• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Kotaku: A Random 4chan Poster Leaked Nintendo's Switch Event Before It Began

Loris146

Member
Y'all just didn't pay attention to me because I wasn't looking for twitter or YouTube followers, I gave GAF the straight dope and people all denied it. GAffers can't handle the real leaks is the problem.

You were non that specific ( outiside for things like ram and absence of nextflix etc ) though IIRC.
 

robotrock

Banned
I trust some random anon on /v/ rather than some twitter "insider". Sounds odd saying that but seeing that post and comparing it to the insiders I just don't believe anything they have to say.

This too. Who was that random twitter guy who said the thing about a damien wayne batman game at the game awards? where was it?
 

Vena

Member
Now, imagine if that Monster Hunter 5 4chan rumor was true.
1.0

Isn't that rumor dead given what was revealed?

You were non that specific ( outiside for things like ram and absence of nextflix etc ) though IIRC.

Nah, he got everything pretty much spot on. He even knew about Steep but had thought it had been canned due to its failures everywhere else.
 

WadeitOut

Member
Some of you are giving 4Chan way too much credit. It's constantly filled with fake bullshit. So how are we just supposed to take their "leaks" seriously when they are sitting in a dumpster.

As a huge SW fan we get fake garbage movie leaks every week that come from there
 

robotrock

Banned
Some of you are giving 4Chan way too much credit. It's constantly filled with fake bullshit. So how are we just supposed to take their "leaks" seriously when they are sitting in a dumpster.

As a huge SW fan we get fake garbage movie leaks every week that come from there

This too. for every legit 4chan leak, there are a million Super Mario Ice Freeze
 
They showed XC2 at the event tho? Maybe I don't know what the 'event' really is..?

I also edited to point out that the Super Mario Odyssey logo didn't have a plane in it. I'm not trying to say he isn't credible obviously... just funny/weird that they had some small errors.

As in what was actually on the show floor, not what was actually in the presentation video. He stated he was working at the location, so obviously he leaked what he saw from promotional material and the booths.
 
I don't read 4chan much but isn't everyone just called anonymous with no post history so it wouldn't be possible to view someone's track record and know if they're trustworthy?
 

Loris146

Member
Isn't that rumor dead given what was revealed?



Nah, he got everything pretty much spot on. He even knew about Steep but had thought it had been canned due to its failures everywhere else.

I know he was right but for example he never said specifically " Steep was planned but now is not coming". He instead said " a third party game that bombed now is not coming "( i don't recall if he said ubisoft though ). He also said that there were/are multiple third party games coming but never said what "was" coming ( name of the games etc ). That is what i meant. This is also why ( in my opinion) lot of people didn't pay "attention" to him,
 

ArjanN

Member
Eh, leaks this close to the actual thing are pretty lame and pointless though. Once you get to less than a day beforehand and it's a fairly big event, more and more people have to get in the loop, which raises the chances of someone blabbing to about 100%. At that point you might as well wait the exta half day and not make the event less exciting/surprising. It's bascailly why I stop looking at GAF in the hours before a big event like this.

Some of you are giving 4Chan way too much credit. It's constantly filled with fake bullshit. So how are we just supposed to take their "leaks" seriously when they are sitting in a dumpster.

As a huge SW fan we get fake garbage movie leaks every week that come from there

Also this. Of course occasionally someone will have something legit, but there's kinda no way to discern it from all the other garbage.
 

Kindekuma

Banned
Some of you are giving 4Chan way too much credit. It's constantly filled with fake bullshit. So how are we just supposed to take their "leaks" seriously when they are sitting in a dumpster.

As a huge SW fan we get fake garbage movie leaks every week that come from there

Well, you can't verify the legitimacy of twitter "insiders" more than some anon on 4chan. I wouldn't say it's giving too much credit. "My uncle works for Nintendo" coming out of the mouth of some anon has just as much legitimacy as someone with a twitter.

Just my two cents though.
 
I find it funny that this forum had multiple threads about information from supposed "insiders" like Emily Rogers and Laura Kate Dale all leading up to the Switch event where most of said information turned out completely false or absent.

It's once again someone on /v/ who has the accurate leaks.
 

Caelus

Member
I don't read 4chan much but isn't everyone just called anonymous with no post history so it wouldn't be possible to view someone's track record and know if they're trustworthy?

Aside from non-anon accounts, yeah. Basically a broken clock is right twice a day kind of situation, except it's a shit-encrusted clock. It was also really close to the actual event so it's not like this is particularly amazing.
 

Vena

Member
I know he was right but for example he never said specifically " Steep was planned but now is not coming". He instead said " a third party game that bombed now is not coming "( i don't recall if he said ubisoft though ). He also said that there were/are multiple third party games coming but never said what "was" coming ( name of the games etc ). That is what i meant.

Nah he gave away it was Steep with a ski emoji.
 

TheSeks

Blinded by the luminous glory that is David Bowie's physical manifestation.
Well, you can't verify the legitimacy of twitter "insiders" more than some anon on 4chan. I wouldn't say it's giving too much credit. "My uncle works for Nintendo" coming out of the mouth of some anon has just as much legitimacy as someone with a twitter.

Just my two cents though.

Exactly.
Just like GAF insiders
.
 

Eolz

Member
Y'all just didn't pay attention to me because I wasn't looking for twitter or YouTube followers, I gave GAF the straight dope and people all denied it. GAffers can't handle the real leaks is the problem.

You're definitely are one of the most reliable I've seen on this website, and not doing it for attention like some previous ones help.

I don't read 4chan much but isn't everyone just called anonymous with no post history so it wouldn't be possible to view someone's track record and know if they're trustworthy?

Yes, that's the whole point. And everyone there mocks people trying to make a name for themselves. Most just roll with it in the fake leak threads.
That's why you also shouldn't start going there in the hope of finding good leaks.
 

Tripon

Member
Aside from non-anon accounts, yeah. Basically a broken clock is right twice a day kind of situation, except it's a shit-encrusted clock. It was also really close to the actual event so it's not like this is particularly amazing.
You say that, but that's not stopping any other insider of posting that info either.
 

Eila

Member
I don't read 4chan much but isn't everyone just called anonymous with no post history so it wouldn't be possible to view someone's track record and know if they're trustworthy?

You can have a unique tripcode if you want to but most real leakers seem to do it as a one off easy anonymous leak.
 

Deadbeat

Banned
Well, you can't verify the legitimacy of twitter "insiders" more than some anon on 4chan. I wouldn't say it's giving too much credit. "My uncle works for Nintendo" coming out of the mouth of some anon has just as much legitimacy as someone with a twitter.

Just my two cents though.
With 4chan there is no twitter handle trying to gain fame. So that cuts out some of the bs.
 

Risette

A Good Citizen
yeah this entire media cycle should've taught everyone that if a leak is real it's not going to be some attention obsessed twitter randos trying to make a name for themselves, it's going to be dumped off anonymously on 4chan
 

silva1991

Member
I didn't enter the story leak thread, but weren't the rumor about Horizon's story/ending from 4chan?

Whatever it was I hope it isn't bad then :p
 
I find it funny that this forum had multiple threads about information from supposed "insiders" like Emily Rogers and Laura Kate Dale all leading up to the Switch event where most of said information turned out completely false or absent.

It's once again someone on /v/ who has the accurate leaks.

Emily had the best track record IMO. Looking at the stuff on her blog:

https://arcadegirl64.wordpress.com/...-kart-for-switch-brings-a-mix-of-old-and-new/

Aside from the 16 new courses (which is possibly her source counting the DLC tracks as the new courses), everything else reported here (new battle mode, characters, first three months) is correct.

https://arcadegirl64.wordpress.com/...th-of-the-wild-will-not-be-released-in-march/

She initially thought Zelda might not be at launch. Upon checking with sources at NOA later, she changed her tune and believed that Zelda would indeed be launching in March. LKD's suggestion is that NOE was pushing for a delay due to EFIGS, but NOA and NOJ always targeted March and ended up winning out. So let's give this point to her.

https://arcadegirl64.wordpress.com/2016/09/02/rumor-what-should-we-expect-from-the-final-nx-product/

Pretty much everything she said about the Switch hardware was correct.

https://twitter.com/ArcadeGirl64/status/819440363903582208

Suggested one of the previously-reported Switch ports would not actually be a port, but Mario Kart would be. Splatoon was confirmed to be a sequel.

https://twitter.com/ArcadeGirl64/status/819360693677936640

Doubted Skyrim would be a launch game. This was true.

That's just from the past few weeks because I can't remember what else she said earlier.

The only points against her at the moment, off the top of my head, are the MIA Mother 3, no female player in Zelda, and the new courses in Mario Kart (which might have been her source interpreting the bundled DLC tracks as new courses). But she believes the former is still coming. The latter is looking unlikely at the moment but some people seem to be holding out for playable Zelda. I don't think she commented on the 4chan leak. Her conduct was also the most professional of all the leakers imo.

LKD got some stuff right and was misled by some sources. I think she might have just been a bit overzealous in some cases but a lot of her info was legit.
 

HeelPower

Member
And they leaked FFXV months prior to release and Horizon and Switch event ,and the list goes on.

I just feel bad for people who work hard to make these things and then some minor employees have no sense of decency not to leak these things.
 

vern

Member
You were non that specific ( outiside for things like ram and absence of nextflix etc ) though IIRC.

I gave as much as I could and said it was very informed speculation. And I always maintained what I did know (hardware, os and 3rd party) vs what I didn't know (first party, contents of the presentation, etc.)

Still waiting to see how the rest of the software and other things I've said panned out, we still don't know for sure no browser or Netflix I guess right? But it's looking that way. None of the other leakers had that which almost made me doubt my source, especially as gaf came down hard on me.

Nah he gave away it was Steep with a ski emoji.

Yea not sure what happened there, I owned up to that one being wrong. Can't get everything right. Possibly it got outsourced or something instead of outright cancelled.
 

Loris146

Member
I gave as much as I could and said it was very informed speculation. And I always maintained what I did know (hardware, os and 3rd party) vs what I didn't know (first party, contents of the presentation, etc.)

Still waiting to see how the rest of the software and other things I've said panned out, we still don't know for sure no browser or Netflix I guess right? But it's looking that way. None of the other leakers had that which almost made me doubt my source, especially as gaf came down hard on me.



Yea not sure what happened there, I owned up to that one being wrong. Can't get everything right. Possibly it got outsourced or something instead of outright cancelled.

Can i ask you one thing? The game that is being remastered ( R *) is available on current gen console ? :)
 

Bboy AJ

My dog was murdered by a 3.5mm audio port and I will not rest until the standard is dead
He got something wrong but I thought it was just a temp ban and he chose not to come back. Shame.
There's no benefit to posting rumors on GAF. Seriously. It's incredibly hostile to insiders.
 

WadeitOut

Member
Well, you can't verify the legitimacy of twitter "insiders" more than some anon on 4chan. I wouldn't say it's giving too much credit. "My uncle works for Nintendo" coming out of the mouth of some anon has just as much legitimacy as someone with a twitter.

Just my two cents though.

You're right, but that's also why I just automatically assume all of these are fake. Skepticism can be healthy.
 

vern

Member
Can i ask you one thing? The game that is being remastered ( R *) is available on current gen console ? :)

Would love to say more but can't really. Impressed that Nintendo felt it wasn't worth mentioning. Perhaps E3. I hear September target release date. Baffling what Nintendo chose to share the other day.
 
Would love to say more but can't really. Impressed that Nintendo felt it wasn't worth mentioning. Perhaps E3. I hear September target release date. Baffling what Nintendo chose to share the other day.

So you just confirmed it will be on Switch?
 
Top Bottom