• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

GAF's Best of E3 2014 Awards

javac

Member
I'm inclined to think it's because of the Treehouse that Nintendo was ignored. Nintendo is now competing directly with media outlets for coverage, and during the most important event of the year, no less. It would make sense that the strategy going in is to either snuff out Nintendo or simply not compete with them because Treehouse will have the better coverage. Nintendo is walking a fine line here, it's pretty nuts. I'm just hoping we've come to a time where social media and word of mouth can spread news faster and better than games media.

When you have a list of best Wii U games at E3 from IGN that looks like this:

Super Smash Bros.
Mario Maker
Yoshi's Woolly World
Captain Toad Treasure Tracker
Xenoblade Chronicles X

It's perpetuating an idea that Nintendo did not show unique titles, mature titles, or anything out of the ordinary like Splatoon, Bayonetta, Devil's Third, Hyrule Warriors, etc.

Yeah it's nuts but like you said, I think it may work out for them. It's going to be tough tho. A lot of gaffers probably don't think of themselves as super savvy or out of the ordinary but you'd be surprised at the numpties out there that are easily fooled. It's how rubish gets spread around. A lot of people will take everything these outlets report as gospel and that includes the lack of news which can be pretty damaging in terms of mind-share in and of itself.

Overall however I feel Nintendo realised relying on such a fickle outlet to create and distribute your message is unreliable. It's ballsy and risky and could burn bridges but I still feel Nintendo doesn't mind being inclusive. Letting others stream the Digital Event and having games like Devil's Third revealed on IGN and even round tables helps keep some form of willingness to work with the likes of say IGN. It's almost like Nintendo is teaching everyone else how it's done, spoon feeding them like babies. With great power comes great responsibility and all that.
 

140.85

Cognitive Dissonance, Distilled
Ya done good, GAF! Great list.

Personally I'd swap 1 & 2 because I got burnt by the Skyward Sword hype, but otherwise it's tops.
 

Tom_Cody

Member
I just went out to compare this list to top media sources... and I probably shouldn't have.

IGN's nominations are horrid, holy shit: http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/06/12/igns-best-of-e3-2014-awards

Thank you for being GAF, GAF

Oh wow, Gamespot's is probably worse: http://www.gamespot.com/articles/e3-2014-gamespot-s-best-of-e3-2014-winners/1100-6420468/

No Splatoon, Bayonetta, Xenoblade Chronicles X, just... wat
Those are absolutely abysmal.

I guess this reaction was inevitable from the moment Nintendo announced the digital event but it's still shocking to see it play out.
 

John Harker

Definitely doesn't make things up as he goes along.
Mostly surprised how low The division is after pretty much winning eveything last year.

Declining interest or more competition?
 

AniHawk

Member
Mostly surprised how low The division is after pretty much winning eveything last year.

Declining interest or more competition?

last year was new and shiny next gen. 2013 was way back when the future was untold and the sky was the limit. now we're living in the future and it turns out video games are still video games. i blame watch_dogs.
 

lamaroo

Unconfirmed Member
I just realised I watched nothing but Nintendo's coverage at E3.

How did The Division look compared to last year?
 

javac

Member
Mostly surprised how low The division is after pretty much winning eveything last year.

Declining interest or more competition?

The demo's are just incredibly boring with the canned 'communication' between the players. Nothing differentiates it from anything else imo. And the fact we'll probably see a similar demo again next year at E3 before its released burns people out. The fact that we see it at multiple conferences also becomes very annoying. That's just me however. I'm sure it'll sell amazingly.
 

gngf123

Member
I just realised I watched nothing but Nintendo's coverage at E3.

How did The Division look compared to last year?

I wasn't really paying attention because it bored the hell out of me, but from what I remember visually it looked good. Not sure if it was downgraded at all but if it was it wasn't Watchdogs levels or anything. Nothing that stood out.

But it is still Ubisoft, so you never know.
 
I don't think I nominated Splatoon. I can't believe I overlooked it, so I'm feeling a little guilty. But fortunately, it's done well for itself on this list.

Cross-checking other sites' lists, I can confidently also say that this is the most solid one I've seen.

Out of the top 10, I'd swap out Uncharted 4 for say, Dragon Age Inquisition, as slightly controversial as it might be. Don't get me wrong, I will also buy Uncharted 4, and it will likely be a good game, at least consistent with the overall quality of the series thus far, but we barely saw anything from the trailer other than it simply being more Uncharted, which only goes so far for someone like me who isn't as big or enthusiastic a fan as others.

Valiant Hearts ideally should be higher as well, but no biggie.
 

jeffers

Member
The demo's are just incredibly boring with the canned 'communication' between the players. Nothing differentiates it from anything else imo. And the fact we'll probably see a similar demo again next year at E3 before its released burns people out. The fact that we see it at multiple conferences also becomes very annoying. That's just me however. I'm sure it'll sell amazingly.

in the rainbow six vid, where they are about to reach and the guy says wait! then goes and looks round to the other guy, that was just hilariously awful :p
 

Mortemis

Banned
Mostly surprised how low The division is after pretty much winning eveything last year.

Declining interest or more competition?

For me, it was just a difference of presentation. Last year it looked great and looked like it played great. This year I was bored silly watching the gameplay. Maybe because last year it was this shiny new shooter that got everyone's hopes up for this gen, but now everyone came down from that high. I'm sure I'll try it out, but IMO, it just looked boring compared to last year.
 

BPoole

Member
Surprised to see Zelda winning. The trailer shown did nothing for me except confirm that yet another Zelda game is being made. I guess that's enough for some people but I would have to see more in terms of gameplay to give it such high regard
 

Kagoshima_Luke

Gold Member
Surprised to see Zelda winning. The trailer shown did nothing for me except confirm that yet another Zelda game is being made. I guess that's enough for some people but I would have to see more in terms of gameplay to give it such high regard

If that's all the trailer did for you then you haven't played many recent Zelda games.
 

Eusis

Member
I don't get it. How can games like Zelda, Uncharted 4 and Xenoblade Chronicles X get into top 10? They only had trailers at the show and those didn't even show any gameplay from what I know.
Zelda gave enough of a hint of the gameplay even though I'm still surprised it got THE top award. I figured for sure it'd be Bloodborne, I guess the fact there'd be significant overlap was another big factor.

Not surprised at all about Splatoon getting biggest surprise though, no one knew it existed yet it got quite a bit of attention, I guess I could be surprised S.T.E.A.M. didn't show up there but then the art style is easy to dislike and really just didn't seem as exciting to me for some reason.
 

atr0cious

Member
I will never understand, with all the hate for CGI and no gameplay, that trailers that show pretty much nothing are touted as game of the show. Zelda U while cool to see, showed nothing. Same with Bloodborne. Yet people are frothing. At least Splatoon is getting recognition.
 

Chamber

love on your sleeve
Mostly surprised how low The division is after pretty much winning eveything last year.

Declining interest or more competition?

Too far off. Hard for me to maintain hype for a game announced 1 year ago that's probably still another 2 away from release.
 

Tizoc

Member
Sad Grin Fandango didn't won anything :(

I like to think it tied with Halo Collection since they're 5 points apart.

GG Xrd only having 50 points is saddening then again if that game had an XBone ver. it might've gotten more points.
 
I just went out to compare this list to top media sources... and I probably shouldn't have.

IGN's nominations are horrid, holy shit: http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/06/12/igns-best-of-e3-2014-awards

Thank you for being GAF, GAF

Oh wow, Gamespot's is probably worse: http://www.gamespot.com/articles/e3-2014-gamespot-s-best-of-e3-2014-winners/1100-6420468/

No Splatoon, Bayonetta, Xenoblade Chronicles X, just... wat

....IGN's list

Biggest surprise:

Dead Rising DLC
Mass Effect 4
Conker in Project: Spark
Crackdown
GTA V on Next-Gen
Grim Fandango Remastered
LittleBigPlanet 3
Rise of the Tomb Raider Reveal
Rainbow Six Siege
Bloodborne

...no Splatoon? Not even nominated? Seriously? Wow!
 

Tookay

Member
I will never understand, with all the hate for CGI and no gameplay, that trailers that show pretty much nothing are touted as game of the show. Zelda U while cool to see, showed nothing. Same with Bloodborne. Yet people are frothing. At least Splatoon is getting recognition.

Showed plenty, especially in how they were deviating from the constraints of their previous game design.

They did more with less. That's all.
 
....IGN's list

Biggest surprise:

Dead Rising DLC
Mass Effect 4
Conker in Project: Spark
Crackdown
GTA V on Next-Gen
Grim Fandango Remastered
LittleBigPlanet 3
Rise of the Tomb Raider Reveal
Rainbow Six Siege
Bloodborne

...no Splatoon? Not even nominated? Seriously? Wow!
LOL at DLC, the leaked game, andf Mass Effect 4 which we already knew was happening
 

gngf123

Member
....IGN's list

Biggest surprise:

Dead Rising DLC
Mass Effect 4
Conker in Project: Spark
Crackdown
GTA V on Next-Gen
Grim Fandango Remastered
LittleBigPlanet 3
Rise of the Tomb Raider Reveal
Rainbow Six Siege
Bloodborne

...no Splatoon? Not even nominated? Seriously? Wow!

Splatoon didn't even make their list of user's vote Game of the Show at first, the one that contains something like 30 games including Abzu and a tonne of indie games. They only added it when people called them out on it.

Gaming media just doesn't give a shit about anything Nintendo does at this point.
 

AHA-Lambda

Member
Mostly surprised how low The division is after pretty much winning eveything last year.

Declining interest or more competition?

Personally I wasn't bothered to begin with and am still unimpressed outside of the graphics. For me it has the same problem that Destiny has had for some time, where the game is a large scale MMO experience and yet they only insist on showing cover based shooting, yawn...

I will never understand, with all the hate for CGI and no gameplay, that trailers that show pretty much nothing are touted as game of the show. Zelda U while cool to see, showed nothing. Same with Bloodborne. Yet people are frothing. At least Splatoon is getting recognition.

I completely agree, Bloodhound was my top but at least that had leaked footage.
 

Kagoshima_Luke

Gold Member
The last I played was Twilight Princess. Didn't play Skyward Sword or A Link between Worlds

Recent entries in the series, notably Skyward Sword, have been very linear, which is at odds with game's roots (in The Legend of Zelda for the NES, you were pretty much dropped into a world map and left to your own devices). This new Zelda looks to return to this non-linear style of exploration/puzzle solving.
 

Cheech

Member
Witcher 3 got robbed

Seen a couple of those comments, and it makes me wonder how the Witcher 3 is going to perform saleswise.

Quite a few people I know loved Witcher 1, but found Witcher 2 to be borderline unplayable. Personally, I think the combat design was just damn bad. I can't bring myself to buy the third game, and I doubt I'm alone as I'm not the only person I know who felt burned by the second game. We will see.
 

lamaroo

Unconfirmed Member
I don't play Zelda games, but if you've spent any time at all on GAF all you heard about the series was it's time for a change in the formula, and it had to be more open.

When both of those things were announced it could still win game of the show, doesn't hurt that it looked gorgeous.
 
This is a goshdarned good year for racing games.

Quite possibly the best ever. There's no way next year or 2016 will be better...2017 is possible if Sony release a new Wipeout, MS release a new Hydro Thunder and Ninty release a new F-Zero and WaveRace.

You nailed it GAF, nice work.

Hardly. Just look at this travesty. This crime against gaming.

Code:
D4					5 mentions		6 points

Y'all should be ashamed for not mentioning it more.
 
Top Bottom