fair enough. I'm not a fan of idol stuff in particular, outside of really enjoying the Project Diva series (though not sure that's even the same thing). I don't like games that pander just for the sake of pandering, either. If i wanted to ogle anime ladies I could do that on the internet for free without spending $60. I have faith ATLUS that they can produce a worthwhile experience using these themes, though.
My initial criticism to many posters' negative reactions is more that they were coming off as though it would be better if this game just not exist, or that it was somehow poisoning the existing series. While Fire Emblem may not ever shake loose the waifu stuff that many equate with the great sales for Awakening, I'd put money on the next SMT game continuing the general darker tone of the series.