• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Kotaku: A Random 4chan Poster Leaked Nintendo's Switch Event Before It Began

I wasn't sure if the leak was real when I first read it (I was trending towards "fake" honestly), but it definitely felt more believable than most fake leaks, so I took it somewhat seriously. Fake leaks are usually really easy to spot, as they tend to be full of "fan fiction" type games like Metroid, F-Zero, Wave Race, etc. and they sprinkle heavily rumored games (like the Mario x Rabbids RPG) or already-announced titles to make it seem legit. This leak was full of stuff the average "leaker" would never even think to include, like ARMS, 1,2 Switch, and a freakin' Street Fighter II update.
 

Tecnniqe

Banned
Yep, more reliable than GAF. War has changed.

187.jpg


But there is no reason to leak on GAF.

If right, nothing happens
If wrong, perma banned
And if you don't want to post definitive proof, which might bite you, the leaker in the ass, baaaan.
 
I wasn't sure if the leak was real when I first read it (I was trending towards "fake" honestly), but it definitely felt more believable than most fake leaks, so I took it somewhat seriously. Fake leaks are usually really easy to spot, as they tend to be full of "fan fiction" type games like Metroid, F-Zero, Wave Race, etc. and they sprinkle heavily rumored games (like the Mario x Rabbids RPG) or already-announced titles to make it seem legit. This leak was full of stuff the average "leaker" would never even think to include, like ARMS and a freakin' Street Fighter II update.

This is correct.

The Smash Bros development cycle is good for one thing: it teaches you how to spot a definite fake, a likely fake, and a "this is just depressing enough to be true" leak.
 

EDarkness

Member
Interesting that the list turned out to be true. I was right that there would be a straight up negative reaction if it did turn out to be true. Sheesh. At least the negativity seems to have subsided. Not sure how it went for the leakers, but I think people should be careful in what they believe and how they interpret "leaks". I think the leaks really messed with people's expectations.
 

Gnub

Member
So were the rumors about Mother etc just used by Nintendo to flush out the mole leaking information to the press? Maybe they have someone locked in a basement surrounded by Ninten-ninjas.
 
187.jpg


But there is no reason to leak on GAF.

If right, nothing happens
If wrong, perma banned
And if you don't want to post definitive proof, which might bite you, the leaker in the ass, baaaan.

Well... back to being overly obsessed with a few dropped frames, port begging, platform warring, agenda driven topics, polygon pie charts, hype trains and concern trolling I guess.
 

Kaelan

Member
You were non that specific ( outiside for things like ram and absence of nextflix etc ) though IIRC.

He was highly specific and spot on. He talked about the app, how the OS will be minimalistic and things will be relegated to app, social media approach, etc. dude is spot on.
 

Vena

Member
Would love to say more but can't really. Impressed that Nintendo felt it wasn't worth mentioning. Perhaps E3. I hear September target release date. Baffling what Nintendo chose to share the other day.

Nah, makes sense. Zelda is the thrust of the reveal and Skyrim/FIFA was the upfront reveal since Skyrim was in the pre-reveal, and E3 is three months later.

Look at how Fire Emblem got a five second shot and then a direct after even though its a big IP for them now.
 

Eolz

Member
Would love to say more but can't really. Impressed that Nintendo felt it wasn't worth mentioning. Perhaps E3. I hear September target release date. Baffling what Nintendo chose to share the other day.

Nah, makes sense. Zelda is the thrust of the reveal and Skyrim/FIFA was the upfront reveal since Skyrim was in the pre-reveal, and E3 is three months later.

Look at how Fire Emblem got a five second shot and then a direct after even though its a big IP for them now.

I don't know, it still was pretty baffling they didn't decide to show more.
The current message out there is that the third party lineup this year is worse than on WiiU...
 

Vena

Member
I don't know, it still was pretty baffling they didn't decide to show more.
The current message out there is that the third party lineup this year is worse than on WiiU...

Go listen to the most recent RFN episode, near the end.

Whatever their plan is, they have more stuff to talk about but didn't for /shrug reasons.
 
Not really worth risking your job over as a setup person, personally. Show's you're
not to be trusted for setup, so who will want to work with you if confidentiality is important? Just saying its "somewhere in Europe" is easy enough since a hired agency operates on most things, maybe another agency for specific countries but yeah, why risk it?
 
Also Suikoden V and Xenosga HD.

To be fair, Namco a while back since tweeted they were "thinking about it" out of pretty much nowhere way after Verendus suggested it was in the works for sometime in the future.

And who really knows if Suikoden might have existed before Konami imploded their games division lol. I don't think anyone saw them canning Kojima and then almost all of the rest of their game development back then.
 

EatChildren

Currently polling second in Australia's federal election (first in the Gold Coast), this feral may one day be your Bogan King.
Of our regular twitter "leakers" Emily was on point for most part and continues to be so. Most of her info correlated perfectly with what we we got, and she didn't discredit the 4chan leak unlike others.
 

azertydu91

Hard to Kill
Y'all just didn't pay attention to me because I wasn't looking for twitter or YouTube followers, I gave GAF the straight dope and people all denied it. GAffers can't handle the real leaks is the problem.

Don't worry some of us still trust you and even though it's just my opinion you are amond the top 3 of my insiders list with CBOAT and Matt But I never quite got what happened to you.
 
Y'all just didn't pay attention to me because I wasn't looking for twitter or YouTube followers, I gave GAF the straight dope and people all denied it. GAffers can't handle the real leaks is the problem.

Where are your leaks? Not trying to be an ass just never saw anything
 

DataGhost

Member
And she added this:


Goes hand in hand with Vern's additions, and what the guest on RFN noted as well.

That would make sense that they wouldn't want to compete with Zelda because people would be buying a new console as well as a game. That's $360 spent already.
 

Pacotez

Member
Some of you are giving 4Chan way too much credit. It's constantly filled with fake bullshit. So how are we just supposed to take their "leaks" seriously when they are sitting in a dumpster.

As a huge SW fan we get fake garbage movie leaks every week that come from there


Most of those fake leaks are memeleaks (my dad works for reggie kind of leak). Pretty easy to spot actually.
And /tv/ has a completely different culture from /v/. /tv/ doesn't actually leak anything ever
 
Why did CBoat get banned? He predicted like the entire E3 before it happened with the exception of Prince of Persia or something.

I remember he was banned for trolling ps4 fans in an npd thread. Lied about the sales difference between xb1 and ps4 after the first price cut. Hilarious to see people blindly believe CBOAT and making jokes about MS.


There is really no benefit in leaking on Gaf. On 4chan you are nothing but a number.
 

jmizzal

Member
Emily had the best track record IMO. Looking at the stuff on her blog:

https://arcadegirl64.wordpress.com/...-kart-for-switch-brings-a-mix-of-old-and-new/

Aside from the 16 new courses (which is possibly her source counting the DLC tracks as the new courses), everything else reported here (new battle mode, characters, first three months) is correct.

https://arcadegirl64.wordpress.com/...th-of-the-wild-will-not-be-released-in-march/

She initially thought Zelda might not be at launch. Upon checking with sources at NOA later, she changed her tune and believed that Zelda would indeed be launching in March. LKD's suggestion is that NOE was pushing for a delay due to EFIGS, but NOA and NOJ always targeted March and ended up winning out. So let's give this point to her.

https://arcadegirl64.wordpress.com/2016/09/02/rumor-what-should-we-expect-from-the-final-nx-product/

Pretty much everything she said about the Switch hardware was correct.

https://twitter.com/ArcadeGirl64/status/819440363903582208

Suggested one of the previously-reported Switch ports would not actually be a port, but Mario Kart would be. Splatoon was confirmed to be a sequel.

https://twitter.com/ArcadeGirl64/status/819360693677936640

Doubted Skyrim would be a launch game. This was true.

That's just from the past few weeks because I can't remember what else she said earlier.

The only points against her at the moment, off the top of my head, are the MIA Mother 3, no female player in Zelda, and the new courses in Mario Kart (which might have been her source interpreting the bundled DLC tracks as new courses). But she believes the former is still coming. The latter is looking unlikely at the moment but some people seem to be holding out for playable Zelda. I don't think she commented on the 4chan leak. Her conduct was also the most professional of all the leakers imo.

LKD got some stuff right and was misled by some sources. I think she might have just been a bit overzealous in some cases but a lot of her info was legit.

Yea I dont know why people still shit on Emily when she has been spot on with Switch

LKD, and the dude on from Unseen64 on the other hand has been off on a lot of stuff and back peddling a lot
 

Forkball

Member
Some of you are giving 4Chan way too much credit. It's constantly filled with fake bullshit. So how are we just supposed to take their "leaks" seriously when they are sitting in a dumpster.

As a huge SW fan we get fake garbage movie leaks every week that come from there

It is basically a dumping ground for BS leaks, but there has been a lot of legitimate information posted there first. It's very easy to remain anonymous and get drowned out, only for people to realize you were legit after it comes true. Several Pokemon leaks came from there, and not a huge laundry list of features, but just short posts revealing story info no one could have guessed. It's extremely difficult to parse what's real and what's not, so you've only got to rely on common sense and faith.

I didn't see the 4chan leak beforehand, but I did see people mention it during the conference and looked it up. I was pretty shocked, but there were at least some surprises like Xenoblade 2.
 
Why was Verendus banned? He was always positive the FF VII Remake was being developed, and that seemed impossible at the time, yet here we are.
 

jmizzal

Member
What were the main things he said?

Edit: Actually went a skim through his videos(ugh) and the one thing he got wrong was the charge time for the Switch.

He did get right, free internet at launch and could be paid later, shin megami tensei Switch

Some of the other stuff could come later, but those are not easy guess
 
Yeah, GAF probably got a little overzealous lately.

It is video games rumors. Not the nuclear launch codes.

I saw a guy trying to rabble rouse a witch hunt on this lady who said she had a job interview at Microsoft just the other day on some thread. Started calling for bish lol. Folks are getting crazy.
 
Top Bottom