• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Next-Gen PS5 & XSX |OT| Console tEch threaD

Status
Not open for further replies.

Moses85

Member
By mere fact that MS wants to release a cheaper version and is not willing to take loss on series X and lower the price there , i would say sony will take more loss at launch


Microsoft generates loss here in Germany regularly. For example, they are selling the X here from time to time for 250€ and even less bundled with up to two games.

And if a Lockhart does really exist, imo this thing won’t print money, it will be a nice product nothing more, like the Xbox One All Digital.
 
Or some part of Konami?

If it’s
  1. related to Japan, and
  2. it‘s not an outright studio acquisition which OsirisBlack OsirisBlack hinted it was not above,
  3. and it’s not a money hat, but where something was purchased
...Microsoft acquiring the Konami video game IP makes the most sense because it doesn’t seem they are doing much with it and they have seem to be focused more on other things as a company.

Not sure how ”Killing it” relates thought. He also bolded the word “cross” some posts back which made me thing Castlevania but maybe I’m reading too much into this :messenger_grinning_sweat:
 
Last edited:

ANIMAL1975

Member
Thanks! It's good to be back
NOW you really back James! By the way, nice pic mate! 😅

Github was deleted too, it must be legit 🤪
:messenger_fire: :messenger_fire: :messenger_fire::messenger_fire::messenger_fire:

There was a spec leak that showed the PS5 using a certain model SSD from them. That's why it was addressed by them. There was also the rumour that MS were using the new SSD from them, and the fact they went out of their way to deny the Sony one, but not the MS one is interesting.
Just to add a bit more MS is using the SSD controller from Phison not the SSD itself.
The controller MS will probably use is that chip on PCB:

PHISON-Press-Release-20190527_E16-PHOTO.jpg


Sony is using it own custom chip so they will put it inside the APU ou ask some fab like TSMC to produce it to put on PCB.
So PCB leak was old devkit with of the shelf parts (and does it even make sense, to use a Phison controller on it?) or it wasn't related to ps5, and people have been throwing the 316mm dye size calculation ... based on inaccurate information!?

PCB reddit leak
PS5 devkit PCB specs from OQA

monolithic die ~22.4mm by ~14.1mm
16 Samsung K4ZAF325BM-HC18 in clamshell configuration
memory vrm seems like overkill with multiple Fairchild/ON Semiconductor FDMF3170 power stages controlled by an MP2888 from MPS
3 Samsung K4AAG085WB-MCRC, 2 of those close to the NAND acting as DRAM cache (unusual 2GB DRAM per 1 TB NAND)
4 NAND packages soldered to the PCB which are TH58LJT2T24BAEG from Toshiba
PS5016-E16 from Phison

Funny thing is and I won’t quote anyone in particular I already posted this same thing a few days ago when I first heard about it. Now it’s just official. Thanks Phil. Also you’re absolutely right if an entire studio had been purchased you would have heard about it by now.
I remember, i thought you were referring to RE8 (loosing the number 2 from the '28 days' title)... So it's actually the 8 that flies away and you're talking about DL2! And you're saying that MS bought the IP? Not the Techland?

That was what most predicted.
2x 5700 chip.
4 SEs instead of 2 or 2 SEs with 4 SA each?.
Well there it is! Github leak redeemed.
 
Some people have really short term memory. Didn't Sony just recently buy Insomniac? A studio that produced one of their highest profile games on PlayStation 4?
Also, you don't need to buy as many studios when you already own or have built over years a larger number of internal game development studios than any other platform holder...

Ps3 was more expensive and late and less powerful .

ps4 was more powerful only through having more gpu not a better gpu .. every console generation xbox has had the better gpu capability ( if not raw performance). Its highly unlikely after playstations over hyper fp16 and hyperbole in every generation that they this gen for the first time they have a more modern functionally capable gpu. Original Xbox was better than ps2 design .. xbox 360 had integrated pixel and vertex shaders and render to texture and gpu compute.. xbox one had decompression hardware and better performance per cu than playstation .. xbox one x was better in every respect than ps4 pro ( more powerful per cu ANd more powerful overall).

Based on history there is zero chance that Cerny or Sony will deliver more advanced gpu than AMD/ Microsoft. I sure sony will deliver a good price for performance ratio though.
??????
PS3 Vs 360 was debatable in terms of performance. The 360 had a better GPU and memory architecture. The PS3 had vastly superior compute.

And the PS4 not only had a larger GPU, that GPU had 4 times the number of asynchronous compute engines that the XB1, which enabled it to better compensate for it's extremely weak CPU, and it had a superior memory architecture. The PS4 was a fantastically designed machine.
In that same sense the XB1X was an excellently designed machine.
 

Audiophile

Member
yep days gone is really good. not counting death stranding and bloodborne since they are third party sony exclusives, i'd rank days gone in the top five.

- gow
- horizon
- spiderman
- days gone
- the last guardian

definitely rank it above the two uncharteds, infamous, and ratchet. its an excellent game. no idea wtf the critics were smoking when they rated it that low.

I haven't gotten round to it yet but from what I hear it's a game that takes a good 10hrs to really take off, I wonder whether a lot of mainstream reviewers didn't have the attention span..
 

ethomaz

Banned
So PCB leak was old devkit with of the shelf parts (and does it even make sense, to use a Phison controller on it?) or it wasn't related to ps5, and people have been throwing the 316mm dye size calculation ... based on inaccurate information!?

PCB reddit leak
I don't know... most leaks says Sony is using a custom SSD solution so it is probably not Phison controller if it is custom.
Xbox seems to using a Phison controller.

It is possible to include that custom SSD controller as a unit inside the APU but that is maybe hard to do... MS added a lot of DMA and Sound controllers in Xbox One APU.
So Sony can do the same or just use the custom chip on PCB like MS will do with his Phison SSD controller.
 
Last edited:

CJY

Banned
LTT just did a video water cooling an SSD that has a Phison controller. Was getting 5GB/s writes.



Mark Cerny said the tech they're using is not available on PC. What's the consensus on what kind of SSD interface Sony is using? I don't think PCIe Gen.4 qualifies as "not available on PC"
 

jonnyp

Member
It's like people forget to mention the part saying it's from an internal trailer from early 2019 so of course it looks rough.

That's all we have to judge it on right now so I don't understand what your point is really. And I don't think it looks rough. It just looks less than impressive in pretty much every aspect considering it's supposedly a next gen exclusive.
 
Last edited:

splattered

Member
I think the lighting and particle effects are nice at least. Not a lot of footage to go on otherwise. Interested in seeing the "loot" etc. So is this like lords of the fallen with aesthetics similar to darksiders?
 
Hello everyone, is there any news ? Thx.
Do you guys remember that insider that claimed Sony exclusives will come to Pc and everybody laughed at him, whats his user name ?
 

Soadi

Member
I mean it's not even AAA right so don't know what anyone would be expecting, RT look's nice though let's just wait for them to show if off.
 

Zero909

Banned
LTT just did a video water cooling an SSD that has a Phison controller. Was getting 5GB/s writes.



Mark Cerny said the tech they're using is not available on PC. What's the consensus on what kind of SSD interface Sony is using? I don't think PCIe Gen.4 qualifies as "not available on PC"

PCIe Gen.4 was not available to the PC market until fall 2019
 
  • Like
Reactions: TLZ

joe_zazen

Member
That was what most predicted.
2x 5700 chip.
4 SEs instead of 2 or 2 SEs with 4 SA each?.

amd has been putting a lot into chiplet research because being able to use multiple chips as if they were one chip is the best way to keep pushing power as we edge closer to the end of die shrinks. IDK if it is mature enough for a console, but maybe for AMD’s next Nvidia Killa XT?

I am going to guess that sony has gone with a very expensive console setup with which they hope to drastically reduce the costs if quickly. So, superfast ssd and 3 chiplet ‘apu’ (2xgpu + cpu), hence pachters $1k comment. And while expensive at launch, all three parts should be much cheaper xmas 2021.

I'm not following the Killing thing?

‘it’ is their competition.

MS is acquiring IP and assets which they will leverage hard to dominate and control and profit. It is what they do in all areas of their businesses. For whatever reasons, gaming is now seen as a profit driver in the future, whereas in the past it was merely tolerated as a gates‘ whim.

it doesnt always work, of course, just look at Nokia purchase. However, there they were competing against other American corporations. It is much easier for American companies to kill foreigner corps they want to kill then other Americans ones who have their own power in Washington.

I predict by 2027, MS #1 in gaming, Tencent #2, Nintendo #3, Sony #4. But, this only applies if Apple remains a hater of gaming.

appl chip design team is best in the world, and they have pushed things far enough that they could easily make consoles superfluous. A12X has more gaming power than x1s and is close to ps4. Make a tv dock, release an official controller, and invest in making it easy for ports (or just buy Nintendo), and we have the ultimate gaming platform with a massive install base that will never defect. Next appl chip on 5nm wont be that far behind next gen. That way, people like me can use their $1000 phones and ipads to play everything. I‘d way rather do that then buy a gaming pc or dedicated hardware.

I don’t think that will happen until Cook retires though, as he is part of the Ballmer/Jobs school wrt gaming.
 

ethomaz

Banned
LTT just did a video water cooling an SSD that has a Phison controller. Was getting 5GB/s writes.



Mark Cerny said the tech they're using is not available on PC. What's the consensus on what kind of SSD interface Sony is using? I don't think PCIe Gen.4 qualifies as "not available on PC"

SSD tech not available can means a lot of thing and not just the PCI-E 4.0 interface.
It is probably a custom solution using PCI-E 4.0 different from any generic SSD solution like the Phison SSD controller.
 

Pantz

Member
MS is definitely KILLING it, shit just got very real. It’s safe to say MS will have quite a few new titles for Xbox fans to sink their teeth into.

edited to add
It’s 5:07am
Or is it 7:07pm
Who calls some this early that excited about game acquisitions? Fucking seriously.

"Sink their teeth into" 🧛‍♂️🧛‍♀️🦇 huh?
 

ANIMAL1975

Member
I don't know... most leaks says Sony is using a custom SSD solution so it is probably not Phison controller if it is custom.
Xbox seems to using a Phison controller.

It is possible to include that custom SSD controller as a unit inside the APU but that is maybe hard to do... MS added a lot of DMA and Sound controllers in Xbox One APU.
So Sony can do the same or just use the custom chip on PCB like MS will do with his Phison SSD controller.
I understood what you said, my point is, if Phison confirmed they are not supplying Sony with their controllers like wrightiswright said (he didn't provide a link), then the PCB leak is inaccurate or it's not ps5 related. And that's where team Gonzalo got their ps5 316mm die calculations.
 

ethomaz

Banned
I understood what you said, my point is, if Phison confirmed they are not supplying Sony with their controllers like wrightiswright said (he didn't provide a link), then the PCB leak is inaccurate or it's not ps5 related. And that's where team Gonzalo got their ps5 316mm die calculations.
Yeap that leak seems fake.

That is the link he posted:

 

ethomaz

Banned
Yeap that leak seems fake.

That is the link he posted:


It is basically Phison repliying a email saying they did not received any order from Sony PS5 like a rumor article said in the past.

Google translated.
"The company has not received an order for Sony PS5. The media reports are market rumors. Investors are advised to refer to it carefully. For company news, please use the public information observation station announcements."
 

CJY

Banned
PCIe Gen.4 was not available to the PC market until fall 2019
Yes, to end-users, but Gen.4 was announced in 2011 and officially ratified in 2017.

I looked backed at what Cerny said in the Wired article. Here's the excerpt:

At the moment, Sony won’t cop to exact details about the SSD—who makes it, whether it utilizes the new PCIe 4.0 standard—but Cerny claims that it has a raw bandwidth higher than any SSD available for PCs.

I guess it could be and most likely is PCIe 4.0, but I would find it a little disingenuous the way it's phrased if that's all it ends up being because Cerny himself is the lead architect. However, he does try to express himself from the perspective of an end-user in parts of that article, so I dunno.

Would be great if Sony had an exotic solution that goes beyond PCIe 4.0, but it's probably not needed as a 16x leap in performance more than justifies a generational leap.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
I haven't gotten round to it yet but from what I hear it's a game that takes a good 10hrs to really take off, I wonder whether a lot of mainstream reviewers didn't have the attention span..
it does take a while to get going and for some reason writing isnt as sharp in the first few hours. its like they go out of their way to make everyone unlikeable.

but then the game takes off and it beame one of the best written games ive played this gen. its like they switched writers in the middle or something. i'd rank it above U4 in terms of writing and characterization. its that good. If it wasnt for GOAT protagonist Arthur Morgan, Deacon would be my favorite new lead this gen.
 
If that's standard IQ for next gen then I'll be very disappointed.
LTT just did a video water cooling an SSD that has a Phison controller. Was getting 5GB/s writes.



Mark Cerny said the tech they're using is not available on PC. What's the consensus on what kind of SSD interface Sony is using? I don't think PCIe Gen.4 qualifies as "not available on PC"


They didn't mean "not available on PC" as in a proprietary standard. They just meant that in regards to commercial consumer drives hitting their internal numbers for drive testing. It's still PCIe 4.0, they could technically get 6 GB/s with three lanes effectively.

The question would be what kind of drive they go with to accomplish that which is economical; if the PCB leak is true, then they might be doing a custom 3D NAND soldering to the board, which is what some of us figured would be the case, emulating AMD's SSG card line. And they might still have a second M.2 slot for user-optional SSDs.

As for Sony going with an exotic solution, really there isn't anything they could create that probably doesn't already exist in some form. There are rival interconnect standards such as Rapid IO, which offer more bandwidth per lane than PCIe 4.0 (3.125 GB/s vs. 2 GB/s), but Rapid IO is usually seen in data centers, telecommunication systems and military equipment. It also facilitates chip-to-chip connections where connections on both ends can be seen as master devices, unlike PCIe where one end is seen as the master device and the connecting device is seen as the slave device, such as a GPU card.

But I don't think that'd be required for a game console to get sufficient big drive speed. PCIe 4.0 is already supported by default in AMD processors, and if they went with something like Rapid IO they'd need a PCIe switch to offer compatibility with PCIe-based drives and peripherals, which have an overhead cost/penalty. Basically it'd be esoteric for the sake of being esoteric, not for practicality.
 
Last edited:

Dolodolo

Member
He has given thorough descriptions on videos of upcoming games that should be at the reveal.

Do you even know what you're talking about?
Techland is not just a developer
What Techland ?
Stop believing people like Tommy Fischer who don't know anything at all, or like Osiris who doesn't know anything about the console launch line
Otherwise, it could say about most specific games, which it doesn't
Stop turning this forum into a circus
I'm not you, sorry
Mixed up the comment
 
Last edited:
Mark Cerny said the tech they're using is not available on PC. What's the consensus on what kind of SSD interface Sony is using? I don't think PCIe Gen.4 qualifies as "not available on PC"

Wired Article:
"At the moment, Sony won’t cop to exact details about the SSD—who makes it, whether it utilizes the new PCIe 4.0 standard—but Cerny claims that it has a raw bandwidth higher than any SSD available for PCs."

PCIe4 was not available on PC at the time of the interview.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TLZ

CJY

Banned
amd has been putting a lot into chiplet research because being able to use multiple chips as if they were one chip is the best way to keep pushing power as we edge closer to the end of die shrinks.

Actually, chiplets have nothing to do with pushing more power as we reach the physical limitations of silicon.

It's an economic measure to keep the die size small, in order to increase yields on a wafer, thus keeping cost down, therefore allowing viable products to actually enter the market at a reasonable cost.

Look at the new 64-core Threadripper. That has 8 x 8-core chiplets. Imagine all those cores on a single monolithic die. If a single core fails upon testing, you'd end up wasting huge amounts of silicon wafer.
 

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
While I appreciate OsirisBlack OsirisBlack 's posts, I am totally confused as to why he/she roleplays as The Riddler
its bizarre and annoying. if you've got something to say, say it. if you cant leak something because it will compromise your sources, keep silent. respect your audience, and their time.

Mod of War Mod of War what do you of OsirisBlack's riddles? shouldnt he just tell us what he knows. i mean he listed the entire description of the demo he supposedly saw, and yet he cant name the game to protect his sources? surely thats a load of bullshit. he's playing the thread and its getting annoying.
 

joe_zazen

Member
Actually, chiplets have nothing to do with pushing more power as we reach the physical limitations of silicon.

It's an economic measure to keep the die size small, in order to increase yields on a wafer, thus keeping cost down, therefore allowing viable products to actually enter the market at a reasonable cost.

Look at the new 64-core Threadripper. That has 8 x 8-core chiplets. Imagine all those cores on a single monolithic die. If a single core fails upon testing, you'd end up wasting huge amounts of silicon wafer.

sure, it makes things cheaper, but why wouldnt it allow for more powerful products?
 
Last edited:

joe_zazen

Member
its bizarre and annoying. if you've got something to say, say it. if you cant leak something because it will compromise your sources, keep silent. respect your audience, and their time.

Mod of War Mod of War what do you of OsirisBlack's riddles? shouldnt he just tell us what he knows. i mean he listed the entire description of the demo he supposedly saw, and yet he cant name the game to protect his sources? surely thats a load of bullshit. he's playing the thread and its getting annoying.

naw, it is more fun this way. We’ll know soon enough. 10 months will be gone before we know it.
 

CJY

Banned
its bizarre and annoying. if you've got something to say, say it. if you cant leak something because it will compromise your sources, keep silent. respect your audience, and their time.

Mod of War Mod of War what do you of OsirisBlack's riddles? shouldnt he just tell us what he knows. i mean he listed the entire description of the demo he supposedly saw, and yet he cant name the game to protect his sources? surely thats a load of bullshit. he's playing the thread and its getting annoying.
Best thing he could do is hand off his info to CBOAT. CBOAT spoke in riddles and garbled rubbish at times, but it got the point across much of the time,
 

ANIMAL1975

Member
It is basically Phison repliying a email saying they did not received any order from Sony PS5 like a rumor article said in the past.

Google translated.
"The company has not received an order for Sony PS5. The media reports are market rumors. Investors are advised to refer to it carefully. For company news, please use the public information observation station announcements."
Lol, i should have known better being wrightiswr**g, it's the second time i fall for it 😅😅😅😅 the first i checked the link he provided and spotted the bull, this time i didn't and fallen in the rabbit hole
 

HeisenbergFX4

Gold Member
I love OsirisBlack OsirisBlack contributions here.

Its all in fun with juicy info actually in there.

Thing is, imo, he puts a lot of thought in these riddles to make them very easy yet people way over analyze them.

It will all be over soon.

A little informal poll.

How upset will the natives be if we only get a State of Play showing the PS5 box with a few game demos here in Feb then a full reveal closer to E3?
 

CJY

Banned
sure, it makes things cheaper, but why wouldnt it allow for more powerful products? Could you even fit 8x8 on a single chip @7nm?
Yeah, why not? Node size has nothing to do with die size. The same 64-core threadripper at 7nm in a monolithic die would probably cost over $10k+ due to the amount of failures. Those failed chips could be binned and sold as 60-core, 58-core, 54-core processors etc., but they'd just end up being Intel in that case.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom