeous saturated colors. That vibrant color palette pairs perfectly with the heightened focus of the season, which will hopefully remain just as sharp as the rest of it unfolds. A hunt for god(s) has recently played out on the small screen, but the focus and dynamic of this hell-bound road trip (yes, the underworld pops up, too) is different. There is a swindle going on in Preacher, but the audience is no longer the one being taken for a ride.
 
I thought the first season was terrible and not simply as an adaptation of the comic but as a show in general. It's pace was meandering at best, the characters seemed drastically shift from episode to episode (Jesse especially), it seemed to think shock value made up for those weaker elements and so on and so forth. I have little hope this second season will actually be good even if it adheres closer to the comic book but I'll give it a few episodes before I drop this show for good.

Agreed. It's been so long since I read the comic that I don't remember anything from it so expectations have nothing to do with why I hated season one. It was just an all around terrible show.
 

TheOddOne

Member
- Daniel Fienberg at THR: 'Preacher' Season 2: TV Review.
That means they're unified in going toward something and also in moving away from something, and that breeds momentum. It's heavily serialized, and yet the hours are pleasantly episodic, bridged by cliff-hangers. It feels like a TV series, which isn't always how the show felt last year.
Putting the characters together — not always, as they're still capable of personal missions — lets Preacher draw much more humor, and occasionally emotion, from the dynamics between the core trio, boasting an even stranger assortment of attempted accents this season than previously.
The clearer storytelling benefits the actors. Or maybe nothing has actually changed, and maybe the past year since Preacher premiered has seen enough out-there programming debut — Legion, Twin Peaks, the aforementioned American Gods, etc. — that Preacher just doesn't feel as outre anymore.

I don't think that's it. I think Preacher was just a complicated adaptation process, and the first season found the creators doing the best they could just to get this world moving, while the second season finds them more comfortable and better able to really tell this story.
 

jonno394

Member
Can't wait for this, really enjoyed the first season.

Can anyone confirm if
Anatol Yusef
is set to return in season 2?
 

Serpico99

Member
Just binged the first season the past two days. I loved it. That being said... I haven't read the source material. I appreciated the slow world building.

Also I just enjoy a good western, which tends to have long almost pointless discussions.
 

Parallax

best seen in the classic "Shadow of the Beast"
Its quite a step down from the comics but still I think Joe Gilgun is fucking amazing and is really doing his part to make this watchable.

Ruth Negga has been fun too. Hopefully it sticks a bit closer to the script this season. the killer plot on the road was dope, which should likely be up next chronologically if they're doing it that way.

cassidy and arseface were the best aspects of season one. but i dont know if i can deal with more of this custer
 
Top Bottom